I found myself in the living room, sitting in a chair, covering my dick with my hands. I was at the mercy of two incredibly attractive girls, who would decide if I get to have my clothes back or not. Kelsey stood off to the side, trying to be as supportive as she could. The other girls sat on the couch across from me. They had already dried off from the pool and put their clothes back on. Kate stared at me with her arms crossed and a huge smirk of satisfaction across her face. Carly just stared down at my crotch, as if trying to see through my hands. I shifted uncomfortably.
"So..." Kate started. "We'll give you your clothes back if you do a few things for us first. Three things. Think of it as earning your clothes back."
"Okay... What do you want?" I asked nervously.
"First, well..." Kate tried to finish her sentence but started giggling.
"Show us your DICK!" Carly exclaimed. The girls laughed together. Even Kelsey giggled a little. I looked back at Kelsey pleadingly, but she only shrugged.
"Just get it over with," Kelsey decided apologetically.
"Okay...Fine. You win," I said submissively. At first I couldn't move. But then finally, after ten seconds of anxious tension, I removed my hands and placed them on the armrests beside me. My penis was on full display for Carly and Kate, unfortunately pretty flaccid. The girls giggled. My face turned hot red.
"You were exaggerating Kelsey!" Kate laughed.
"He's a grower, not a shower!" Kelsey tried to defend me, but it only made me feel more embarrassed.
"Okay, now for the more serious part: Questions," Carly announced. I was mortified, what could be next?
"This 'jerk off folder' that you have... Are we in it, too?" Carly asked. All eyes were on me, the room went silent. Even Kelsey was looking at me for an answer.
"Well... yeah...both of you are," I admitted embarrassedly.
Carly clapped her hands triumphantly like she won a bet. Kate blushed, a little embarrassed by the news. Kelsey actually looked a little hurt.
"They're in it, too? Really?" Kelsey asked, trying to hide her disappointment.
"They're in some of the photos. You're in all of them," I told her. She still seemed a little shocked, but at least a bit more consoled.
"I can't believe he masturbates to us, too!" Kate giggled nervously.
"Probably from our beach trip. Bet you're happy we took all those photos," Carly teased. "I was probably wearing the same bikini." Carly lifted her shirt, revealing her black bikini bra from earlier. I could see her boob cleavage and her slim stomach. I couldn't believe myself. My erection was starting to grow in front of them!
"Oh my gosh! He's getting a semi from just that!" Carly said, pointing at my dick. The girls started to laugh hysterically.
"Alright, you had your fun humiliating me. Can I have my clothes back now and can go home?" I complained.
"Aww, don't be like that. This was just getting good," Kate teased in a fake sad voice.
"Yeah, and we said three things," Carly decided. "Last order: I want to see you jack off in front of us."
"What?! No way!" I immediately protested.
"Why? It's only fair. You jack off to us, too. We should get some compensation. Kelsey did. I can still see some of your cum on her panties," Carly argued. Kelsey blushed, looking down at her slender legs.
"I should probably get some pants..." Kelsey murmured.
"Look, I'm sorry, I don't think I can do it. It's too weird--" I confessed.
"Bullshit, if you made a 'jerk off folder' of us, then what's the difference?" Kate pressed on.
"Wait. It's okay, Kate. I got this. We'll just have to make him want to," Carly decided, teasingly. She got up and left the room. The rest of us just exchanged glances, a little confused. Moments later, Carly returned with a bottle of lotion and placed it on the table beside me.
"In case you need it," Carly whispered with a smirk. She looked over to Kate and pointed at the coffee table in front of me. "Get up here!"
Kate looked confused but then immediately understood. She stood up on the table like a stripper. Kate started to sway her hips back and forth while feeling up the sides of her smooth body. Kate slowly pulled off her tank top, revealing her red bikini top underneath. She groped her breasts with her hands and let out a teasing moan. Kate looked down at me and giggled. My erection had started to raise itself up. Carly unbuttoned Kate's shorts and tried to pull them down. The string of Kate's bikini bottoms wouldn't detach from the seam of her shorts. Struggling, Carly gave the shorts a final yank down, untying Kate's bottoms in the process. Her unshaved pussy was on full display in front of me.
"Huh, I didn't know you were shaved down there," Kelsey observed.
Taking a second to realize, Kate looked down and finally realized she was naked from the waist down. She yelped embarrassedly and cupped her pussy with her hands. My dick twitched with arousal. Carly laughed, noticing every detail.
"Oh come on, girl! It's working. Show him that pussy!" Carly yelled.
"No!" Kate protested embarrassedly. She removed one hand, trying to lift her shorts back up. Her pussy was covered, but I could still gaze at the full shape of her breathtaking lower body.
"Fine. At least I know what really turns him on," Carly said. She walked over to me while pulling off her shirt. She stopped directly in front of me, and dropped her shorts to the ground. Her tight black bikini bottoms were directly in front of me. I could kiss them. Carly laughed at how mesmerized I was and then mounted me. In a cowgirl position, Carly gyrated on top of me, her bottoms just barely sliding against my now fully hard erection. I couldn't help but moan.
"Now that's a better sized cock," Carly smirked.
