(This story is posted on the Literotica website. Do not repost anywhere else without the author's consent. For fans of my stories, they know what kinds of things to expect. This story deals with similar themes as the stories by wannabeboytoy, seducedHylas, and Dark Betrayal, namely cheating, betrayal, and heartbreak. If stuff like that isn't your cup of tea, then you probably shouldn't bother reading it. I do not condone any of these actions in real life. This is just a story. Enjoy.)
(An additional note. We're at the epilogue, which means that these stories aren't so self-contained anymore. I will be giving endings for the characters that appeared throughout this tale across four epilogues. In this fourth and final epilogue, I'm covering the remaining chapters, as well as closing out some loose ends and looking forward to the future. So, this epilogue the characters from Chapters 9 and 10, in that order, plus a few other background characters and stories. So, if you're looking to see the endings for Dan and Gwen, Max and Janet, Fourth Street itself, or a little glimpse of some North Pole intrigue, read onwards. And finally, in terms of themes, although this epilogue is posted in the 'Reluctance' category, some of it features characters from a chapter that centered on INCEST. And because part of this epilogue examines their fate after said act, don't be surprised to see a bit more INCEST in this chapter as well...)
**************
(Chapter 14)
(Epilogue 4)
**************
By every lesson Dan Carroll had been taught his entire life, he figured he should feel terrible. A nervous, guilty wreck, addled with regret and shame. Ever since his father ran off with the preacher's daughter so many years ago, he'd always believed that cheating on one's spouse was among the worst things a man could do. He'd experienced the fallout firsthand, and he figured that if anyone who thought about cheating knew what his dad did, they would never go through with it.
But now Dan had cheated on his wife.
And not only had he cheated, he did it by fucking his own smoking hot, huge-breasted daughter. It was incest, one of the worst sins out there, right? Seeing her perfect ass in a thong sent him down a slippery slope into incest. His daughter had used her hot body, her perfect ass and massive boobs, to wear down and seduce her own father into some truly filthy sex. In the immediate aftermath of his illicit, Christmas day fuck with Gwen, the guilt hadn't hit him just yet, but he expected it to hit him in waves eventually.
That guilt never came.
It was amazing how little this whole thing bothered him. He'd fucked his busty, fit, sexy daughter hard, making her scream in pleasure, cumming both in her tight pussy and on her big tits, and honestly... he felt great about it. Every time he thought about it, a rush of excitement and manly pride coursed through him. The same thing happened each time he glimpsed at Gwen, or passed her when walking through the house, or even got a whiff of her natural girly smell. After spending so much time rejecting any thought of getting turned on by his sexy daughter, just being in her presence made him horny now.
Their spontaneous affair had forever changed their relationship, and he wondered if things could ever go back to normal. Could he ever look at her and not be reminded of their lusty Christmas day encounter? Could he ever be around her and not be reminded that he'd been balls deep inside her tight pussy? Could he ever be in her presence and forget about seeing her massive, juicy tits bare? Could he ever hope to have parental authority over her knowing that she had convinced him to abandon all fatherly instincts and fuck her senseless? He couldn't say for sure.
Things were so busy in the aftermath of that furious Christmas day fuck that they didn't really have a moment alone afterwards to see where things stood. Sure, there were shared moments in the hours after that wicked fuck, basking in the glow of what they had just done together. But beyond those immediate few hours afterwards, when maybe the weight of what they had done might hit them, things got more hectic and busier as the rest of the family got back home, preventing them from having any moments of privacy. Sure, there were shared knowing looks and fleeting smiles passed between them, but nothing beyond that. And as the days went on, and Gwen gave no outward sign either way about her true feelings of what had happened that day, Dan began to worry that maybe she was having second thoughts. He would of course understand if she did. Seriously, it was stranger that he didn't. But... it just felt like they had discovered something together. Something incredible. For the first time in his life, he'd found something that truly excited him, something he didn't know existed, and he didn't want to be alone with this knowledge.
He didn't even know what he even wanted. If he was hoping she'd make another move on him, or communicating how amazing their encounter was... anything, really. He wanted some sign that she was okay with what they had done with each other. Even if she wanted what they did to be a one-time thing, that was fine. He just wanted to know.
Leaving Deerberg, making the long drive back home, with Connie next to him, Max in the back seat behind him, and Gwen on the opposite side of the back seat, it felt like any other drive. Connie talking about some of the Church things she'd taken part of while in Deerberg. Max, silent, in his own head, thinking about God knows what. But Dan's eyes kept drifting up to the rearview mirror, just so he could glance at Gwen again. And eventually, she began looking at him, eyes meeting his in the mirror, his unsure, hers twinkling with amusement. At this, he was filled with renewed excitement.
In that moment, he was filled with hope that he wasn't alone.
They got home, celebrated New Years together, but things never fully got back to normal. Which is to say, he never got the chance to be alone with Gwen. When Connie was gone doing her thing at the church, Max was still around. And after Max left to head back to college, Gwen had another week off before resuming school, which was good. But both Dan and Connie both had to go back to work, which was bad. By the time he left to head back to work after his Christmas vacation, and with Gwen never clarifying her feelings either way, things still seemed kinda up in the air.