"What kind of question is that?"
"I think Jennifer is prettier," Scott said "But Lucy is sexier. You would never guess such a sweet-looking girl is so freaky."
"I don't know. I stopped guessing a long time ago."
"You know what would be interesting? To have them both at the same time."
"No!" I said ... maybe a little too quickly and emphatically.
"Whoa, settle down." Scott said "I'm sorry, I forgot how emotionally attached you are to her."
"Fuck you!" I laughed.
"I mean seriously Dave, emotionally speaking, you are as much a slave to her as she is to you. Maybe even more so."
"What?!"
"Yep. That's the difference between you and me. You are so deeply into her, that you couldn't bear the thought of losing her, even for one night" He said. "While I, on the other hand have complete control over Lucy, sexually and emotionally."
"Dude, That is complete bullshit."
"Okay", Scott said calmly, "then let me borrow her for a night."
"Fuck no! Why don't YOU let me have Lucy for a night?"
"Lucy is too much for you. And she is way too much for Jennifer."
"Too much?"
"Lucy is, shall we say, complex."
"Complex?"
"She switches you know. A bisexual switch. She literally does it all."
"So?"
"So you have to really understand her to dominate her, and you don't even truly understand your own sub."
"What the fuck? I totally understand Jennifer. Dude, YOU are the one who is new at this."
"Okay imagine this: We make the two of them make love. You and I would just sit back and watch. If we made the two of them make love for our entertainment, without any instructions, then who would dominate whom?
"Lucy would dominate Jennifer. She has already started."
"You think so?"
"Absolutely."
"I think Jennifer would dominate Lucy."
"No chance. Lucy switches. Jennifer never has. Not even close."
"Lucy only dominated Jennifer because I told her to. If she is left to her own devices, she is a natural sub. But more importantly, she has more experience, so she would have discipline and restraint. Jennifer can't even keep her pants from getting wet at fucking Denny's"
"That's because we were making her talk. It embarrassed her, and that's what turned her on."
"My point is that, faced with arousal, regardless of how it occurred, she couldn't control herself."
"So?"
"So Jennifer would lose control first, and eventually dominate Lucy out of frustration. Lucy knows that she will, and she can just wait it out until she gets what she wants. And what she wants is Jennifer to dominate her." Scott fiddled with his napkin. "And If I know Lucy, which I do, she will be soft and sensual. Eventually Jennifer would get so excited she wouldn't be able to contain herself. She would push Lucy's head down between her legs, grasping Lucy's hair with both hands and grinding her pussy into Lucy'smouth. She would make Lucy lick her clit until she cums."
"There is no way Jennifer would do that." I said.
"She would." Scott sounded self-assured. "What I am saying here is that you don't really understand your sub. If the two of them made love on my living room floor in front of us, then Lucy would assume the submissive role."
"No fucking way. No way."
"Now it might be subtle, and I concede that it will probably take a while" Scott said, looking away, "but I will bet you anything, Jennifer dominates, Lucy licks pussy first, and Jennifer cums first."
"No WAY!" I laughed, "Look, Jennifer will do JUST as she is told, and nothing more. I don't care if it takes all night. She will only kiss Lucy, if Lucy kisses her first."
I took a drink of water. "In fact, she is not going to hug, kiss, caress or do anything unless she is explicitly told to do so. She will lie there like a dead fish unless she is specifically ordered to do something different. No way in HELL she would make someone lick HER pussy. Jennifer NEEDS to be commanded. Lucy would definitely cum first. Hell, Jennifer might not even cum at all."
Scott looked at me with an eyebrow raised, "You wanna bet?"
"Fuck, not another bet."
"This one is simple. I say Jennifer will assume the dominant role. If I am wrong, then Lucy assumes the dominant role, and she makes Jennifer lick her pussy first, and Lucy cums first; then you are right and you win." He paused. "But if Jennifer makes Lucy lick first, then I win."
Easy money. "What are we betting then?"
"A three-way." He said. "You win, Lucy goes home with the two of you. If I win, then Jennifer spends the night at my place. Sex only. Nothing crazy."
"Ha! You got a bet."
As we shook hands I laughed to myself. There was no way Jennifer would dominate another person.
"And of course," Scott added. "No additional instructions from either of us."
"Of course."
"And if neither of them licks the other's pussy, then the bet is off."
"Absolutely."
"Absolutely what?" Lucy asked as she and Jennifer returned to the table. Jennifer looked flushed, but the wet spot was gone.
"Absolutely nothing" Scott said, picking up the check and standing up, "Let's go back to my place."
β¦ β¦ β¦ β¦
Scott flipped on the lights to his downtown apartment as we entered. He tossed his keys on the table and turned to address the girls.
"All right you two" he said. "Move that coffee table out of the way and stand in the center of that rug."
Jennifer looked surprised, maybe a little stunned. Lucy smiled wryly and said "Yes, Sir" with an emphasis on 'Sir' as if she knew what was about to happen. She bent to lift one end of the coffee table as she motioned for Jennifer to take the other end.
I sat on one couch; Scott sat on the loveseat facing me. The large Persian-looking rug was on the floor between us. I admired Lucy's body as she bent over to lift the table. She had a nice petite Asian body, with just a hint of curvy musculature. I began to get a little hard thinking about how I would soon see her naked.
Jennifer looked more troubled than confused at that point. She and Lucy moved the table and returned to the rug between us. They were a little unsure whom they should face. "Okay." Scott clapped his hands once and leaned forward. The girls turned to face him. "Now the two of you are going to put on a little show for us."
The girls froze.
"I want the two of you to make love." He said, smiling. "Right here, Right now, right on this rug."
Lucy turned slightly and looked at Jennifer. Jennifer turned and looked at me. I saw horror in Jennifer's face. I knew she had never been with another woman in this way. She had been masturbated by Monique as she lay on the table during the football game, but this was different. This time she was going to have to participate.
Her facial expression changed from shock to a desperate imploring. She was begging me with her eyes. She was begging me to not make her do it. I looked at her gravely and nodded once. She knew she was going to have to go through with it.
They faced each other awkwardly like a couple of junior-high kids at their first school dance. They faced each other in their jeans and tight t-shirts. They weren't sure what to do. Finally, Lucy smiled, took Jennifer's chin between her thumb and forefinger, and leaned in to kiss her on the lips.
Jennifer stood frozen. Her lips shut tightly, refusing to return the quick, soft peck of a kiss. Lucy backed away slightly, but kept her hand on Jennifer's chin. Jennifer crossed her arms in front of her chest, as if to protect herself. Lucy smiled broadly and said "Oh you are so CUTE!".
She leaned in again, this time kissing her longer.
Jennifer closed her eyes, not to enjoy the kiss, but to wish this whole scene simply was not actually happening.
Lucy reached up with her other hand and placed her palm on the back of Jennifer's head as she continued to nibble her lips upon Jennifer's frozen, non-reciprocating mouth.
She stopped kissing and gave Jennifer a soft, quick tap on the cheek.
"Kiss me back!" Lucy whispered to her. "Put your arms around me!"
Despite the complete look of disgust on Jennifer's pretty face, she slowly, reluctantly, wrapped her arms around Lucy's slender torso, barely touching her back with her fingertips.
"That's it." Lucy smiled.
She closed her eyes again as Lucy approached and this time the two of them kissed each other.
This elated me. It was a not-so-subtle moment of domination. Just as I had predicted, Lucy was going to dominate Jennifer.
Lucy moved her hand off of Jennifer's chin and wound it around the small of her back. She pulled Jennifer's body closer and pressed her pelvis into her. Jennifer opened her eyes and looked uncomfortable at how tightly Lucy was pressing into her. She broke away from the kiss, a thin line of saliva stretching between the two girls' lips.
Lucy did not slow down. She leaned her head in and sucked on the side of Jennifer's neck, just below her ear. Jennifer gasped and closed her eyes as her hoop earring laid upon Lucy's cheek.
I could see that Lucy was squeezing her tightly. Jennifer looked helpless and paralyzed as Lucy gently gnawed on her neck. But she was starting to resist less and her breath was audible.
It was clear that Jennifer was starting to get turned on by Lucy's kiss.
Lucy started to moan ... or it was more like a hum. She moved her head in little circles as she sucked on Jennifer's neck.
Jennifer opened her eyes again and looked over Lucy's shoulder at me. She had that helpless pathetic expression on her face. It was that expression she would get when she would get humiliated by what was turning her on, while simultaneously being turned on by what was humiliating her. The cycle was starting again and there was nothing she could do about it.