Ian had always thought of himself as a monogamous, heterosexual male who took pride in being a caring, respectful lover. Over the past five days, Ian's girlfriend Lori had been waging a campaign to convince him he could enjoy bisexuality and expanding his horizons to include more than one sexual partner with the objective being to have him accompany her to a campus networking event in three days' time that was really an excuse for a student and alumni orgy. He'd somewhat reluctantly given a friend a blowjob, and now Lori wanted him to try giving and receiving anal sex.
Wednesday, Day 6
During their lunch on Wednesday, Ian reluctantly agreed to try anal sex that afternoon. Lori was excited at the prospect of Ian finally shoving his cock up her ass, which made him feel a little better about that, but he still wasn't sure about having a dildo or a cock up his own ass.
After class, Ian found excuses to talk with professors, to touch base with a project team he was working with, and to take care of a few other odd errands before he admitted to himself he was procrastinating. Steeling himself like a kid who's being made to take some unpleasant medicine, he slogged across the square. Noone would guess he was a man on his way to have sex with a gorgeous woman. He was still in the midst of his internal wrestling match when he knocked on Lori's door.
To Ian's surprise, Elvira opened the door for him. Elvira was a striking woman, tall, dark haired and fair skinned like the TV character she'd been named after. In bare feet as she was then, Ian couldn't quite see over her head. In her signature goth boots, she stood a couple of inches taller than Ian. Her body was full figured and toned thanks to a naturally high metabolism and an incessant restlessness that kept her constantly moving. The only time she was still was when she was working on one of her exquisitely detailed paintings.
Her parents had met at a horror film festival featuring episodes of "Elvira's Movie Macabre." Her mom bore a passing resemblance to Cassandra Peterson, with slightly larger breasts and naturally black hair which she'd passed along to her daughter. Growing up, Elvira had watched the cheesy B movies with her parents and had learned to love them and to love Peterson's goth surfer girl persona. She'd begun emulating it in high school and it had become her signature look.
What really surprised Ian was the fact that Elvira was only wearing a black see-through bra and a seven-inch strap-on dildo. He'd seen her in some skimpy clothes before, but never anything this revealing.
He was intrigued by the intricate ivy-pattern tattoo that circled the bottom of her D-cup tits. He'd seen part of it peeking out of her cleavage, and now, seeing the whole thing for the first time, he saw how it matched the sleeve on her right arm and the tattoo that showed at the base of her spine. He was also intrigued to see the pattern repeated in her pubic area and running down her left leg.
Stepping into the room, he saw that Lori was dressed the same as Elvira, and that Gary was there wearing a basketball shirt and shorts. It was obvious he was going commando under the shorts.
Lori got down to business right away.
"Today's lesson plan is as follows: Elvira is going to fuck my ass so you can see that I really do like it, and that it isn't gross or messy. Gary is going to show you how he cleans himself before anal sex, and he's going to teach you how to clean yourself. You're going to fuck me in the ass, and then one of us is going to fuck you in the ass. You can choose who. Any questions?"
Lori removed the strap-on she'd been wearing and knelt on the bed with her ass towards the futon. Elvira motioned for Ian and Gary to sit where they had a good view.
Ian had suspected that Lori and Elvira may have enjoyed each other sexually, but seeing Elvira move behind Lori and confidently lean down to tongue her ass convinced him he was right. He could see from the way both women acted that this was not the first time Elvira had licked his girlfriend. It raised doubts in the back of his mind about whether Lori had been completely straight with him when she said she was only having sex with him.
In truth, when she and Ian had first started dating Lori and Elvira had been getting together regularly. When Ian made it clear he expected them both to be monogamous, she'd told Elvira they needed to stop, and Elvira had graciously gone along with that.
That didn't mean Elvira hadn't missed playing with her friend, and she was going to make the most of this opportunity, knowing it might be their last time together.
Before her tongue contacted Lori's cute little butt, Elvira stopped and motioned for Ian to come over. When he was kneeling next to her, Elvira spread Lori's cheeks and said, "Take a whiff."
Ian was taken aback and hesitated until Elvira said, "Get a good whiff of her asshole. Tell me what you smell."
Ian leaned in and took a tentative sniff. Elvira put one hand on his head and the other over his mouth, forcing his nose into her crack until he had to breathe or suffocate. When he'd taken a couple of deep breaths, Elvira said, "Well?"
Ian said, "Uhh . . . she smells . . . uhm . . . clean, I guess."
Elvira grabbed Lori's ass with both hands and spread her cheeks until her hole was gaping slightly. Lori winced but kept quiet.
"Now?"
Ian took another sniff and said, "Clean."
Then Elvira shocked Ian by licking her finger until it was coated with saliva and shoving it into Lori's ass up to the third knuckle. She swirled it around and fucked it in and out a couple of times, pulled it out, and waved it under Ian's nose.
Ian was repulsed, but he could see that there were no signs of poop on her finger. Elvira waved her finger under his nose again and he took a small sniff, followed by a deeper breath.
"I smell something, but it doesn't smell like poop."
Elvira nodded saying, "Lori cleaned her butt before you came over. That means flushing it with water until the water comes out clean. There won't be any poop in her lower bowels until the next time she needs to take a dump."
Gary chimed in, "She's theoretically clean enough that you could safely lick Elvira's finger, but ass to mouth isn't for everybody."
Elvira continued, "That's why I'm perfectly comfortable doing this," as she swirled her tongue around Lori's dark ring.
Lori, who had been patiently waiting with her ass up in the air and her cheeks spread, let out a happy, "Oh, yeah!" as soon as Elvira's tongue made contact.
Ian watched closely as Elvira seemed to truly like having her tongue all over Lori's ass, and Lori made the same kinds of sounds as when Ian ate her pussy.
Elvira has one of those long, pointed tongues that she jokingly calls her pussy pleaser. When she extends it fully, she can make it hang down to her chin and then bend up another inch or so. Ian saw her press the full length straight into Lori's ass and then withdraw it like a kid scooping ice cream from a cone. Lori responded by shaking like she'd had a small orgasm. Then Lori was reaching back to press Elviras face as deep into her crack as she could get it while using the other hand to spread herself open.
Elvira continued making love to Lori's ass with her tongue until Lori was panting and squirming. Ian and Gary could see her resisting the urge to play with her own pussy, and from what they could see of her nipples, they looked painfully hard. Elvira was humming contentedly as she happily buried her face between Lori's cheeks, and she let out a satisfied coo whenever a shudder ran through Lori's body.
After a bit, Elvira pressed two fingers into her own sopping pussy before painting Lori's ass with her girl cum. After repeating this a couple of times, Elvira pressed her fingers into Lori's ass and leaned up to whisper in her ear, "More tongue, or are you ready for some cock?"
Lori was fucking herself on Elvira's fingers, so no one in the room doubted what her answer would be. She gave Elvira a long kiss and then said, "Fuck me, please."
Gary stepped up and drizzled lube on Elvira's probing fingers, rewetting them as she worked the slippery liquid into Lori's hole. When her fingers were gliding in and out, she took the lube from Gary and slathered it on her cock as she rose to her feet.
Lori was spreading her ass with her hands, her hole gaping lewdly, as Elvira lined the dildo up with her opening. That's when Ian noticed that the shaft buckled to Elvira's hips was half again as big around as his cock. Before he could think of anything to say, Elvira speared Lori with the tip, eliciting a grunt from Lori. Then Elvira leaned her weight into it, slowly sinking the whole thing into her ass.
