Like the first time, Maria and I tried to put the last experience with our captors behind us. But, at first, she had a hard time doing that. She was not her usual cheerful, bubbly self. Rather, she was somewhat sullen and withdrawn. I once asked her what those men had done with her in there. She only lowered her eyes and mumbled, "They did some terrible things to me." I didn't press it. Within about a month, however, she seemed to be returning to the Maria that I knew before.
For Maria, her two daughters were the love of her life. Teresa was a senior in college. Cheryl was a freshman. Maria was, justifiably, very proud of them and talked about them regularly when we were together. The father had abandoned them when the girls were just babies and Maria raised them alone. She had done a very good job.
Things were going really well for Maria and me, although we had not had sex yet. Maria had explained at the beginning that she was somewhat old-fashioned about things like that. I didn't object. She was definitely worth waiting for.
It had been about two months since the last incident with our captors when I received an anonymous letter in the mail. Instantly recognizing the handwriting, I tore open the envelope and read:
"You remember us, no doubt. We have Cheryl and Teresa. If you want to see them again, be at the same meeting place as last time at midnight tomorrow."
Frantically, I threw down the letter and called Maria. She had received the same letter and was hysterical. She had been informed by each of the girls' roommates that they had not been seen for a few days--very unlike them. The girls' friends had assumed they were visiting their mother. Neither of us said so, but Maria and I both knew what we would have to do.
I picked up Maria at about 11:00 the next night. It was about an hour drive from her house to the meeting place. When we arrived, the area was deserted. Shortly, headlights approached from the distance. It was the same shabby van as before. The same two men, masked and armed, jumped from the side door. As before, we were handcuffed, blindfolded, and tossed into the van. I couldn't believe this was happening again.
Eventually, I heard the same garage door open and then close behind us. Once again, we were led from the van into the residence. As before, the blindfolds and cuffs were removed. Maria instantly began pleading to see her girls. The female captor stepped over to the door to what I knew to be the "dungeon" and motioned to those inside to come out. It was Teresa and Cheryl. They were both naked.
The girls had apparently already received instructions on what to do when we arrived. Cheryl stood facing her mother. Teresa stood in front of me. When the lead captor said, "begin," Cheryl stepped forward and began undressing her mother, while Teresa did the same with me.
When we were both stripped naked, the lead captor motioned for all four of us to sit down on the floor. Pacing the floor in front of us, he started, "We're going to make a movie. Guess what? You all are the stars. Maria, you will play the role of Cinderella. Your daughters will be the "evil sisters." Pointing at me, he said, "You will be the prince who 'takes' Cinderella."
"Here's the story. Cinderella ignores her chores and goes to the ball, where she meets the prince. They come back home and the prince fucks her. The sisters come in from the ball and see the chores weren't done. They find the prince and Cinderella in bed. Angrily, they pull Cinderella aside and teach her some manners. Got it?"
Starting to cry, Maria begs, "Please let my girls go. I'll do anything you want. I'll stay here forever as your sex slave, if you want. Just please, let them go."
"No can do," said the younger male captor. "We need them for the story." With that, he picked up a bikini and a pair of spiked heels and handed them to Teresa. "Here's your costume. Put it on," he commanded. He then did the same with Cheryl. Looking at Maria, he smiled, "You don't need a costume."
We were then led through the dungeon into the next room. In it were two large cameras on tripods and a couple of spotlights. A dresser and mirror were in a corner. On the dresser were what appeared to be various types of make-up, lotions, etc. In the center of the room, the floor was slightly raised, creating a sort of stage. On the stage was a king-size bed, a nightstand and a lamp.
The younger male and the female captor each got behind one of the cameras. The lead captor pushed me and Maria onto the stage. Playing at director, he informed us, "This is the scene where the prince fucks Cinderella. Now, get in bed and let's see some real hard-core action."
Maria and I looked at each other. We were both probably wondering how we could get out of this predicament, but we also both knew that there really was no way out. It disgusted me that our first time making love together would be on camera--and directed by these bastards.