(Sometimes you don't think to write things down until much later, as is the case with this story. While most of it is fiction, there are some parts that are real. The setting is the late 60's in Iowa.)
Jill, Tina, and Amber were all seniors at Roosevelt High School, having turned 18 in close succession. All three were very popular in their large high school of 2,000 kids. Their popularity standing was enhanced by the fact that all three were cheerleaders. Usually one's perception of a high school cheerleader is that she is not only sexy but an easy fuck. The girls were sexy alright. Jill and Tina had light brown hair tied up in ponytails and Amber had long silky, blond hair halfway down her back. All three had very striking features, something that is a pre-requisite for being a cheerleader. (You gotta have something to provide incentive for the team to win.)
Having looks and popularity to match, the girls had their pick of any guy in the school to go out with. Since they felt like they could get any guy they wanted, when ever they wanted, they basically played the field, never really having a steady boyfriend for any length of time. They would let a guy kiss them but never any further than that. The way they acted and dressed, they sent the clear signal that you can look but you can't touch. As sophisticated as they seemed, all three had never had sex but were always trying to check out guy's bodies. It was this curiosity that would get them into a predicament they weren't prepared for.
It was late in the swimming season and the girls had cheerleading practice early in the morning on Saturdays in preparation for other sports events. Now as most everyone knows, the cheerleaders don't normally do their routines for swimming. They usually just sit in the bleachers to act as moral support. As usual at a swim meet Jill, Tina, and Amber would be in the bleachers to provide the moral support, but they also had an ulterior motive. The swim meets gave them a chance to check out some of the best looking guys in nothing but swimming trunks. With the guys wearing tight trunks for less drag in the water, it was usually pretty evident who had the biggest 'package'.
As the girls sat through a meet, they would whisper back and forth speculations as to the length and girth of each swimmer. It was kind of a game for them. Later the next day, they would relate to their friends who looked the biggest and who looked the smallest. A lot of times, the girls assessment was somewhat cruel. It was not hard to guess that some of this assessment would filter back to the guys on the swim team. For the guys who were well endowed, it was a boost to their ego. For the guys the girls made fun of, it wasn't much of a stretch to say they were pretty pissed at having been dissed by the girls.
It was at one of those Saturday cheerleading practices that the girls decided to check things out a little further. The cheerleading practices would normally take about an hour. The swimming team practice would normally start at about the same time but would last for 2 hours. Today's cheerleading practice concluded early because some of the other girls had places to be and it just didn't work very well for less than half the squad going through the routines. After 10 mutes, practice ended and all but Jill, Tina, and Amber were left. They thought about leaving as well until Tina stopped the other girls. The devilish look in her eye let the other girls know she had something interesting in mind.
Tina knew that during swim team practice the doors to the upper level bleachers and the locker room were locked. A number of girls had heard rumors that during practice, the coach would have the guys swim naked. The excuse was that it was an easy way to check for any obvious signs of VD. For some of the guys it seemed a little odd. At the beginning of each practice, the coach would line all the guys up and the coach would walk past the front of each guy, like a drill sergeant inspecting the troops. After the inspection, the coach would give instructions on what he wanted each swimmer to work on and during the last half hour of practice, how many laps to swim for conditioning. According to some of the guys, the coach was pretty consistent about his routine. Inspect the 'troops', issue the orders, then go back to his office, close the blinds, and take a nap until just before practice ended.
Tina wanted to know if the rumors were true or if it was some tall tale. It wasn't enough that she see for herself, she wanted witnesses to verify her story. That's where Jill and Amber came in.
She told the other girls her plan. First they would look through the crack in the upper doors to make sure all the swim team was assembled; the coach usually never started practice until all were present. When all the guys were present, Tina could use the locker room key she had swiped and made a duplicate of , to go through the locker room door and watch the guys through a crack in the folding screen placed just in front of where the locker room exited out onto the pool area. The plan seemed flawless. All the guys' attention would be locked on the coach and no one would notice the 3 pair of eyes watching them.
The coach was so predictable. By the time Jill, Tina, and Amber had made their way through the locker room to hide behind the screen, the coach was just finishing up his pre-inspection pep talk. As 3 pairs of eyes watched through the crack in the screen, the coach had the guys line up at the edge of the pool, facing the locker room door. The girl's eyes lit up and big smiles appeared on their faces. Just 30 feet in front of them was the well built varsity swim team, each sporting a pretty good 'package'. Most of the guy's cocks were average size, a few were super size and some were less than average.
As the coach started down the line of 12 seniors for his 'inspection', the girls began to make their own notations, scoring each guy as to how good his body was and good his cock looked. For the guys with the above-average size cocks, the girls were whispering to each other as to what it might be like to experience them first hand. For the guys with the less-than-average size, the girls were whispering cruel comments about how maybe these guys needed a pair of tweezers to grab hold of their cock and stifling giggles at the same time.
With the inspection done, the coach gave instructions for what kinds of laps and how many of them to do before walking back to his office. As predictable as ever, he closed the door, closed the blinds, put on head phones to listen to music that sometimes put him to sleep.