Nice Guys Finish Last
Reluctance/nonconsent Story

Nice Guys Finish Last

by Aimenigmaclic 18 min read 4.8 (21,700 views)
femdom spaning humiliation cfnm handjob bitch boy naed male small penis
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

This is a romance series that contains domination, femdom, and humiliation topics. I hope you enjoy this wild journey!

Chapter 15

It was difficult to explain, but for some reason, it was like a weight had been lifted off my shoulders. Julia was back in my life; the opposite of what I had always wanted, and yet, she was somehow the key to the new positive outlook I had.

Nothing had really been established between us. We never said anything about our relationship or how often we would see each other. However, after being forced to fuck her open palm as she sat there staring at me with a blank face, I knew that things were back to normal... at least, normal by our standards.

Sex wasn't the reason I wanted her back in my life. In truth, I had grown to care about her, no matter how poorly she treated me. Her ability to make me cum with hardly any effort went beyond her beautiful appearance. There was something about her that captivated me, and unfortunately, my girlfriend, Tina, didn't have it.

A few weeks went by, and though I hadn't seen Julia since that fateful night, I was still just happy to have her back in my life. We texted back and forth every now and then, and she'd even let me vent to her about Tina. I didn't know how interested she was, but I was relieved that she would give me actual advice for my current relationship instead of just making fun of me for being so awful with women.

The more comfortable I got at speaking about my girlfriend, the more I was willing to admit the embarrassing things about my relationship. One night, out of pure shame, I ended up telling Julia about my second experience of having sex with Tina.

It happened about a week after re-encountering my bully for the first time. Tina appeared drunk, just as she did before. She still didn't do any of the dirty things I secretly enjoyed, like fondling my balls and playing with my nipples, and of course, doggy-style was out of the question. However, the worst part of the experience was that I could hardly even get a boner without thinking about Julia.

For some reason, I admitted this to my former bully through text. I should have known not to say something so awkward, because she hardly texted me afterwards.

She just replied, "Oh..." and then left me on "Read" for the rest of the night. All I could do was hang my head in shame as I wondered if I had ruined things with Julia once again.

***

My problems with women were only compounded as I noticed Tina seemed to be in a terrible mood the next morning. I would see her between classes, and we would talk as I walked her to her next class. We would normally talk about our day and what tests we would study for together. On this morning, however, she wasn't talkative at all, leaving me awkwardly following her as I carried her backpack.

Instead of engaging in a conversation with me, she would just respond with single word answers while she texted on her phone. I didn't know what was wrong with her, but I figured whatever she had going on must have been more important than me.

Like the insecure boy that I was, I glanced over her shoulder and got a peek at her phone. She was texting Romeo, which shocked me because I didn't even know that they kept in touch after he switched his major to business.

"Is everything okay, Tina?" I asked, pretending as if I didn't look at her screen. "You seem awfully quiet today, and you're typing a lot..."

After sending what appeared to be a huge message, she put her phone away. "I'm fine," she said, hardly looking in my direction. "One of my friends is just being stupid..."

"One of your friends? Who is it?"

"It's not important," she answered as she increased her pace. "It's just one of my friends from back home. There's no need for you to interrogate me."

I apologized, even though I knew she was lying to me. In truth, I didn't feel brave enough to confront her about texting another guy so much. It was Romeo, after all, and even though he was much taller and better looking than me, I knew I could trust him not to act inappropriately with my girlfriend.

Unfortunately, Tina didn't say another word to me for the rest of the walk. I didn't even get a "thank you" when I handed her the backpack I carried all the way to class for her.

Only when we went our separate ways did I have the courage to speak to her again... through text... I offered, "If you'd like to talk, I'm always here for you."

It wasn't until I finished all my classes that she finally responded. "Thanks, but I'll be okay," she started, making me feel even more insecure for some reason. "I'll just see you tomorrow. I have a lot on my mind."

Walking back to my dorm, I couldn't help but wonder if she was going to talk to Romeo about her problems instead of me. Though I trusted our former study buddy, I felt like less of a man knowing she apparently texted him way more than she did me. Even worse, she hid the fact that she was talking to him at all...

With my head down, I made my way back towards my room, wondering if I should try texting Julia again. I knew seeking comfort in another woman would make me a hypocrite for being jealous about Romeo, but I still wanted to do it. Unfortunately, I didn't even know if Julia would respond, given that I had already made such an awkward admission to her the previous night.

Now, only a block away, I continued the walk while lost in my own thoughts. There was hardly anyone around, except someone approaching in my peripheral.

Quickly, I turned my head to make sure I didn't bump into this person. That's when I noticed who it was. It was her... Julia...

My eyes lit up as she made her way towards me, bearing that evil smile that was common on her face. I took a step back and nervously squealed, "Julia!"

Confidently, she closed the distance, making me even more uncomfortable with her dominant aura. She was already laughing at how scared I appeared just to be in her presence. "Hello, Phillip. I was hoping I'd run into you."

"Hoping you'd run into me...? Why?"

Taking advantage of my timidness, she asserted her dominance over me by grabbing both of my wrists and pushing me backwards towards a nearby building. As she pinned me against the wall, she brought her lips close to my ear and whispered, "I was just thinking about you..."

I gulped in fear, hardly able to open my eyes. However, when I did, she was staring right at me with that confident smile she always possessed.

Struggling to deal with her strength, I quietly whimpered, "What were you thinking about me?"

"Oh, you know... Just that stuff you told me last night... You admitting that you have to fantasize about my hand when you're with your girlfriend..."

There were goosebumps all over my body from the way her breaths tickled my ear and neck. She had me squirming so hard, all I could do was pray that no one walked around the corner and saw how pathetic I looked.

"I'm sorry if that was awkward," I responded with my scared voice, unable to look her in the eyes. "I was actually afraid you were going to stop talking to me after that..."

"Stop talking to you after something like that?" Julia asked with a little giggle. "Now why would you think something silly like that?"

"Well... because you stopped texting me after I sent that...."

Allowing one of my wrists free, Julia rubbed her hand up and down her body while biting her lower lip. In a low voice, she asked, "You really expected me to respond when I could hardly keep my hands off myself?"

My heart was pounding and my eyes grew big. "You couldn't keep... your hands... off yourself?"

For just a second, she allowed her roaming hand to grope her breast, before gently grabbing my chin with it. "How could I when I knew you had to fantasize about my hand to get a boner with your little girlfriend?"

My face was completely red, but before I could even try to save myself from that embarrassing admission, she took her hand from my chin and opened her palm directly in front of my face. "Does the sight of my palm excite you?" she teased, wiggling her fingers in front of me. "You missed this hand, huh?"

As embarrassing as it was, she reached down and grabbed my boner right through my pants. "Oh, my goodness!" she reacted, laughing to herself. "Just the sight of my hand has made your little pecker so hard!"

In all honesty, I had an erection the moment I saw her. Her pinning me to the wall and whispering into my ear didn't help either. To be fair though, the thought of her hand probably would have been enough to give me a boner anyway, but I was hard the moment I realized I was in her presence.

"Please, Julia... This is so embarrassing," I said, hoping no one would see us.

With a little chuckle, she responded, "Aw, my poor little baby," causing my penis to jump for some reason. She then let go of me in the nick of time as others started to walk our direction.

Nervously, I tried to hide my erection by adjusting it in my pants. I quietly panicked as the others walked past us and whispered to Julia, "Thank you for letting me go..."

"I wouldn't want strangers to see how embarrassing you act when I'm with you," she responded, giggling so hard she was going red in the cheeks. She then winked at me and continued, "But I'm starting to think your girlfriend should see this so we can show her how it's done."

Gulping in fear, I shook my head as my boner only grew stronger. "No, please!"

"I'm just kidding," she interrupted, playfully slapping me on the shoulder. Glancing down at my penis, she suggested, "We should probably do something about your little problem though."

"My little problem? How are you going to help me?"

Taking a step back, she clasped her hands behind her back and gave me a cute smile. "You should come to my dorm room tonight... unless, of course, you have something better to do."

Immediately, the thought of Tina saying she would just see me tomorrow while she was texting Romeo crossed my mind. "I don't have anything better to do..." I admitted, looking like a sad puppy.

Fortunately, the cute smile on Julia's face cheered me up. "I guess I'll see you tonight then. I'll text you my address."

If I didn't know any better, I would have thought her cheeks were a little red. However, the sun was out, and with all the swimming she did, I was sure blood was always rushing through her athletic body.

Just as Julia was about to walk off, she stopped and looked back at me. "By the way... I saw your dick flinch when I called you my poor little baby."

Suddenly, I was the one completely red in the face after being called out for my embarrassing reaction. However, before I could make up some sort of excuse, she winked again and said, "Goodbye, my little baby..."

Again, my penis twitched at her calling me baby, even though she felt the need to add "little" in front of it. I was frozen, watching her butt sway from side to side as she walked away from me. It left me wondering...

What could she possibly have in store for me tonight?

***

Even though it had been established that I really, really, really enjoyed the sexual relationship I had with Julia, it wasn't like I was expecting it to happen just because I was coming over to her dorm room... at night... I suppose I hoped it would happen, despite the hypocrisy it showed with my jealousy towards Tina and Romeo. However, if Julia just wanted me to come over only to have a conversation, I was completely fine with it.

Now, based on her actions earlier that day, I could only assume something sexual would happen between us. She was quite aggressive with me... pinning me against the wall while whispering seductively into my ear... This was how she acted when she was on the prowl, and I seemed to be the only thing that would satisfy her appetite.

What I didn't understand was how she was supposedly going to help me with my erection issues when it came to Tina. I'll be honest, the thought of being forced to have sex with Julia in front of my girlfriend made me oddly aroused for some reason. However, I knew that wouldn't be the case, but whatever my bully had in store for me was sure to make me feel like the pathetic pervert that I truly was.

Wearing a long-sleeved shirt and sweatpants that were easy to tear off, just in case, I made my way to Julia's dorm for the very first time. It was a cold walk, with her building being on the other side of campus. However, a long walk in chilly weather was probably what I needed, considering I could hardly keep my erection in check due to the impending encounter I was about to have.

The more I thought about it, the more I accepted that we were probably going to have sex. And even if it didn't happen, I knew Julia was capable of making me unload a massive stream of cum without even moving a muscle... because she literally had me in the palm of her hand...

Every time I crossed paths with someone on my way to Julia's, I was forced to adjust myself inside my sweatpants, hoping they wouldn't notice how excited I was. I still maintained that I was okay not doing anything physical, but if my erection was this significant already, I couldn't help but wonder how aroused I would be when I encountered her.

Once I got outside her building, I texted her, letting her know I was out front. Much to my surprise, she came right down and opened the door for me with a smile on her face. Everything seemed so right. This was probably the first time I ever truly looked forward to being alone with her.

Luckily, there was hardly anyone around. I just followed Julia's curvy figure until we reached her room. I could only imagine what she was going to do to me once we got inside.

She could be so vile... and mean... I was just her prey... There was no telling how badly she would take advantage of me once we were out of everyone's sight.

To my other shock, however, when we got inside her room, I quickly discovered that we weren't alone at all! Her roommate, Valerie, was there, sitting on her bed. And just like Julia, she was wearing a comfortable t-shirt with athletic shorts, looking as if she had no plans to leave the room.

"Hi, Phillip," the tall and imposing roommate said as I stood there, frozen.

"Oh, hi... Valerie... What are you doing here?"

Both girls laughed at me before Valerie spoke up and unnecessarily explained, "I live here."

"I know you live here..." I responded, taking this as a sign that Julia and I wouldn't be having sex. "I just didn't realize you'd be here..."

"Why wouldn't I be in my own room?"

"Oh... um... because..."

"Because he wants to have sex with me," Julia interrupted, causing me to panic.

As I struggled to find the words to save myself, Valerie paused from her chuckles and expressed, "You have nothing to worry about. You can have sex with Julia if you want."

Then, as I turned my worried face towards my long-time bully, Julia explained, "Valerie isn't going anywhere. I need her here for a little experiment."

"Experiment?! What kind of experiment?!"

"You know how you were telling me that you hate having sex with your girlfriend?"

"Those weren't my exact words... but what about it?"

"Well... since I can't actually teach that girl how to satisfy you... I figured we could pretend Valerie is your girlfriend, and you can practice asking for all those dirty little things that you like!"

Even though both ladies high-fived each other as they laughed at my pathetic reactions, I could tell they were being completely serious. It was embarrassing enough knowing that Valerie was aware of our situation, but forcing me to pretend she was Tina so I could ask her to do the things that Julia did to me was beyond humiliating!

"I...I... I can't do this," I whimpered as my entire body shriveled in fear.

"You have nothing to worry about," Julia said, as she grabbed both of my shoulders and forced me to face Valerie. "She already knows about all the nasty things I've done to you. You just have to practice asking for them out loud."

"Yeah, Phillip!" Valerie said, jumping in to confirm my biggest fears. "Pretend like I'm your boring little girlfriend and ask me to finger your ass like Julia does."

A loud gasp escaped me as one of my biggest fears had been confirmed. There was no more doubting that Julia had disclosed my embarrassing kinks to her roommate. And now they were both laughing at me hysterically as my most shameful secrets were brought to light!

While I just stood there, too frightened to even respond, they continued to make jokes at my expense! It was like that locker room talk where people shared their embarrassing experiences. The only difference was, I was freaking standing right there, and they didn't give one crap whether I heard or not!

"Oh, come on Valerie," Julia started, gathering herself from her constant giggling. "Don't tease him. His boring girlfriend never makes fun of him and that's why he has ED around her."

"Yeah, you're right! I'm supposed to be acting like that lame little girl," Valerie started, before turning her evil gaze towards me. "Pretend I'm your flat and boring girlfriend, and tell me what you wish I would do."

I stood there struggling for what felt like an eternity. It was absolutely impossible to keep my head straight in this situation, no less actually pretend that a tall and voluptuous swimmer like Valerie was, instead, my girlfriend, Tina. But as I stuttered over my own words, they just continued laughing at me, making me even more nervous!

Then, much to my utter shock, Valerie stood up and walked behind both of us. As I turned around, she wrapped her arms around Julia from behind and began groping her breasts!

"Is this why you can't get a boner?" she teased, using an annoying voice she made up to mimic Tina. "Is it because Julia's tits are so much better than mine?"

Oh, my fucking God!

I screamed in my head, feeling a mixture of panic and extreme arousal. I was still scared beyond belief to play this game with them, but seeing Valerie play with Julia's boobs, even jokingly, almost forced me to ejaculate right through my sweatpants!

As if I wasn't drooling enough, Valerie then turned Julia around and pulled her shorts down, revealing her thick booty in a little gray thong. Rubbing my bully's thick cheeks, she asked, "Or are you an ass man, and you can't get over how nice her peach is compared to mine?"

I swear to God, my head almost exploded right from my shoulders at the sight of another beautiful woman playing with Julia's assets. No amount of porn could ever make me feel the way I felt in that moment. If being aroused by their little show made me a pervert, then I deserved to be locked up in prison forever!

Giggling, Julia tried to push her roommate away. "Oh, stop, Valerie! You're so silly!"

Then, Valerie landed a playful smack on Julia's ass, causing my dick the flinch so hard I thought it was going to detach for my body. She then continued her playful banter, expressing, "I'm just so jealous of you because you can give my boyfriend a boner and I can't!"

Although Valerie was even taller and thicker than my voluptuous bully, Julia successfully pushed her back towards the bed, forcing her to sit on the mattress. As they giggled together, I couldn't help but be an even bigger pervert and pray that they would wrestle right in front of me. However, what actually happened was that Julia turned her attention towards me and reaffirmed that I would be practicing having a conversation with Tina.

"Come on, Phillip. Pretend Valerie is your annoying little girlfriend and let her know what you really want. Since she's not assertive like me, you can't just expect her to do what you want without asking."

Unfortunately, Julia was right. Tina wasn't going to force me into these kinky experiences that I had grown to enjoy. I needed to somehow ask for these needs, or I'd risk never experiencing them again once my bully walked out of my life for good!

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like