the-first-temptation-of-sister-mary
NON CONSENT STORIES

The First Temptation Of Sister Mary

The First Temptation Of Sister Mary

by spiderboi
19 min read
4.71 (11100 views)
adultfiction

***AUTHOR'S NOTE***

This work features themes of fictional rough, reluctant, dubiously consensual, or non-consensual sexual scenarios. All characters are 18 years or older.

Also, I haven't been to Mass since I was like ten, so I definitely took some liberties. If you're catholic, sorry about anything I get wrong as it pertains to that lol

✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞

What was an incubus if not a hedonist? A demonic hedonist, but a hedonist nonetheless. Kain's pleasures were simple. He loved nothing more than to bite into ripe, holy fruit that no one had ever plucked. It had the sweetest flavor he'd ever tasted in his extensive life.

And once upon a time, the world had been full of his favorite treat in every variety he could imagine--a devoted nun, a modest brother, a chaste priest. The human world was an orchard of fine, aged, unspoiled apples that he could devour if he played his games right.

But how things had changed. And in so short a time. Kain's brothers and sisters were fat and happy with the new norm. Humans freely inundated themselves with sex and sin all over the world. They gorged on it and were feasted on in turn.

But to Kain, the taste was sour. Yes, he could still find unspoiled virgins, but they were so often lacking in the life experience and resistance that he enjoyed. Humans simply started fucking so young nowadays. Of course, their virginity had to be a choice to make the tang right.

And forget about that rich flavor from one wholly devoted to God. Devotion so pure and consuming that breaking it twisted their souls into something addictive to conquer. Faith like that was rare in the modern age, though.

It'd been decades since Kain encountered a human who met all three of his criteria. Decades since he'd satisfied his cravings. He'd all but given up.

His current prey was a man who met two of Kain's standards. He'd be a decent enough meal, but Kain wasn't sure he was worth binding. Father Luca, as he liked to be called, was young for his newly elected position of abbot, but that's what nepotism can do, even in a monastery. He'd just barely turned thirty before his great uncle retired, and the few remaining monks of Our Lady of Sorrow's Abbey unanimously chose the fresh-faced priest who had served as a transitional deacon a couple years prior as his replacement.

Father Luca hit the age marker and even had the sweet scent of a virgin, like Kain preferred, though his was subtle. Unfortunately, his aura stank of suppressed lust, clouding the radiant holy energy that should encompass those committed to their faith. He'd break in hours of Kain's game starting. Hell, if Kain never intervened, the man was bound to break on his own someday. Maybe he'd seduce a congregant or save his meager pittance to rape a prostitute, but he'd inevitably succumb.

He may as well give his soul to Kain, the demon figured. There were worse fates for a human than to become an incubi's plaything. Kain would have Father Luca's soul for all eternity, but Father Luca would have a long life of being worn by Kain on and off like a comfortable coat, experiencing pleasures of which he'd never even dreamed. He could commit all kinds of delicious perversions with an abbot's body, admittedly. But the lack of a prospective challenge and an airy and flavorless-tasting holy aura were detractors for Kain.

It was Father Luca's first day at the abbey. He had already unpacked his meager belongings and was enjoying the quaint, one-bedroom lodgings that were now his and his alone before he went to track down the resident brothers and sisters. They were taking their breakfast in the refectory, the simple fare expected of those in their positions.

To Kain, the stink of stale sins and vices clung to the elderly monks and nuns at the long table. Not one of them had respected their vows of chastity, and their auras were murky and streaked by past transgressions. Not uncommon, but Kain had expected at least one of them to have made decent prey. It would have been fun to tempt an elderly brother who had remained pure to lust.

"Oh? I never had a chance to meet Sister Mary," Father Luca said to Sister Ida, the oldest nun at the abbey. Kain could see from the other's thoughts that he remembered tell of a younger nun who did most of the more taxing chores.

"This is usually Sister Mary's duty," was a common refrain he'd heard. Father Luca was excited that there was someone younger to help him revive the flailing abbey. It was no secret that recruiting young blood into the Church was harder than ever, but he was sure he could do great things with just a bit of help.

Kain grinned, knowing that any of the abbot's aspirations would be distant memories in a short time.

"She's either tending to the animals or the gardens at this time of the day," Sister Eunice piped up. Father Luca excused himself to track down the mysterious final member of his order. Kain was bored with the whole affair. This nun was bound to be as disappointing as the last ones.

Or so he'd thought.

He smelled her before he saw her. That honey-sweet scent of a virgin was strong and mature. When he did lay eyes on her, Kain could practically feel his mouth watering and his cock hardening. He hadn't witnessed such a pure, divine aura since the advent of modern technology.

Father Luca couldn't see her aura or smell her virginal sweetness. But he could see a beautiful woman in her mid-thirties. She'd removed her veil while working the land, so her long, auburn hair hung loose, and she'd tied her tunic in a knot at her hips as the heat had risen, revealing her shapely legs.

When she turned at the father's approach, she revealed over-large blue eyes and a smattering of freckles over her nose and cheeks that gave her face an innocent appearance to match her spirit. Her full lips split into a welcoming smile until she realized her tunic was still tied up and showing off her legs, and her veil was missing.

"I apologize, Father," she said, righting her appearance. "I wasn't expecting anyone to come visit me at my work." Not even a habit could hide her curvaceous hips, though her small breasts only left the barest impression. Father Luca swallowed the lump in his throat, attraction hitting him like a freight train.

He was distracted and just barely caught what Sister Mary was saying. "I'm so glad to have a proper abbot back. None of the brothers are priests, so there's been no one to hear my confession since Father Matthews--er, the other Father Matthews--"

"Please, call me Father Luca," he interrupted her. "Father Matthews was my uncle... obviously," he laughed at his own weak humor. "And I'd be happy to hear your confession! I'm free now if your work is done?"

"Perfect! Just let me put my tools away." She turned and bent over at the waist to gather her things, completely unaware of the way her tunic clung to her generous ass. Father Luca tried to look away, but found his eyes pulled back.

Kain didn't need his prey to feel lust to take over their body, but it did make the possession quick and seamless. Though Father Luca didn't belong to him, meaning if he tried to make him do anything truly depraved, the priest was like to cast him out. So, nothing too extreme yet.

πŸ“– Related Non Consent Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

One moment, Father Luca was fighting the urge to stare at the fat rump in front of him; the next, Kain was in control and staring without shame. The best part was that Sister Mary was so naΓ―ve that she thought nothing of his fixed gaze when she stood and faced him. It would never occur to her that the father had been ogling her.

They walked together to the abbey church, where the confessional booth was located, making small talk about the many chores of Sister Mary. Kain could tell before they even reached the wooden booth what her confession was like to be.

Blocked from seeing her physically in the confessional, Kain could still smell her and see the glow of her aura through the cracks in the lattice. He found himself wishing he'd seduced Father Luca a month ago. Then he could wear his body and rape the nun right that moment. Surprise her by joining her side of the confessional, trapping her in that small spot, and forcing the abbot's hard cock inside her, stealing both their virginities.

Father Luca's body was responding to Kain's fantasy. Luckily, he wore a black suit with a clerical collar when he wasn't giving a service. Otherwise, it would be difficult for Kain to free the respectable, circumcised cock he sported, just over five inches.

It gave him a perverse pleasure to tease and touch the veiny, virgin member as Sister Mary started baring her soul through the partition. "Bless me, Father, for I have sinned. It's been three weeks since my last confession. These are my sins... I have resented my fellows in the order," she said predictably. She went on to complain that she was often the only one to clean, cook, tend the animals, garden, and so on. The guilt in her voice was apparent. "I'm sorry for these sins and all the sins I cannot remember. Please, Father, is there any advice you can offer?" She asked plaintively.

Kain thought carefully. "Resentment is a serious sin, Sister. But to resent your brothers and sisters in the order, especially so. Resentment leads to anger, which impedes our ability to freely love each other, as God intended. Have you thought about the source of this feeling?"

"It's just... I do so much, Father," she started. "It feels overwhelming sometimes. I get so... all the chores--"

"You're reiterating defenses for your sinful feelings, naughty girl," Kain interrupted. He tugged at Father Luca's dick just enough to keep it hard. "Is it your habit to indulge your sins, perhaps?"

"Not at all, Father," she countered genuinely, none-the-wiser to the abbot's masturbation. "I would rid myself of this feeling if I could, but it's just grown lately. Especially after Sister Eunice stepped back from helping with Sunday School--"

He cut her off again. "Excuses and more defenses. Sister, you don't seem to be taking confession very seriously. Do you want to live in resentment of your order?" Kain could see her shiny aura flicker with indignation at the suggestion through the cracks in the grille.

"I don't, Father," she replied tightly. Kain was sure she'd never had such a combative confessional before. But from Luca's memories, he knew from hearing about her that Sister Mary had only ever served at Our Lady of Sorrows Abbey under his uncle since she was an 18-year-old initiate. So, her frame of reference was limited to one other abbot. It gave Kain a delicious idea. His movements on Father Luca's cock sped up.

"Then we need to determine the source of your resentment. The feeling at the center. What would you call it?" The demon asked in a leading manner.

"I think I'm, well, I'd call it frustrated, I suppose."

"That's good! Frustration is the lesser feeling that leads to resentment, so it's what we should counter."

"Counter the feeling, Father?"

"That's right. And you're lucky. I'm uniquely qualified to help you deal with your frustration. Just like I counseled my great uncle," he finished with a slight grunt, enjoying the feeling of precum beading at the tip of Father Luca's rod.

"Father Matthews?" Her voice sounded hopeful. No doubt it made her feel comfort to think her abbot would have dealt with similar emotions.

"Oh yes, he was constantly frustrated. On the daily. In ways that drove him positively mad."

"I had no idea!"

"Yes, frustration caused by being pent up is a slippery slope to sin. Father Matthews fretted about it constantly."

Sister Mary didn't understand. Confusion spotted her aura. "Sorry, pent up?"

Kain couldn't help but grin to himself. "There was this young woman. A sexy little nun who appeared when she was on the cusp of womanhood. She tempted him with her big eyes and wide hips. The way she sauntered about the abbey drove him wild." Shocked silence from the other side of the partition. He could feel her aura recoil as Sister Mary realized what he was saying. Of course, it was a mix of lies and half-truths, but she didn't know that.

"F-father, I don't think--"

"This same nun is trying to test me, I think. She showed me her bare legs in the garden earlier, then presented her ass to me like it was nothing. Those were the same ways she'd tease my uncle... I certainly know what Father Matthews meant when he talked about grabbing her by those giant hips and raping her tight pussy until she begged for more."

"Father Luca!" she gasped and jolted to her feet. Kain kept his hand jerking Father Luca's cock. He thought about ripping the lattice down and showing her, but that would be a big enough shock for the father that he would push Kain out.

Corrupting them both would take more prodding, but he was sewing the seeds with his indecency. Sister Mary's aura wavered with uncertainty and outrage. She wanted to leave, but a need for absolution was keeping her in place. And it was surely a great surprise to know her priest had viewed her in such a way.

"Father Matthews chose the mortal sin of self-defilement to avoid the mortal sin of rape. Do you know why?"

"If you'd just... give me my penance, Father Luca..."

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

"Your penance is knowledge, Sister. The knowledge of how you've spent the last seventeen years condemning a good man to sin with your wicked body," Kain grunted louder this time, hoping she might at least instinctually know that he was getting up to something dirty. "I want you to think about how many times he had to tug his poor cock raw to keep you safe. How many times did he cast himself into the fiery pit imagining himself plunging into your virgin cunt?"

Fight, flight, friend, freeze, and fawn. Those were the fear responses Kain had learned about while playing with humans all these centuries. And Sister Mary was frozen to the spot, her holy aura shivering and whirling with confused emotions.

"Go in peace," Kain said through Luca. He'd skipped granting her absolution, but the nun was in such a disturbed state she didn't notice.

"Thanks be to God," she squeaked out. Then she was gone, fleeing the church and leaving Kain to quickly store Father Luca's leaking rod back in his pants without cumming.

He dispossessed the abbot, letting Father Luca return to his faculties in time to hear the nun's quick retreat and grow confused and uncomfortable with the bulge in his pants.

✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞✞

Through the remainder of her day, Sister Mary avoided Father Luca, as well as her brothers and sisters of the order, who had nothing but positive things to say about the man.

Confusion plagued her mind. The vile words he'd said to her... never in her life had she heard such things! Much less from a man of the cloth. And what he'd said about Father Matthews? Absolutely reprehensible. He'd been more than a mentor to her. He'd been like a father to Sister Mary.

As she fixated on her disturbed thoughts, her chores went by in a blur, and before she knew it, she was doing her nightly routine.

She showered and dressed in her nightgown quickly, feeling strange about her bare body after... well, she just felt uncomfortable looking at her naked flesh, was all. She even felt like the fabric of her gown could be a little thicker. She'd had the garment so long it was thin and clung to her small breasts and flaring hips.

It was chilly that night, the days shortening as autumn drew near, and there was no central heating or cooling in the nuns' dormitory. Instead, they relied on the heat from a wood-burning stove in the basement during the winter. Sister Mary shut her window, blocking out the evening breeze. Her nipples hardened at the residual touch of cold air.

The dormitory had once been full of like-minded women. They were mostly a great deal older than Sister Mary, but they had been lovely company. Over the years, she'd lost so many sisters. Most to natural causes--age would come for us all one day--but some few were lost to the secular world, typically those who had been closer in age to Sister Mary. Our Lady of Sorrows had the bare minimum to keep it running. It could barely be called an abbey anymore.

She'd hoped Father Luca would be just what was needed to get new blood inspired to enter the order and ease her burdens somewhat, but after what happened earlier in the day... Sister Mary shook herself.

Despite herself, she felt a certain sense of self-doubt. Had she really been a temptation that had caused Father Matthews to stray? Had she been thoughtless with how she'd behaved around men? She'd never been censured in that regard. Surely, someone would have pointed it out to her in her years of service.

But if Father Matthews had those thoughts, and it was the abbot's responsibility to dispense discipline where necessary, was it possible he couldn't bring himself to tell her the truth and shame her, so he let her go on in blissful ignorance?

Did Father Luca resent her for leading his great uncle to sin? He'd sounded so strange while he spoke his debauchery. His voice was thick with an emotion she didn't recognize. Did he hate her intensely, and that's why he'd been so terrible?

She prayed on it for an hour at least before falling into a deep sleep.

Her dreams were strange and vivid. She was walking through the woods surrounding the abbey, wearing her full habit and clutching the only source of light in the darkness, her rosary. She was reciting her Hail Marys. It was so cold she could see her breath. Strange for a late summer night.

Somewhere out in the dark woods, Sister Mary heard a twig snap and came to a halt. She cast her gaze into the darkness, but saw nothing.

She sensed something, though. Could feel something strange in the atmosphere, something unnatural. Almost like the air was flexing.

"... he talked about grabbing her by those giant hips and raping her tight pussy until she begged for more." Father Luca's voice came from behind her, almost directly in her ear. She whirled around, but saw nothing, just more darkness.

Something was behind her again. She could feel a physical presence this time, daunting compared to her small form. Still holding the glowing rosary tightly, bringing it close to her face as she felt phantom hands caress her rear and legs through her habit, Sister Mary felt an unfamiliar warmth rush to her face.

"H-hail, Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee," she said in a stuttering voice as those invisible hands traveled up to caress her belly and then cup her breasts. She gasped as she felt fingers pinch and tease her nipples through her tunic.

"Blessed art thou amongst women," she continued stubbornly, her legs frozen in place, shaking uncontrollably, but still holding her aloft. A pressure between her shoulder blades forced her to bend at the hips. Her breath came faster, but she was still unable to run away, frozen by fear. Whatever it was slid her tunic up, revealing her legs slowly, caressing them with barely-there touches until her panty-covered rump was revealed.

Sister Mary was in the middle of the woods, bent over, with her underwear on display while something touched her thighs and breasts with terrible persistence, making her tremble. Then, a new feeling in her nether region made her jump. It didn't feel like hands. It felt wet and warm and wiggled against her underwear, up and down her vulva.

"And blessed is the fruit of thy womb--ah! Jesus!" Sister Mary cried out as something struck her buttcheek with a loud crack! Another slap, and another in the same place. Heat rose in the abused spot until tears formed in her eyes.

She prayed as the wriggling heat caressed her covered sex, and what seemed numerous phantom hands touched her breasts, thighs, belly, and slapped her rear.

"Hoooly Mary," she stifled a strange noise trying to escape her. "Mother of God, pray for us sinners... " she trailed off in a whimper as her white cotton underwear was pushed to the side, exposing her.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like