Lily in the Valley
Nonconsent/reluctance Story

Lily in the Valley

by Devonprinceton 18 min read 4.4 (18,300 views)
cheating wife adultery reluctance forced big coc neighbor group blowjob
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

Note: This story and the stories that follow in the Lily in the Valley series are a continuation of my novel, Lily. Hope you enjoy...

Lily in the Valley

Chapter 1

Meet the Family

I opened the door, and standing in front of me was maybe the most beautiful man I'd ever seen. He stood about six-foot-two with olive skin, dark wavy hair, deep brown eyes, a perfectly symmetrical face, and a body that made me quiver in my core. I hadn't had that kind of reaction to a man since I saw Tom for the first time. Unlike Tom, however, the man in front of me was, by anyone's standards, gorgeous. Also in contrast to Tom, this man was impeccably dressed in designer jeans and a short-sleeved button-up. Everything fit perfectly and was completely devoid of wrinkles. The perfect man.

"Can I help you?" I asked, trying not to stare.

"Are you Lily Bradford?"

Even his voice was sexy.

"Yes," I answered, wondering why he would possibly be knocking on my door.

"My name is Noah Martin."

He paused briefly, looking nervous.

"I'm your brother."

"I'm sorry. I don't have a brother," I corrected. "You must be mistaken." Surely, this must be some new kind of scam, I thought.

"Your mother, Jane Watford Adams, was my mother. Your father, James Adams, was my father."

He handed me a tattered, yellowed document. As I unfolded it to examine, he continued.

"I was born two years to the day before you. I'm guessing from the look on your face that they never told you about me."

I stared at the birth certificate in my hand. He wasn't lying. I shook my head, trying to wrap my brain around what I was seeing and hearing.

"I don't understand," I mumbled to myself.

"I was put up for adoption. I never knew my biological parents - our parents. I was raised in Florida by the people who adopted me."

"I'm sorry. I just..." I stammered. I was in complete shock. For a moment, I thought I was going to lose my balance. My mother and father were the only blood relations I ever knew, and they were both dead. I had always assumed I was the only one left. And for good reason. To hear otherwise absolutely rattled my view of the world and my place in it.

"I know how you feel. I felt the same way when my parents told me I was adopted. That was a hell of a day."

I looked up at Noah, taking in his face again. He smiled.

"I'm sure you have a lot of questions," he said. "I probably don't have most of the answers, but if you invite me in, maybe I can tell you what I do know. At the very least, I think you should probably sit down. You're looking a little wobbly."

I tried to gather my senses. "I'm sorry. Yes. Please...come in," I agreed, pointing Noah in the direction of the kitchen. He took a seat at the bar.

"Would you like something to drink?" I offered, making my way to the cabinet to retrieve a wine glass.

"Some water would be good."

"Are you sure I can't get you something else?"

I was hoping he'd drink with me so I could feel a little better about myself for wanting to take the edge off. I put my wine glass on the counter and reached for the bottle of red that I had opened the night before. I couldn't believe that my initial reaction to seeing my own brother was so visceral and so sexual. The last man that made me feel that way ended up looking down at me on my knees for him just a few hours later.

"Given the circumstances, I think I'm gonna have a little drink. It's gotta be five o'clock somewhere," I joked.

I was relieved to see Noah didn't seem to judge me. He smiled and let out a little chuckle.

"A glass of wine sounds good," he nodded.

As I filled our glasses, I noticed our neighbor, Bob, out the window. I quickly turned my attention back to pouring the wine. I didn't want to waste a second of my time thinking about the asshole across the street. He was retired and had nothing better to do than spy on everyone in the neighborhood and cause problems. He seemed to have a particular fascination with me. He stopped shy of catcalling, but his lingering stares and inappropriate comments were an almost daily bother. Had we known such an asshole was going to be across the street, Will and I would have bought a house somewhere else. I just knew that at some point in the future, the grapevine would be ripe with rumors about me welcoming a handsome stranger into my house while my husband was at work. No one there knew of my past. If they did, Noah's mere presence at my doorstep would have caused quite the kerfuffle.

Noah and I agreeing that we weren't going to get through the moment without alcohol settled my nerves a little bit, even before taking a sip. I wasn't worried about drinking so early in the day. Alcohol wasn't my problem. Sex was. Much like an alcoholic shouldn't hang out in bars, I normally wouldn't have allowed myself to be alone with such a beautiful man. However, considering that the gorgeous man in question was apparently my brother, I felt confident I wasn't going to relapse, even if I indulged in a little ethanol. My head was swimming, and I was still too befuddled to guide the conversation. I think Noah sensed that and took the lead.

"Why don't I start by telling you what I'm doing here?" he suggested.

"Okay," I agreed, already nearing the end of my glass, having gulped down most of it the first two sips. I went to top myself off. I gestured with the bottle to offer the same to Noah. He'd barely had a sip of his.

"Why not?" he answered.

We laughed at how little I could actually add to his glass, and I felt some more tension leave my body. Noah took an awkward sip of his wine to keep it from spilling before continuing his story.

"Obviously, I'd been curious about my birth parents ever since my mom and dad first told me I was adopted. But I was always too scared to actually do anything about it. What if they were awful? What if they refused to see me? I was terrified of being rejected. For years, there always seemed to be something holding me back. Some excuse. But a few months ago, I just decided, 'Screw it. I want to know. Good or bad.' Then, of course, I found out they were both gone. I saw your name in the obituaries, and here I am."

"Here you are," I smiled. The shock was wearing off, and incredulity was taking its place. "God, you're so beautiful," I beamed.

Noah smiled back. "So are you."

I made my way to the other side of the bar, reaching out with my arms to hug him. "I have a big brother!" I cried.

Noah stood up and embraced me. I'll never forget that moment, being wrapped in my brother's arms for the first time, for as long as I live. We spent the next few hours and the rest of that bottle of wine telling each other of our childhoods and marveling at how similar we were. We both loved wine but hated scotch. Comedies, not horror. Fish, but not seafood. Even our features were similar, right down to our toes. As the afternoon wore on and the wine continued to flow, the questions became more and more personal.

"Can I ask you something? It's none of my business, but I'm curious," Noah asked.

"Sure," I replied.

"When our dad died, you were Lily Bradford. When our mom died, you were Lily Adams. Now you're back to Bradford."

"Ah. I understand the confusion."

I felt a little embarrassed, but I had learned to deal with it. Normally, I only told my story to other people if it was in the interest of helping someone. I don't know if it was the wine or if it just felt like I was talking to a mirror, but I decided to tell Noah the unabridged version. I still carried some shame about my sex addiction, but I tried to challenge that shame when I could. I was glad I was drunk, though.

"So, yeah. Will and I got married right after college. We were married for right at six years - split up on our sixth anniversary, in fact. Then we were apart for several years. While we were apart, Will got sober. I got sexually sober. And then, by pure chance, fate, or divine intervention - whatever you want to call it - we wound up in the same bar in Nashville. I didn't even live there, and I had no idea that he did. I was there for a conference. I went for a drink with friends afterward, and Will was there in the corner. He was playing guitar, not drinking, by the way. We'd both been sober for a while by that point. We talked, and I ended up never leaving town. We've been back together ever since. It's been wonderful. We got married again a year ago. So, in true white trash fashion, I married the same man twice."

"Wow. So, what does that mean exactly? Sexually sober?"

"It means that I used sex just like an alcoholic uses alcohol."

Noah looked terribly concerned. "So, you can't have sex anymore?"

"No! God, no!" I laughed. "I just can't use it like a drug anymore. I only have sex in a committed, loving relationship, and I don't allow myself to use it to change the way I feel. I use it to express love, not hide from things."

"Oh, thank God," Noah sighed. "If I couldn't have sex, I don't think life would be worth living!"

We both laughed. I couldn't have agreed more.

"So, do you have to go to meetings and stuff?" Noah probed.

"I used to. I haven't been in a long time. I haven't had any issues with it in years, though." I knew that I should probably at least find out where a meeting was in my new hometown, just in case, but I wasn't worried. I'd relapsed once, after my mother died. I went to Myrtle Beach for a long weekend with friends and ended up falling off the wagon. I quickly got back in recovery and had been fine ever since.

"What about you? Ever married?" I asked.

"No," Noah replied. "I came close once or twice, but it never panned out. I don't know that I'm built for settling down."

"Kids?"

Noah cocked his head a little and confessed, "Uh...actually, I prefer men."

"Really?" I couldn't hide my surprise.

"Yup."

"I should have known," I joked. "There isn't a wrinkle anywhere on you. No straight man irons his jeans."

Noah laughed.

"I, myself, have taken a dip or two in the lady pool," I offered, making a blatant effort to signal that I wasn't homophobic.

"Let me guess...college?"

"You guessed wrong. Well, actually, I did kiss a girl in college one time, but I didn't have sex with a woman until things started going off the rails."

"Going off the rails?"

Drinking wine with a brother I never knew I had was the last thing I thought I would be doing that day. Telling him of my sexual exploits was the second to last thing I thought I would be doing that day.

"Will and I had this game we used to play where I would dance and flirt with other men when we were out of town. It would get him all riled up, and then we'd go back to the hotel and have really good sex, or at least what I thought at the time was really good sex. Looking back, I was incredibly naΓ―ve at that point in the bedroom."

"What's the lesbian part?"

"Hang on. I'm getting there."

"Okay. Sorry."

"One night, on the Fourth of July, Will asked me to flirt with this guy we'd met at the neighborhood picnic. He wasn't particularly attractive, but for some strange reason, I was immediately drawn to him. Things got a little out of hand and ended up going a bit farther than usual, all while Will spied on us."

"What's a bit farther?"

The wine had all but put the filter between my brain and my mouth into a coma.

"I sucked his dick in the middle of our living room."

"Wow! And Will saw?"

I nodded.

Noah looked enthralled. "Did you know at the time he could see you?"

I nodded. "Yeah. He's the one that started the flirting thing, but taking it that far was kind of my fault. To be honest, I got so caught up in the moment that I forgot he was there."

"I still don't know what that has to do with you being a part-time lesbian."

"HOLD ON!" I scolded him good-heartedly. "I'm getting to it."

"Okay! Okay!" Noah laughed.

"So then, that same guy comes over to fix our sink a few months later. He ends up bending me over and fucking me while Will was at work. Noah, believe me when I tell you, it was A-MAZ-ING. It changed everything for me. That's how it all started, anyway. This is not long after dad died, by the way. I spent the next year sleeping with half the people in town, one of whom..."

I gestured to let Noah know that I was finally getting to his question.

"...was my best friend, Sally. There were some other women peppered in there, too, for good measure," I joked. "Anyway, I used to really beat myself up about all of that. I didn't understand it at the time. I just knew it was the only thing that made me feel better. I was in complete denial about how big of a deal it was that dad died and all of that."

"Hey, don't feel bad," Noah commiserated. "I'm no stranger to that sort of thing. Not to sound arrogant, but when you look like we do, there's a lot of temptation. I've done my share of sleeping around. I've think I've probably cheated on every boyfriend I've ever had."

"Oh, good. It's genetic, then." I raised my glass.

Just then, the front door opened, and Will walked in with a confused look on his face. He had obviously already seen Noah's car. "Hello?"

"Will! Hey! Oh my gosh. We must have lost track of time."

That did nothing to explain the handsome man and two empty bottles of wine in the living room.

"Um, okay?" he replied, waiting politely, but worriedly, for an explanation.

"I want you to meet someone. Will, this is Noah. He's my brother."

Noah stepped forward to shake Will's hand.

"Did you say brother?"

I nodded my head. "Yeah. Can you believe it?"

"I was adopted," Noah quickly explained. "A few years before Lily came along."

"Oh! Okay." Will was obviously relieved to both understand how it could possibly be that his wife had a brother he had never heard of before and to know that the man in his living room was not fucking his wife.

I scrunched my face apologetically. "I'm sorry, babe. I didn't fix anything for dinner."

"That's fine. We'll just order out," Will smiled. He really was a kind, decent man.

In true Will fashion, he took care of everything while Noah and I kept grilling each other about every little detail of the thirty-something years we'd missed together. Dinner was nice. The conversation was more polite than it had become just before Will got home. It was mostly Noah recounting for Will what he had already told me earlier that afternoon about being adopted and his time in Florida. It gave me the opportunity to stare at Noah and try to process the fact that I had a brother. He was scheduled to leave the next day, but he promised he would keep in touch and be back soon for another visit.

That night, as Will and I laid in bed, I couldn't stop pestering him about Noah.

"He's so handsome, don't you think?" I asked.

"Yes, he's very handsome," Will agreed for the third time. He was being so patient with me.

"I know I'm being a pain. I just can't help it."

"Baby, it's fine. I mean, you just found out a few hours ago that you have a brother. How crazy is that?"

"I know, right? And it's so weird. As soon as I opened the door, I knew there was something about him."

"I bet you did," Will joked.

I slapped his arm playfully. "Hush!"

I waited a brief moment before confessing, "I did kind of think he was hot when I first opened the door, though." I shoved my face into the pillow and squealed in embarrassment.

Will let me off easy. "Of course he's hot. He's like the male version of you."

"Oh, you think he's hot, do you?" I teased.

"I'm just saying that the two of you look a lot alike."

"Will, are you gay for my brother?" I joked.

Will laughed. "I'm about as gay for your brother as you are horny for him!" he retaliated.

I laughed and slapped his arm again, only much gentler. We finally settled down, cuddling under the sheets. This was usually the part of the evening when Will and I made love. Starting a few weeks before, we had begun indulging Will's fantasies of me being with other men. Not like we did before. We didn't take it out into the real world. That had destroyed our marriage and nearly killed the both of us. Literally. After we started dating again, I confessed to him almost immediately that even though he already knew I had cheated on him multiple times without his blessing, he had no idea the extent of my indiscretions. I didn't want any secrets between us. I left it up to Will to decide if he wanted to know the things I had done. He'd recently begun asking questions. More and more often, Will would ask me to tell him a story about one of the times I was with another man - or woman - while we were married the first time.

"Hey, Lily?"

"Yes, Will?"

"Tell me a story."

That's how it always began. I paused, trying to decide which story to tell him. I had a lot to choose from. I'd had sex with literally hundreds of people behind his back. I couldn't even remember all of them.

"Did I ever tell you about the time I relapsed?"

"No," Will said, shaking his head. "I knew you had, but you've never told me anything more about it."

"It's pretty racy. Are you sure you want to hear?"

Will looked at me with a reluctant hunger in his eyes. He nodded.

"It wasn't long after Mom died," I spoke softly. "I went to Myrtle with Jason and Steph. You never met them. We only hung out for a year or so. Anyway, the first night we were there, we went to this big dance club. I started dancing, and before long, a few younger guys were starting to dance their way closer to me. They kind of reminded me of those two guys in Atlanta that one time. Do you remember that?"

"I remember," Will nodded, waiting with bated breath. His hand started drifting toward his cock that was already starting to bulge in his pajamas.

"Anyway, they got closer and started dancing right up on me. I should have shooed them away, but I had a few drinks in me and thought, 'What's the harm in a little dancing?'"

Will gave me a look. Given our history together, he knew how foolish that thought was.

"I know, right?" I responded without him having to say a word. "I forgot exactly how it came up, but one of them told me I was a MILF. Can you believe that? I wasn't even thirty yet, and those punks were calling me a MILF."

Will's slid his pajama pants off. His cock was hard in anticipation of the rest of the story. I reached down and stroked it with a feather touch.

"They started buying me drinks. They told me they were from Virginia and that they were staying in one of their parents' beach houses on Pawley's Island. I told them I'd always wanted to go to Pawley's but had never been. I knew exactly what I was doing when I said that. I remember feeling the roller coaster coming for me for the first time in a very long time. I knew it had everything to do with my mom dying. I just didn't care. I wanted to feel better. The boys immediately offered to take me back to their place. Even I was surprised by just how quickly and easily I accepted."

I squeezed the tip of Will's cock, coaxing out a drop of precum. I started getting wet.

"Should I keep going?" I teased.

Will nodded with a little moan.

"As it turned out, there were actually four of them in the club. My guys went to see if they could talk the other two into leaving the club and making the drive south to Pawley's. When they saw me, they didn't hesitate. Five minutes later, their tab was paid, and we were on the road."

"The driver introduced himself and the guy in the passenger seat. I didn't bother trying to remember their names. I didn't care. I sat in back between the two guys I danced with."

I scooted down in the bed just a bit and started kissing Will's chest, still gently stroking his cock.

"We listened to music and joked around in the car on the way. After about twenty minutes, the lights of Myrtle Beach were behind us, and the road got darker."

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like