Many thanks to jellybelly2 for first editing and improving this story from a previous version.
Special thanks to defiantly_me for further edits and for suggestions that made it much better.
The husbands of Doreen's friends were tired of hearing about Ted. Their wives almost always talked about him when they were driving home from any gathering that included the couple.
The theme was always "Why can't you be more like Ted?" with such variations as "Did you see the way that Ted looked after Doreen?" and "Ted knows how to treat a woman."
The subject of Ted also came up when the girls got together. Her friends marveled at how thoughtful Ted was and how attentive to her and eager to do anything she asked. One time one of them asked whether he was like all the time.
"I wish," said Doreen. "No, he's just the typical thoughtless husband at home, but I don't complain, because the important thing to me is how he treats me when others are around."
Her friends agreed they'd be happy with a similar arrangement, but Doreen was lucky. They could talk until they were blue in the face, but their husbands would never change.
"Luck had nothing to do with Ted being the way he is," said Doreen. "Five years ago, he used to be just like your husbands. I found a way to change him."
The others all wanted to know how, but Doreen said she wouldn't tell them, because each husband was different. What worked for her might not work for them. All she was telling them was there were solutions out there, and if they wanted to go beyond complaining, they would find them.
******************
Five years before she told them this, there was a night that totally exasperated Doreen.
"How could you just stand there when you saw that my boob was about to fall out of my dress?" she asked Ted on the drive home from a party. "I didn't expect you to know that a seam had come apart or what to do, but you could have at least said something to me."
"I'm sorry," said Ted. "I just froze. I know I should have done something or said something, but I felt like a statue."
"You're always freezing," said Doreen. "Whenever I need you to get my back, you turn into a refrigerator. You get cold, and I get humiliated."
"I've always been that way," said Ted. "You can ask my parents. I was the kid watching from the outside. I never jumped into anything."
"But you're a grown man now," said Doreen, "and I know you're a take-charge guy at the office. You wouldn't be doing so well if you just stood on the sidelines."
"Why do you turn into that kid again when we're out together and always just when I need you most. You know how I put myself out to save you any kind of embarrassment. It's automatic for me because you're the man I love. What's wrong with you?"
"I honestly don't know," said Ted. "You're right that I don't hesitate to jump into things at work. I used to be painfully shy and never wanted to attract attention. Maybe I still get like that when it's something personal. I guess it's just the way I am."
"I won't even dignify that answer with a response. All I'll say is I'm getting awful tired of you being the way you are if it means you're out to lunch when I need you the most."
***************
A few weeks later, Doreen and Ted were having a picnic on the beach. It was a freakish, warm Indian summer day. The remote area where they liked to go was nearly deserted. It was cut off from nearby beaches by large rock formations on both sides.
Doreen had discovered the pathway into the area when she was a teenager. In those days, it was a well-known nudist spot during the summer, and she and her girlfriends had made some educational observations there.
Today, they saw no one except for a young couple at the other end that seemed to be busy on their blanket with their mouths and their hands. Doreen and Ted were sitting on their beach chairs watching the surf and chilling with a glass of wine when they heard voices. It was the couple, and they were yelling at each other so loud that the sound carried down to them -- even though the words couldn't be made out.
They looked over and saw one of the two jump up and scream some words at the other one and stomp away toward the water. Then the figure began walking down the beach in their direction. As it got closer, they saw it was a young woman.
"Oh no!" said Doreen. "It's Carina."
"Who?" asked Ted.
"Carina," said Doreen. "She's a student of mine, and she's bad news. I think she's in a girl gang. I had to flunk her, and she came to my room during planning period and threatened me. I reported it to the assistant principal, and she may have been suspended. I hope she doesn't spot me."
But the girl walking by the water noticed the couple, and as soon as she recognized Doreen, she made a beeline for her. Doreen got out of her chair, but Ted didn't.
"Are you here to spy on me, Mrs. Nelson?" were the first words Carina said when she came up to them. "So you can tell Mr. Evans and make more trouble for me."
Doreen noticed she was slurring her words. She and her friend must have been drinking.
"No, Carina," Doreen said, "we're just having a nice picnic, and we didn't even know you were here."
"Sure," said Carina. "You're just minding your own business and not making trouble for anyone, are you, you bitch?" With that, she jumped at Doreen and grabbed her hair and pulled her down into the sand.
"Ted!" yelled Doreen as she went down, and Ted jumped up. He looked down and saw his wife and the girl rolling around in the sand. The girl was slapping Doreen hard on the face and pulling at her bathing suit top. In a second it was off. The girl was much larger than Doreen.
As Ted watched, the girl grabbed Doreen's suit bottom and began pulling it down.
"Ted!" screamed Doreen, but Ted didn't move. He stood as if in a trance.
The girl got the suit off and pulled Doreen over her lap and began spanking her as Doreen screamed and Ted watched. Then she began sticking her fingers between Doreen's legs.
"Ted, goddammit! Get her off of me! She's hurting me. Ted!"
Finally, he seemed to hear her voice and moved to the two women, but he couldn't seem to decide what to do.
"Grab her hair and pull it!" screamed Doreen as she struggled to get free.
Ted reached for the hair but the girl moved her head away. He tried again, but again she ducked. Finally, he grabbed a bunch of hair and pulled back hard. The girl screamed and released Doreen, who jumped up and ran back a few steps.
"Hold her there, Ted!" Doreen yelled. "Don't let go of her whatever you do. When you see I've disappeared from sight on the pathway, you can let her go and bring the rest of the stuff to the car."
Doreen pulled her suit back on and gathered up some of their picnic and began walking toward the path, sobbing loudly as she went. Ted held onto the girl by her hair and felt her swaying but not trying to get free. In a few seconds, he couldn't hear Doreen's sobs over the sound of the surf. When he saw Doreen disappear from sight, he let go of the girl. She ran back to her friend.
Ted collected the rest of their gear and followed Doreen, who was sitting in the car looking straight ahead. She wasn't making a sound, but tears were running down her face.
"I'm sorry, Doreen."
"Shut up, Ted!"
Those were the last words she spoke to him until the following night.
***************
When he came home from work, she was pleasant, and she made small talk through dinner. But once they had cleared the plates, her mood darkened. She motioned for him to sit down at the table.
"Did you know that Carina pushed sand up my vagina and anus?" she said. "No, don't say anything. Did you hear me screaming your name? Why did you just stand there? She could have really hurt me badly. This wasn't just something embarrassing. She was dangerous. Couldn't you tell? Now you can say something."
"I don't know what to say, except how sorry I am," he said. "You are right. I should have jumped in and pulled her away immediately. I'm so ashamed. I've thought about it a hundred times and asked myself why I didn't do anything, but I can't come up with an answer."
"That's exactly what I thought you would say," said Doreen, "but it's not good enough. I asked you to work on this freezing of yours and waited for you to do something, but you never have. Yes, you're always sorry and tell me you love me. So why can't you change?
"I've been thinking about it since yesterday and decided that I can't leave it to you anymore. I need to find out what's holding you back. I have an idea already, but I have to think about it some more. I should be able to tell you in a couple of days. If you come up with anything before that, tell me. I'm willing to try anything."
Two nights later at dinner, she asked him if he had thought of anything, but he said no.
"I think I have the answer," she said, "and it's actually very simple. I don't think you are motivated enough. What do you think of that?"
"I don't know," he said. "I don't think I can love you more than I do already, and I think I've proven that in many ways."
"I know," she said, "and love is a great motivator. Many of the things I do are because of my love for you. But sometimes love doesn't work, and you have to find other motivations.
"Do you really want to change this habit enough that you'll let me help you? Think a moment before you answer. I don't want to be overly dramatic, but after what's happened, I think the future of our marriage depends on what you answer."
"Of course I'll let you help me," he said. "I don't have to think about that for one second, even without your threat. I know something has to be done."
"Okay," she said. "I'm going to work on the motivation idea. I'll let you know when I've come up with something."
Ted did his best to be attentive to Doreen over the next several months. There were a few small incidents, but Ted was quick to notice and apologize before Doreen mentioned them. He was proud of himself for taking this small step in the right direction. Doreen didn't say anything more about motivating him, and he forgot about it.
**************
It was a June morning and already warm. Doreen and Ted had risen early to drive to a national park a couple of hours. Doreen told him she had thoroughly researched the park on the Internet to plan the outing. They arrived at 10 as the park was opening.