Chapter Four: The Trappings of Choice
Note: This story references events from Enslaved by the Pen that would otherwise be decontextualized if read independently and requires the reader to be familiar with the general chronology of events from that series. It is recommended that this be read following Enslaved by the Pen. Please note that the stories contained within both series are non-con fiction, and should be read at the reader's own discretion.
==========
Gabe's words echoed hollowly in my ears. It was as if he was uttering a foreign tongue, unrecognizable in its cadence and articulation. He repeated his query to me as if re-stating his proposition would prompt a quicker resolution to what clearly was an untenable choice.
"What is it you desire Amelia, accountability or liberation?"
Gabe's hand never ceased caressing down the length of my hair, his palm skirting the silky tresses as if a reassuring gesture, but assuredly more unnerving in its execution than its intention. A sudden tremor overtook my limbs as I pondered the absurdity of Gabe's ultimatum. Rather than simply releasing me, his solution was to offer me enslavement with the potential of his imprisonment, or enslavement with the certainty of being imprisoned by him. The latter was particularly repugnant. I couldn't exist under the yoke of his keep, perpetually kowtowing to the capriciousness of his every sexual whim. To do so voluntarily was an unforgiveable treachery of self, a betrayal to everything that I had battled and suffered through at the mansion, and within the bowels of the earth. It mattered little that he was fulfilling my deeply submerged fantasies, or that I admitted I loved him. I couldn't be the submissive of a man who refused a measure of accountability, and who couldn't reflexively introspect on his own monstrosity.
Gabe was appallingly correct in his assessment, however. My body had capitulated to him willingly in the conservation area. It had danced in jubilation under his seemingly coercive command, presenting and twisting itself into sensual curves for his visual satisfaction, wrenching itself into positions of vulnerability that he nurtured with an appropriately rapacious hunger. His initial winsome smile as he observed me convulsing took on a menacing look of predation. He knew then that possession of my body was inevitable.
The realization had eluded me in the moment as my stamina compelled itself solely with pursuing and delivering pleasure; but I had bestowed upon him the power to control me, to possess me in that subservient sense of place and space that both of us revelled in, and that our bodies hungered to entwine in. The thought of disobeying his directive had not even factored into my mind as my body vaulted itself increasingly towards sexual yearning. Within the span of mere hours, Gabe had mentally transported me back to the mansion, captive to his dominance, permanently a prisoner to his passion and my own.
It was an unsettling revelation that Gabe insisted I confront. His influence was all illusion, yet his power was ever potent and omnipresent. He may have bound my hands, but he did so loosely. He may have gagged me, but my legs were free to tread my own path. The realization humbled me outside as I stood on the balcony, paralyzed by the cloak of self-loathing that refused to lift in reprieve from my hunched stance of defeat. I had fallen in love with my interlocutor, my interrogator, my incarcerator. The intensity of his stare bore into my back as he lurked beyond the door. The briny wetness slipped down my cheeks as I registered that I had permitted myself to become a pawn in his game yet again. I could only move forwards; I couldn't rewrite the past.
I was as much a complicit partner in his fantasy, as he was a duplicitous fiend in my delusion. But somehow, I had persuaded myself that my participation reflected the efforts of coercion. What Gabe requested from me with his proposition was an open and voluntary surrendering to his dominance, freely given out of vengeance, or bequeathed to him out of love. He wanted me to indenture myself to him regardless of my determination.
I had endeavoured so diligently to rid his hold over me. When the detective had not been able to deliver results in the furtherance of justice, I had elected to forge ahead, casting off the entanglements of the past. Through my months of captivity, my memories were overwhelmed with the alienating reality of Gabe's depravity. Yet, I had also observed Gabe to be of honour. Punishment was never arbitrary. His compassion for me held no bounds. I was his captive and his sexual slave, but his humanity still flourished and graced upon my body and soul. His refusal to abandon his dreams of me being his submissive seemed illogically inconsistent with the rational person I knew him to be.
That afternoon in his office, he had seemed angry, but resigned after my confrontation with him, weary from the burden of truth that suddenly was magnified under duress. I wasn't his. He finally understood that. Yet, we found ourselves back again. I despised that Gabe had evaded the responsibility for his actions, but I had abandoned such negativity. If justice wasn't to be meted out for him, I refused to stand as the arbiter of his fate. Rather, I wished to disentangle myself from the strands of his life entirely. I loved him, but I wouldn't permit myself the indignity to dream of happiness or consign myself to the oblivion of forgotten truth.
My fingers drifted back to the leather collar, and then skimmed across the table to its knitted counterpart. Rather than make a declarative statement that illustrated my tenacity and my refusal to engage, I felt the first wet tear slide down my cheek. I refused to be a party to my own enslavement again. My shoulders buckled forwards and I soundlessly wept, until silence no longer afforded me solace.
"I have nothing left to give," I howled repeatedly as if some mantra that would provide salvation.
The rupture of my squeal of anguish through the eerie stillness of the room surprised even Gabe, who immediately gathered me upwards in his arms and rocked me for reassurance.
"Little one, please don't fret. This wasn't meant to be a challenging decision. It was intended to furnish you with your ultimate desire, punishing me, or provisioning your pleasure."
Despite epitomizing the face of every atrocity committed upon my body, I sank into the protective solidity of Gabe's chest, floundering at first in his tight embrace, until I accepted the affection he imparted, consenting to feel a kernel of his misplaced compassion. I had no other companion in my capture beyond Mittens. Gabe was both my accomplice and my antagonist. How do you escape the clutches of your conspirator when you willingly contribute to your own subjugation? Gabe only continued sweeping down my hair in reassurance, emitting inconsequential shushing sounds, as his other arm pinned me tight against his torso, strangling me close as if I would suddenly disintegrate from his hold.
"Please Amelia, I adore you like no one I've ever loved before. I never wanted you to wallow in such despair and become this distraught. Today was an illustration of how powerful our connection continues to be, and how much power you ultimately retain. Since your release, I've fretted about your mental health and your persisting feelings of powerlessness. I wanted to ameliorate that for you."
Gabe's words contained a trace of sincerity, as if the educational benefits of this morning's exercise merited my apprehension again. He operated under the delusion that assuaging his own guilt adequately compensated for the psychological and emotional trauma he inflicted on me through my continuing confinement. My attempted departure from his hold proved ineffectual as his grip tightened. I remained on his lap until tears could no longer be shed.
"I neither want nor need the decision Gabe." The timbre of my voice was solemn. "I want you to leave me alone. Please. I've nothing left to give you. You've wrenched everything from me already, my sanity, my dignity, my sexuality. What more is there I can surrender to you at the alter of your insatiable appetite?"
I was exhausted of the artifice, of the manipulations, of the entirety of our deviousness and the repertoire of our conniving through months of my abduction.
My body wracked in silent upheaval again. Gabe tilted my head upwards so that I could meet his scrutiny. He wanted assurance that his intended actions hadn't irrevocably shattered me. He held my chin between his two fingers so gently, yet the threat of force remained. My eyes closed, unwilling to provide him the answers he so desperately sought. Gentleness ceded to more pressure and my eyes fluttered open from the piercing pain as his fingertips dug into my chin.