Part Two is where things take a turn for the more depraved, degrading, humiliating, and all around fucked up. Anyone that's looking for something more gentle out of a non-consent story, either read Part 1 or look elsewhere.
********************************
The next morning, Mallory and Jacey put each put on a new swimsuit, Jacey's black with bright blue stripes, Mallory's all white, and they made their way down the beach.
It was a bit of a walk, but they were enjoying the cool breeze and the bright sun, giggling and talking.
"No, I mean it, I think Caleb really likes you!" Jacey laughed, pushing Mallory.
"What kind of guy lets his friends fuck the girl he likes?" Mallory snapped, shaking her head, and Jacey shrugged.
"I dunno, it's a beach town, things are different here!" Jacey giggled, bending down and picking up a shell.
She threw it into the water and they kept walking. They passed the main beach, guys staring and old women sneering at them, little kids running around, screaming. There were restaurants and public bathrooms and even a boardwalk, but they kept walking, slowly approaching the small concrete restrooms.
It was immediately clear why the guys chose these bathrooms as a point for meeting up. All the families and little kids stayed near the main beach, but here, there was barely anybody. They'd have the beach and waves all to themselves.
Caleb and Teddy were standing outside of the restrooms, talking with each other and smoking cigarettes, leaning against the wall. They waved as soon as they saw the two girls, and Jacey and Mallory waved back, Jacey skipping forward and planting a hot, wet kiss on Teddy as soon as she'd gotten there.
Caleb waited for Mallory, his arms extended for her embrace, but she approached him, arms crossed, allowing him to put his arm around her but not much else.
"Aw, what? Are you mad at me or something?" Caleb asked, smiling at her.
"Mallory's still sore." Jacey laughed, "She's pretty upset you guys were so rough, you didn't even ask if she wanted to get fucked in every hole!"
Jacey erupted in laughter, and Teddy and Caleb joined her. Mallory frowned and hit Jacey.
"Jacey!" She screamed, and Jacey held her hands up.
"Ok! Ok! I'm sorry, I couldn't help it. Come on, Mallory." But Mallory didn't smile, standing there, glaring.
"Ok, well look," Jacey said, turning to the boys. "We didn't come here for a repeat of yesterday. We're both too sore, I'm even too sore. We just want to surf a little, relax a little, maybe smoke a little weed if you got some."
Caleb and Teddy looked at each other, and they smiled.
"Look, we're pretty worn out too. We just want to hang out and have a nice time today, alright? And yeah, we even have some weed," Caleb said, pulling a cigarette pack out of his pocket, a couple joints in front.
"Fuck yeah!" Jacey laughed, bouncing.
"Ok, cool, well, we gotta smoke it inside the bathroom, the lifeguards drive by in their pick ups all the time, and they're real pricks." Teddy informed them, and Caleb grimaced.
"Fuckin' assholes." He agreed, pushing the door open slightly.
"I dunno," Mallory shrugged. And Jacey glared at her.
"Hey, you can stay out here and keep watch if you want," Caleb laughed, and Jacey sighed deeply.
"No, no, that's ok, I'll come," Mallory relented, and Caleb held the door open for the two of them.
They stepped inside, and no sooner than they'd crossed the threshold, two guys jumped out from behind the door and grabbed them both.
Jacey struggled, kicking and turning a ferocious shade of red, and Mallory quickly broke down, sobbing and trying to hide her face.
Caleb and Teddy stood before them, arms crossed, shaking their heads.
"You girls are some of the stupidest sluts we've ever met," Teddy laughed, and Caleb nodded in agreement.
"This isn't funny!" Jacey shrieked, turning to Mallory and seeing the exhaustion in her face. "Let us go!"
"No, it's pretty funny," Caleb laughed, reaching forward and pulling Mallory's top off, exposing her tits, then turned to Jacey and pulled hers off too.
"Assholes!" Jacey yelled.
"Please! Just let us go!" Mallory moaned, but Teddy shook his head.
"Nah, you girls are gonna make us some serious money," He said, then grabbed Jacey by the throat, pulling her around into his grasp as she squirmed and fought against him.
"Wh-what do you mean?" Mallory whispered, and Caleb grabbed her by her hair, smiling at her as she tried to pull away, then he turned to the two guys that had been hidden behind them.
"Put on the hoods," He told them, pulling Mallory's hands behind her back, and immediately the room went dark, sacks being forced over Mallory and Jacey's heads.
Mallory gave up, feeling her arms being pulled behind her back and bound together, tightly.
"Lock the door, put up the out of order sign, and rallie the troops. Tell them the gloryholes are open, teenage sluts, 50 bucks a pop." Caleb instructed, and Mallory started shivering, not sure of what was awaiting.
"You're sick! You're sick!" Jacey screamed, fighting and pushing, but her restraints kept her arms still, and Teddy just let go of her, letting her fall to the ground.
She gasped, the fall having knocked the wind out of her, and as she regained her breath, she started whimpering and sobbing.
"Just let us go!" She squealed, sobbing on the ground.
"We will, once we've made our money's worth." Caleb laughed, then they he undressed himself and mounted Jacey, forcing his dick up her ass.
Jacey grunted and groaned while Caleb spanked her and pounded her from behind.
"Stop! Please!" She begged, and Caleb obliged.
"God damn it, even her ass is loose!" Caleb laughed, grabbing Mallory and pushing her against a wall.
Mallory felt her bottoms being pulled down, then she was bent over and spanked.
"Please! Ow!" She begged, wincing at every slap. "Please, just let us go!"
Caleb forced his dick inside of her, fucking her roughly, while Teddy dragged Jacey off to one of the bathroom stalls.
"No! No!" Mallory heard her friend crying, her face rubbing against the wall as Caleb fucked her pussy raw.
She kept quiet though, unable to beg anymore, and soon felt her body being dragged through the bathroom. There was a long row of stalls, and they took the last one, large and empty.
Moans and grunts from Jacey echoed through the bathroom, and Mallory felt her legs being pushed open, then being pulled into Caleb's lap.
He pushed his cock inside her, and she squealed and gasped as he forced her to ride him.
"Just like yesterday, right?" Caleb whispered into her ear, and she moaned. He grabbed her ass and pulled her tight, fucking her harder and harder.
Mallory tried to fight it, but her body wasn't hers anymore, it belonged to Caleb. He played with her ass while he fucked her, choked her and slapped her tits, and she finally gave in, letting herself climax.
"Holy shit, this one's coming!" Caleb yelled at Teddy.
"Mine, too!" Teddy laughed, and it went on like that, for some time, being fucked and spanked, slapped, and choked, kept in darkness as they abused and fucked them.
Soon enough, Caleb started groaning, shooting his cum deep inside Mallory's pussy.
He gently set her down on the cold cement, catching his breath. He left the stall and came back with a large bottle of water, chugging and then lifting the hood from Mallory's face.
