Kathryn sat at the kitchen table in her nightgown. The 24-year-old couldn't help but notice Dave's eyes drifting down to where her nipples poked through the thin material. The pretty blonde knew that if her mother was home that she would have had a fit over Kathryn prancing around in her short nightgown in front of her younger sister's 20-year-old boyfriend. But Kathryn's mother was on day 2 of her three-day, 12 hour night shift as a nurse at the hospital. Her father was off in his den, drinking as usual as he watched Sunday night football.
Her sister, Jill, was working as a waitress and wouldn't be home until after midnight. Dave, and his 21-year-old friend, Richard, we're hanging out with Kathryn's brother, Gary. The three of them were playing video games in the living room. Dave was hoping to stay and see Jill when she got home. Kathryn knew why, of course. But those plans changed when Jill had told him over the phone that she was on her period.
Gary and Jill were twins. Gary was friends with both Dave and Richard from college, and he had introduced his 19-year-old sister to Dave about three months ago.
Kathryn was the oldest of the three siblings. She had been adopted when her parents thought they couldn't have kids. But a few years later they were surprised to find out that they were expecting, and with twins.
Kathryn always felt like she didn't belong. Her parents always favored their "real" kids, as she often referred to them. It didn't help that Kathryn had been overly rebellious as a teenager, often getting into trouble and causing stress for her parents. While she was a cute girl, she was somewhat awkward looking during her teen years. Tall and thin, with puffy lips and a thin face. It wasn't until she hit 18 that she began changing, and over the next three years Kathryn had become quite an exotic looking beauty. While still slender, with only firm B-cup breasts, she was considered a very attractive woman.
She had moved back home less than a year ago. Something her dad had opposed, since he had been the one forced to deal with most of the problems she had caused in previous years. Kathryn also knew that he still had issues with catching her giving her cousin a blow job at 18 when they were at a family wedding reception. He kept that secret because he didn't want the rest of the family to know that his adoptive daughter had been sucking her cousin's dick.
Kathryn did regret that incident. But she had been overly promiscuous back then. She was still sexually active, but she had more restraint now, especially since she could be more selective as more men were now interested in her.
But she was interested in Dave. She knew that she shouldn't be; he was Jill's boyfriend after all. But he was a good looking guy, charming, well built. And, according to Jill, Dave had a huge cock. Kathryn thought that her sister might be exaggerating, but Jill claimed that he let her measure it once, at that it was over 10 inches. Kathryn had never experienced anything that big, and she really wanted to try him out in bed. And Kathryn believed she had a way to do it that would keep her from being blamed if it was ever found out.
To gauge his interest, she pretended to drop the pill bottle she was holding onto the floor. She bent over, allowing her low cut top to hang down, giving Dave plenty of time to gaze down and see her exposed tits. She suppressed a grin when she raised up and observed that he was indeed staring at them.
"I better take two of these sleeping pills tonight." She said. She opened the cap and pretended to take out two pills as she went to the refrigerator to get a bottle of water. She mimicked taking them and explained to Dave that she would soon be so out of it that someone would have to carry her out of the house if it caught fire. Kathryn had tried this trick before, and got a friend's boyfriend to fuck her when he thought she was out cold once, so she believed that she could trick Dave the same way.
"I have to be real careful with two pills," she said. "My last boyfriend claimed that he would fuck me when I was out, and if he didn't tell me about it I would never know I had been fucked. He even claimed that I would sort of wake up during it and respond, but I wouldn't remember a damn thing. I hope no one else ever took advantage of me when I took two pills on a trip or somewhere. Shit, if I didn't have my dad and Gary around, one of you could take advantage of me."
Dave didn't know how to respond to that, but Kathryn could tell that she had given him an idea. She just hoped he would follow through. To ad a little more enticement, as she began to get up, Kathryn appeared to accidentally spread her legs apart so as to provide Dave with a view of her now fully exposed, well trimmed, party-less pussy for a few seconds before standing. She quickly excused herself, claiming the pills would put her out soon, so he had to get to bed.
Kathryn went to her room. She left the blinds open so the back porch light would enable her to see Dave well enough, even while pretending to have her eyes closed. She wanted to get a good look at that supposed big cock, after all.
Not long afterwards, she heard Gary in his bedroom next to hers. She knew that if things went according to plan, Richard would leave and Dave would wait on the couch in the living room until Jill came home later. She only hoped that Dave would have the balls to pay her a visit.
Kathryn was restless as she waited. Soon she had her right hand beneath her nightgown, caressing her pussy in anticipation. Then she heard her doorknob turning. She quickly pulled her hand aside and pretended to be asleep. She squinted her eyes, keeping them open just enough to see. She watched as Dave quietly entered the room. Then she was surprised to see Richard follow him. "Shit." She thought, she did not want Richard to be there. He was a rugged looking man with scraggly facial hair, unkempt, slightly long brown hair, and was easily 20-30 pounds overweight. While he was a friendly guy, Kathryn had bo interest in him at all.
"See, she's out cold." Dave whispered. He came closer and slid the sheet off of her. Dave's hands trembled as he took the hem of her nightgown and raised it up to expose her bare pussy.
"Shit, that's nice." Richard whispered. "Let's see those titties."
Dave continued pulling the gown up, until both of Kathryn's firm tits could be seen clearly in the light pouring in through the bedroom window above her head. Dave risked reaching down and fondling her right breast. Kathryn wanted to jump up and order them out, only because of Richard, but she had taken this too far to do that now without risking her deception being discovered and Jill being told what she had done.
"She said that she could be fucked like this and never know it." Dave said.
Richard was unsure of that, "Are you really going to try it?"
"Why the hell not. Look how hot she it. And Jill is on the rag, so I won't get anything from her tonight, accept maybe a handjob. She doesn't suck dick."
