Author's note:
This is a sequel to two of my earliest stories, Megan's Coercion and Using Ashleigh. You can, however, read it stand-alone. Like those stories, this one features themes of reluctance and manipulation. All characters are over the age of eighteen.
Thank you for reading!
------------
"This is going to be so good," the blonde said. Her fine hair tickled her partner's chest as she rode him.
"It already is," he groaned, his hands resting on the young woman's thighs.
This earned a laugh. "You know what I mean, silly." She leaned in, gave him a kiss, then pulled back. "I mean it will be so fun what we'll do with this."
"It will," he agreed, and for several heartbeats, his eyes slid shut. "You're fantasizing about it now, aren't you?"
"A little bit, yeah."
"Because you're dripping wet."
"That's not the only thing making me wet," the young woman replied. She ran her fingers through the man's lush chest hair. "Anyway, you're pretty fucking hard. What are
you
fantasizing about?"
"I don't have to fantasize with you on me, do I? But I'm thinking about it. Thinking she might not be the only one I fuck that day."
"Ohhh, I think we'd like that, too," the blonde said with a sigh.
"Yes we would," said a third person. The one holding the camera.
***
"And in a late flurry of trading, both the NASDAQ and the Dow climbed into positive territory. Whether that rally continues will depend on the jobs report due out tomorrow. We now return you to the-"
Rob flicked off the TV, his ears alert. For a moment he thought he had imagined the sound, but there it was again, a quiet knock on his door. The pair of young women waiting on his porch could hardly have surprised him more.
"Megan," he began carefully, "and Ashleigh. It's so nice to see you."
"Surprised?" Ashleigh asked. Just like the last time he had seen her, three years ago, Ashleigh's glossy hair fell around her shoulders unrestrained.
"It is a surprise," Rob said, still speaking with great care, "but it's good to see you both."
In truth, 'nice' wasn't the first word that leapt to Rob's mind. Had it really been three years since the summer that he had coerced or tricked both of the young women into his bed? It was a cliche that the years slip past ever faster as one ages, but surely those blissful afternoons couldn't be so distant.
"Are you going to invite us in?" Megan asked. Like Ashleigh, McDonnell thought he caught a winking playfulness that he couldn't remember in either of them.
"Of course, of course," he stammered, holding the door open as the two young women breezed past. A fleeting whiff of perfume lingered in their wake.
"Your house is just like I remember," Megan said. "It's airy and open," she added, "not cluttered."
Rob couldn't picture the Megan he remembered saying 'airy and open'. Nor was she the only one to surprise him. Ashleigh let her eyes wander around the living room, landing in turn on an original landscape, a collection of Hopi pottery, and a pair of shadow puppets, elegantly framed.
"Are those from Indonesia?"
Eyes widening with surprise, Rob admitted as much. "That's a very good observation, Ashleigh."
"Thank you," the brunette said with the same ease with which she had slipped into his home. "Art history," she explained. "But I've only studied it. You've been there, right?"
"Five years ago, I think. Shit, no," Rob said, correcting himself, "I think it was more like seven." He would have liked to discuss art history with Ashleigh, but Megan pulled his attention away.
"Sooo," the blonde said, flopping into Rob's favorite chair. "I seem to recall that I owe you a bottle of bourbon."
"I suppose you do." Rob hadn't forgotten that particular element of his encounter with Megan. She had, in the course of a week of house-sitting, downed a fifth of his favorite bourbon. It was that weakness to alcohol, in part, that had allowed him to manipulate her into fucking him.
"I thought maybe this would settle our debt," Megan said, pulling a bottle from her bag.
Rob eyed it. "Shit!" he said. "Is that Dickel's?"
"Bottled in bond," Megan confirmed, handing him the bottle.
"Megan! This is hard to find."
The blonde laughed, easy and musical. "Tell me about it."
"How did you... wait," Rob said, "this isn't your father's, is it?"
Here Megan executed an expert-level eye roll. "Mr. McDonnell, please," she said, "I
do
have some money, you know. I have an internship at Kerner this summer."
"So do I," Ashleigh said. Like Megan, she had settled as comfortably into Rob's home as if she was renting a room there.
"Are you going to open it?" Megan asked.
"It
is
after five." Rob peeled back the foil, tugged the cork free, and poured three modest servings. To his pleasure, both young women sipped -but didn't slam- the whiskey. As they shared the simple moment, Rob's eyes swept over his guests. Both had morphed subtly in the intervening years. Megan, who had been skinny to the point of sharpness, had filled in nicely. Though still slender, her angles were now softened. More a woman, less a girl.
Ashleigh, the voluptuous brunette, had moved in the other direction. Rob remembered her as a soft but ripe young woman with a touch of baby fat to accompany her round breasts and hips. In the intervening years, she had shed some of her softness without losing her curves. Though Rob wouldn't have believed it possible, both of his guests had become even sexier.
"This is nice," Rob said, sipping the whiskey, "but you two didn't come here to repay a three-year-old alcohol debt."
"Alcohol debt," Ashleigh said, laughing. "No, that isn't why we're here."
Rob took a sip and waited for more.
"First," Megan said, "Ashleigh knows."
"Oh?" It only took Rob a few seconds to realize what she meant. Just two weeks after he had coerced Megan into fucking him, he had leveraged her friendship with Ashleigh to lure the brunette into his bed.
"Yyyyep," Ashleigh said. For a moment she fixed Rob with an intense gaze, but she couldn't hold it. "It's cool," she said, laughing. "Seriously. Kinda hot, honestly."
"So, you know Megan watched?"
"Yeah," Ashleigh said, twirling a strand of black hair between her fingers. "She told me."
Rob chuckled. "How did
that
come up in conversation, I wonder."
It was Ashleigh's turn to laugh. "I told her that I slept with you. I thought it was kind of cool, getting with an older guy, plus I thought maybe Megs would be jealous."
"So I told her that I'd
already
fucked you," Megan said. "Aaaand, that maybe I helped set her up."
"Bitch," Ashleigh said, but not without a smile. Neither woman seemed particularly upset.