Nice Guys Finish Last
Nonconsent/reluctance Story

Nice Guys Finish Last

by Aimenigmaclic 18 min read 4.5 (15,700 views)
bitch boy small penis femdom humiliation submissive male cfnm span spaning
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

This is a slow burn romance series that contains femdom, humiliation, and non-consensual themes.

Chapter 18

There's a saying in life that people can either be 'book smart' or 'street smart.' When it comes to evaluating my own intelligence, I can humbly admit I fit the criteria of being 'book smart.' 'Street smart,' however... I don't like that term in general.

To me, the terms 'street smart' implies that you can keep yourself safe when the odds are against you. I believe that is reserved mostly for people who face actual danger. In my opinion, the type of people who normally use that terminology are just saying it to make themselves feel better for not being committed to their academic careers.

On the subject of love, however, I know I'm the last person to provide a valued opinion, but I believe neither of these smarts really portray what you need to handle relationships. It's like an art form of its own, with all kinds of secret codes that you may or may not learn, depending solely on your experience. Most importantly, the difficulty of seeing things clearly when you're the one having your emotions influenced by attractive people, both physically and personally, is unlike any other phenomenon this world has to offer.

That was the tough predicament I found myself in, with not one, but two women in my life.

I don't feel I need to rehash the importance Tina served, being the first woman to ever outright choose me after a lifetime of self-pity and doubt. Sure, it wasn't the perfect relationship, and we didn't spend time with each other as much as I wanted. But, to this point, she was the only woman who had ever been willing to announce to the world that I was her boyfriend and she was my girlfriend.

Julia, on the other hand, gave me quite the tumultuous experience growing up; one that I also feel is not worth rehashing. She was my bully in the past, but unlike Tina, she provided me many of the physical interactions I was looking for in a relationship, even outside of sex.

Unfortunately, after Valentine's Day, the time I felt our bond was the closest, Julia practically disappeared from my life again, at least for a few weeks. She would respond to my texts every now and then, but I could feel through the letters on the screen that she didn't really want to talk to me.

I knew I had no right to feel jaded by her lack of communication. After all, I had a girlfriend, so I completely understood why Julia chose not to speak with me. However, after the romantic night we had on Valentine's Day, I couldn't help but wonder if she had just chosen to spend it with me because she herself didn't want to feel lonely on such an important day.

Ever since that night, the warmth I felt for Julia when we kissed into the morning hours was slowly replaced with guilt. Whether I felt I was justified to do so or not, these were not the type of rules I thought a real man would live his life by. Even if my girlfriend had been cheating on me with Romeo, I believed there were other actions necessary instead of simply getting revenge with the same action.

Oddly enough, Tina had been overwhelmingly pleasant with me since that night, making me feel even more guilty. She even apologized for her behavior on Valentine's Day, explaining that she was just going through some drama that she wasn't ready to talk about yet.

I, in return, apologized for putting pressure on her and possibly making the situation worse. I felt pathetic for apologizing to her, considering she might have been cheating on me, but I definitely was cheating on her, so she deserved some sort of apology, nonetheless.

In no time at all, we went back to our ways, spending time together, not only for studying but also just to hang out. Of course, not everything felt natural with her, as we obviously had different interests. However, just going to a coffee shop with her or holding hands with her as we walked to class was more than enough to make me happy.

Despite the secrets I held from her, as well as the secrets she possibly held from me, I enjoyed that we could at least talk about our feelings. Julia and I were far from open books to each other, but I could read some of her feelings through her confusing actions. However, it would have been nice if we could just talk the way Tina and I did.

Unfortunately, despite being able to have a clear perspective on my relationships, I was still having trouble with my insecurities. Someone like me, a cheater, had no right to feel insecure when I was hiding my own skeletons. However, I still couldn't help but wonder what Julia and Tina were doing when they weren't with me.

First of all, I could read through Julia's actions all I wanted, but I truly had no idea what I meant to her. Sure, she found me important in some sort of way, but the Lord only knew how many guys she was giving the same treatment.

Even the blind could see that she was way out of my league. She could have any guy she wanted because she was interesting, athletic, and absolutely stunning. I'd be dumb to think I was the only one she was seeking attention from.

Tina, on the other hand, despite not being as attractive as Julia, was also out of my league. In her case, however, there was one person I had penciled in who was potentially giving her the attention that I wasn't allowed to give. And though I hadn't caught them texting each other secretly in a while, I couldn't help but wonder what was going on with her and Romeo.

Outside of moral standards, I couldn't blame Tina for seeking attention from a man like Romeo. He had several traits that I just didn't stack up to. He was tall, good-looking, charming, and most importantly, fun to be around. He was everything I was not, and that's what made me so insecure.

Oddly enough, I ended up running into him one day. It was one of the only times I had seen him since he switched majors, leaving him on the other side of campus for the majority of his time.

There was a big smile on his face when he saw me, like he often had. While I cringed at the idea of talking to a potential rival for my girlfriend's affection, he seemed to think it was no big deal, either because he actually liked me or he just saw me as a non-threat.

What made the interaction strange, however, was that it was one of the few times he and I talked to each other without Tina being there. She was in class, and I was just walking around campus, trying to clear my mind. It gave me the opportunity to confront him about their relationship... in the most fragile way possible.

He asked me how things were going, and after some meaningless back and forth, I decided to bring up my concerns about Tina. Instead of attempting to call him out, however, I just kept it centered around my insecurities, explaining, "Sometimes I don't know how Tina really feels about me..."

An uncomfortable look came over his face, but he seemed concerned about my well-being instead of me calling him out. "What do you mean, buddy?"

"I mean, sometimes I don't think she's that into me," I expressed, telling the half-truth. Then, in as bold of a move as I could have ever hoped to pull off, I asked, "Does she ever talk to you about me?"

Immediately, he waved his hand at me as if to deny any accusations. "Whoa, man! I sort of stopped talking to her ever since I switched my major to business. I doubt she has told me anything she hasn't told you."

Somehow, I persisted on, despite probably shaking in front of him. "I've seen her text you before... Are you sure she hasn't said anything about me?"

"No, no! It's not like that at all!" he said, brushing my concerns off. "We used to text here and there when I first changed my major, but recently, we haven't been talking much at all."

As he said that, I confirmed in my mind that I hadn't noticed her messaging him in a while. I hate to admit it, but I found myself checking over her shoulder quite often, trying to see if they were secretly messaging each other again.

Despite the reassurance, I still didn't feel much better for some reason. Putting my head down, I let out a sigh before expressing, "I'm sorry if that came off weird."

"Oh, you have nothing to worry about," he said, patting me on the shoulder. Then, with a sigh of his own, his voice lowered a bit before explaining, "You have nothing to worry about... because... she's really into you..."

Immediately, my eyes lit up, and I turned my head and looked at him. "Are you serious?!"

"Yeah, she only speaks positively of you," he affirmed, looking slightly discouraged for some reason. "She always talks about how smart you are... and that you're going to become a great engineer. She thinks very highly of you... in ways that she doesn't think of... other guys..."

It's not that I was fishing for compliments or anything, but I couldn't help but be curious how she could possibly think more highly of me than other guys. "Does she really think that way about me?"

"Yeah... She's always going on and on about how much money you're going to make someday..." he said, pausing for a moment before putting the smile back on his face. "You're her boyfriend, after all! And that's all that matters, okay?"

From there, our conversation didn't last much longer. We both talked about our plans for the day, most of which was a bunch of nothing. Then, as we said our goodbyes, I was left so encouraged that I finished my walk with a smile on my face.

Sure, I understood that there were red flags with women bringing up money when they spoke about men. However, I could also see the positive from that, since that symbolized success and hard work as well.

What was most important was that he assured me that I was her boyfriend and that she only had positive things to say about me. It's not that I felt I needed to one-up anyone, but the idea of her speaking highly about me to other men felt like the rare victory I needed in our relationship.

There were things in her life that I just didn't understand, but nowhere near the level of Julia. For the first time in as long as I could remember, however, I felt encouraged to not worry about me since she supposedly thought so highly of the few positive attributes that I possessed.

Surprisingly, as soon as Romeo left, Tina made her appearance, calling out my name as she waved me down with her hand. Lately, she had been happy to see me, but on this particular day, she seemed to be in an even better mood. And after talking to Romeo, I was feeling more confident than ever.

"Hey, Phillip!" she called out, showing excitement in her voice.

"Oh, hey, Tina! You're out of class early."

"Yeah, we had an exam today! And guess what I got!"

"Judging by your excitement, I'm assuming you did well."

"You're assuming correctly!" she said with a cheerful smile. "I actually got an A!"

I had almost forgotten that she had a test that day since this wasn't normally one of the classes I walked her to and from. However, after all the studying we did together, I wasn't surprised that a smart girl like her would do so well on her exam.

Not to try to outshine her or anything, but I decided to share my own good news, seeing as we both took academics so seriously. "That's so great! I'm proud of you! I actually got a hundred on one of my engineering exams earlier today."

"Are you for real?!"

"Yeah, it looks like all that studying we've been doing is really paying off."

"Oh, Phillip, you're so smart!" she said, boosting my ego even more than Romeo did. "We should totally celebrate!"

My eyes lit up at the prospect of hanging out with her on such a happy occasion. "You really want to? What do you have in mind?"

"I'm not sure yet!" she said with a cheerful smile. "We should go out on Saturday. I actually don't have any plans that night, so we should do something!"

Of course, I agreed to hang out with my girlfriend the next Saturday, not even knowing what we were going to do. The details were irrelevant. It felt like our relationship was stronger than ever, so no matter what we were going to do, I was just happy to spend time with her. And if I was being completely honest... I had hopes that we would actually have a more intimate experience that night...

Despite not working out any details, we went our separate ways after agreeing to spend that Saturday together. For once, I was looking forward to the weekend and hanging out with my girlfriend for sure! However, all my excitement was quickly put on hold as an unstoppable force made its unexpected return to my life.

While lost in my own thoughts, I felt a bump to my side, almost causing me to lose my balance and fall to the ground. When I caught myself and noticed what had almost knocked me over, my jaw dropped at the sight standing before me.

It was none other than Julia, my former bully, that I hadn't spoken to in weeks. And surprisingly, she too seemed to be in a good mood, wearing a pretty smile on her face as she gazed upon me with her radiant eyes.

Immediately, my heart started to thump the same way it did that night we spent together before Valentine's Day. Perhaps the memories of that night flashed through my mind when I felt the positive energy radiating from her presence. Despite her good mood, however, and the confidence I had built that day, I was brought back to my normal insecure self, shaking as I tried to address her.

"Oh... Julia... How have you been?"

She stepped towards me with a smile on her face, but unlike times before, I couldn't see that special sparkle in her eyes whenever she was about to torment me. Instead, she placed her arm around my shoulders, like we were buddies... though I did sort of feel like her bitch because of the way I was walking while being held in her arm.

"Are you nervous, Phillip?" she asked with a cute chuckle. "You're shaking so badly, like I'm going to do something to you."

"I'm always nervous around you..." I admitted, oh so pathetically.

"Don't worry, Phillip. I'm not going to bite."

"You're not?"

She then whispered, "Hey... I know what you're worried about, but I'm not going to do anything to you. So just try to relax."

"Okay..." I whimpered, looking up at her and feeling comforted by the pleasant smile she was giving me. "So... what's going on...? And where have you been?"

"Oh, you know how I can get, Philly Willy. I've just been a bit all over the place. I was going to text you today, but I'm so glad I ran into you."

"You are?"

"Of course I am! Can't you tell?"

For some reason, I couldn't look her in the eyes any longer. Placing my own eyes down to the ground as I continued walking in her arm, I smiled. "Yeah... You seem like you're in a good mood today..."

"If I'm being completely honest, I'm not really in all that great of a mood," she said, surprising me with her sweet yet sincere voice. "I'm just being nice to you because I have a favor to ask."

Of course, I didn't like the fact that she was only acting pleasant because she wanted something from me, but truthfully, I respected that she was so willing to admit that, especially after some of the concerns I had with my own girlfriend. Wanting to oblige her, I asked, "What do you need from me?"

"It's about this Saturday. I have something important going on, and I need your help. Are you free?"

"This Saturday?" I asked, trying hard not to get excited. My slight smile quickly disappeared as the conversation I just had with my girlfriend popped into my mind. "I actually just made plans with Tina... Is there any other day I can help you out?"

Following her lead, we both came to a stop as she looked at me and gave me another pleasant smile. "Unfortunately not. It has to be Saturday. It's one of those things I can't reschedule."

She could see the uneasy look coming over me as I contemplated what to do. Of course, I should have been spending time with my actual girlfriend, but it was so rare for Julia to make such a sincere request of me.

And not that I was proud of this or anything, but I secretly wanted to recapture that feeling I had when we shared that Valentine's Eve together. Not the feeling of me cumming so hard while having sex with her... Well, that too... but that warm feeling in my heart when we spent the whole night kissing.

Before I could put any further thought into it, Julia spoke up and gained my full attention. "Look, I can see that you don't have an answer for me right now. Just let me know if you can make it or not." She then left me there with a smile and a wave goodbye.

I stood silently, watching as her beautiful figure disappeared off into the distance. Just like with Tina, I had no idea what we would even do if we spent that Saturday together. However, with Julia, I couldn't even come close to making any predictions. She had always been such a wild card. I suppose that was one of the many things that seemed to endlessly draw me to her.

***

As dusk turned into dawn, I was still left with the dilemma of what I wanted to do that Saturday. Though I badly wanted to see Julia, I couldn't get over the immorality of choosing to see her over my own girlfriend. However, for once in my life, she seemed understanding of my situation, making it feel as if I had nothing to worry about if I turned her proposition down.

Tina, on the other hand, though pleasant on the outside, always held power over me because she truly controlled our relationship. Although she hadn't threatened me with it, it always made me nervous that she could simply break up with me, leaving me a sad and pathetic loner like I always feared I would become. Keeping her happy was a dire necessity if I wanted to keep her as my girlfriend.

After pacing around in my room for what felt like an eternity, I finally came to a decision.

I'm going to tell Julia I can't hang out with her Saturday,

I declared to myself, putting on a brave face.

Tina's my actual girlfriend... I need to spend time with her when I can; not Julia...

As I grabbed my phone to send the text message, my heart started to race.

Am I really doing this?

I asked myself.

Do I have the balls to do what's obviously correct?

Suddenly, I noticed a vibration while scrolling through my phone. When I looked through my notifications, I realized it was Tina that messaged me.

What is she doing texting me so late?

My eyes grew big and my heart rate slowed as I read her text out loud. "Sorry, change of plans... I forgot I had a prior engagement on Saturday, but we can hang out some other time!"

Without realizing it, a large smile grew over my face as I read the message over and over, making sure I interpreted it correctly.

What a relief...

I thought to myself before coming to a stop and wondering why I felt that way about my girlfriend canceling plans on me.

Only then did I realize the look on my face as I picked my head up and glanced at the mirror. I was smiling from ear to ear, like I had just received good news or something. My brain was confused, but I suppose in that moment, my heart was happy for some reason.

Immediately, I brought myself back to reality and almost chastised myself for being so idiotic.

Tina's my girlfriend... She's the one I should be dying to hang out with...

With the phone still in my hand, I took a few moments to indulge in the guilt I felt for being excited over such a silly thing. However, I couldn't stop myself from messaging Julia as quickly as I could to let her know I was coming.

With my fingers practically shaking, I texted her, "Hey, I can make it on Saturday. Just tell me when and where to meet you."

Placing my phone on the desk, I once again attempted to talk myself down from being so excited. However, as my phone vibrated again, I couldn't help but jump to grab it so I could see if Julia had messaged me back.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like