Lemonade Out of Lemons
Reluctance/nonconsent Story

Lemonade Out of Lemons

by Demonaandariel 18 min read 4.4 (3,100 views)
noncon anal anal sex
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

He didn't watch her leave. Why would he? No point in standing in front of his door waiting until he couldn't see her taillights. It was better this way anyway. For her. For him.

The weekend had to go by way too quickly. He could have had her stay a couple more hours. Fucked her ass at least once more, maybe be a little bit rougher. He was a bastard, wasn't he? She had started to get attached to him. Of course, she did. It made sense with all of his praising. His intention was to emotionally manipulate her after all.

Those tears.

He shook his head. He shouldn't have been so sweet with her in the morning. When he noticed her distress, her tears, he changed his plans. He should have kept them, kept the rough sex ideas that he had. But he didn't. The way she looked up at him and how she combed his hair back, the feeling of her fingertips along his scalp.

His skin rose recalling her touch. At the thought of more tender moments coming from her spontaneously.

He wanted to join her in that shower, see what she would do to him. Touch him? Tease him? Her personality was starting to peek through. She was starting to get more comfortable with him. But, joining her would have led him down a path he wasn't entirely sure he wanted to go.Β It was a good thing he masturbated before she woke up again. He had to fingerfuck her. Had to feel her cunt walls quiver around his digits because he couldn't do it one last time with his cock. Had to feel her body go boneless on him because of him.

God, she was perfect for him. There was still so much more he could explore with her. He had started molding her into the perfect sexual partner for him. And, honestly, he couldn't have done that if her true interests didn't align with his. He had given it quite some thought. Yes, his manipulation of her emotions had played its role. But, there was more to it. She needed validation. She needed to be praised. She needed to be punished. She needed to resist because, ultimately, she needed to be dominated. And he could give her everything she needed.

God. What a weekend. He got to explore things he wasn't sure he'd be able to explore. Okay, he knew eventually he would be able to explore them. There were plenty of kinky people out in the world. But he and Angelica just clicked. Even she knew it. She seemed have been born for him to mold into the perfect sexual creature just for him. Such an unintended discovery.Β  But he let her go.

Why? He had too. He knew he could convince her to love cock. Even figured she'd probably get attached to him in some way. What he didn't expect was his reaction to those fucking tears.

She wasn't the only one who started getting attached.

His body demanded she stay. Demanded he keep her. He could have. He had her wrapped around his finger, his cock. Just the smallest of hints that he wanted her to stay would be enough to get her back. But, for once, he thought about her own needs.

She deserved better than him. Of course she deserved better. He was an absolute bastard. A sicko. Her rapist. He could make all the excuses he wanted, but he knew he raped her. He forced her to sexually explore his own sexual fantasies. Young once virgin girl thrown into a sexual situation she wasn't prepared for. Sexual situations she probably never thought she'd be in any time soon. And he kept things tamed as best as he could.

He shook his head, annoyed with himself. He should have kept her. She would have stayed and it wouldn't have been by force. It didn't escape his attention, her enthusiasm, her need to please. Her fucking cunt was dripping each time he buried himself in her since yesterday. She'd begun to loosen up yesterday, get more comfortable with him.

While making dinner, she'd talked to him. It was a simple, relaxed, normal conversation. As if she wasn't his victim. His simple, casual touches made her skin rise. He loved it. Love how normal everything seemed. Love how he knew that just hours before she had a plug up her ass. Love how, despite everything seeming normal, he was going to bend her over the kitchen table and take her ass or cunt when he was good and ready.

Jerry plopped down on his sofa and let out a deep, loud groan, covering his face with his hand as he leaned his head back. Having her stay brought up a new set of problems he wasn't sure he wanted to deal with.

"I don't deserve it." Fuck. That hurt. He wasn't entirely sure why. He wasn't her boyfriend or husband. And yet, he wanted to hold her tightly and tell her she deserved so much more than she thought. How could she not deserve praise? So eager to please, she added her own rapist to her list. Did they not notice the brightness in her eyes at the compliments? The swell of her chest, the power she seemed to feel. How could the man who took her freedom and control away for a weekend be the only one to want to apparently praise her?

So eager to please.

"We wouldn't have worked out," he grumbled to himself. He didn't have enough time to give her the confidence she needed to stay with him. They'd be over before they even began. He wouldn't always be around her at the start. He couldn't take over that role as her guardian and protector until they were more stable. Until she came to live with him. And it was far too early to think about that. He did like her.

There was another problem. She was going off to the university. It was one a few hours from his home. It was less the going without sex for a week or so that bothered him and more the idea that she would be surrounded by boys her age. Her innocence made her an easy target.

Although, it would be a bit of fun to let his jealousy shine. Fuck her in a bought of jealousy at the mere thought that she might have flirted with a boy her age. Just to remind her whose cock she craved in her ass, pussy and mouth.

He let out a deep sigh. Someone else was going to get to enjoy what he had started to create.

You'll always be her first. She'll always compare others to you. Hell, she'd probably go through a few boys before she found the right one who would satisfy her newly found kinks. Or maybe she wouldn't. Maybe she'd settle for a vanilla type of guy, close the part of her that he opened up.

It would be a damn shame if she did. God! Watching her struggle was fucking hot as shit. What a lucky son-of-a-bitch her future partner was going to be.

He rubbed his face with his hands.

But, what if she found someone worse than him? Yes, he forced her to do things she didn't want to do. He may have been rough and hurt her, but he didn't want to break her. He made sure he didn't go too far. So fragile. She wasn't quite strong enough. Someone else would hollow her out inside.

That thought annoyed him. Angered him. Frustrated him.

"Fucking shit," he growled as he stood up. It was just supposed to be about sex. He was only meant to manipulate her to be fond enough with him to not go to the cops. He'd fucked up somewhere, because he'd grown fond of her too. A little too fond. Feelings of protecting her from that swirled inside of him. She was so great at the struggle, at the fight to be dominated only to eventually give in. And then, when she finally gave in, she was a little seductress. Her young lithe body had awoken the horny teenager in him.

"Not your problem."

He was being silly. Although, those morning tears fascinated him. She didn't want to leave? They both knew she had to. They both knew that it wouldn't have worked out. It was just a weekend of sex. He really shouldn't have gotten more intimate. He added just a little bit of kink because he had to watch her struggle. Maybe he should have let her fail and come without his say-so. So she could hate him for withholding his cock from her. Leave her unsatisfied to tempt her to come back.

"No," he said softly, shaking his head. It would have left him unsatisfied as well. Besides, he saw it in her face, the clear distress. She wouldn't hate or blame him. She'd blame herself. Internalize her "failure" even more, adding to the shit that was already in there. He didn't want her to be more broken. He'd added enough to her internal turmoil. He liked her.

He figured he'd give her one parting gift. Help ease the storm in her mind just a little bit by telling her he couldn't get her pregnant. Although, it did amuse him that she already wasn't worried and had lied to him about being on birth control. Actually, it made him want to punish her somehow for lying like that.

Copper jumped up on the couch and laid down by his side. He scratched the dog's side and looked down at him.

"She'll move on," he said, feeling pretty sure of him. "She's smart. She'll realize I fucked her up. Bet you she's already cursing up a storm in her car, calling me all sorts of names."

The dog just panted in reply.

It was back to work in the morning. Back to life. Back to searching for someone like her. He let out a sigh. No one was going to be like her. He was going to miss that ass. He could mold her to be his ideal, perfect partner.

He looked down at his old dog Copper. "Just the four of us again," he muttered. "Chinese tonight?"

He let out his younger more rambunctious dogs and ordered delivery, before returning to the couch and turning on the TV.

It was just sex. That's all it was. A weekend of kinky, explorative sex. A weekend of sex that he had planned on having with his date and ended up having with Angelica instead. Sex that wouldn't have happened if he hadn't noticed her. If he wasn't so pissed off and horny that he focused on everything else but her words.

His cock started to bother him as his mind brought up the way she looked handcuffed to his bed. Damn, how would she look completely tied down with a gag in her mouth? Did he have time to rub one out before the delivery guy arrived?

A knock on the door answered his question.

He got up and grabbed his wallet from the coffee table to give a cash tip. His food was going to get cold, but oh well.

"Keep the-" the rest of his words got caught in his throat.

Angelica looked up at him. Her eyes glistened a little and were slightly puffy as if she'd been crying.

"Hi," she said.

You shouldn't be here.

"Angelica," he said softly, shaking his head. He leaned against the door, clenching his fingers for a moment to keep himself from reaching out.

You're making a mistake.

"I...Β  Can I come in?"

No.

His body moved of its own accord. He stepped back, allowing her to enter. She hesitated.

Good. Go.

Then walked inside and closed the door behind her.

"We're not going to work out," he stated coldly as he crossed his arms over his chest. You can't mentally handle it in the long run.

She looked at the floor for a moment. "You said, you think," she finally said, raising her brown eyes to look into his blue ones.

"What?" he asked, confused.

"You've-" she paused for a moment, shifted her feet and looked down at the ground again. "You've always been so sure. Your statements. Your commands. But, you said you think I should go home."

He hadn't noticed. The part of him that didn't want her to leave slipped into his speech. He narrowed his eyes. She wasn't thinking this through. She wasn't thinking about how wrong and fucked up the whole situation was. What he'd done to mentally screw her up even more.

He shook his head again. The moment she got home, she'd figure it out. Or, someone would point it out to her.

"I'm much older than you," he said. Those weren't the words he wanted to say. He wanted to get into what a horrible person he was. That she'd get over him once she got home to her parents. She'd realize. She just needed some time to process. He wouldn't apologize though for what he did. He couldn't. He loved their fucking weekend and what he was turning her into. It was going to be a memory he'd bring up over and over again while touching himself.

"And I'm much younger than you," she said.

He ran his fingers through his hair. "Your parents are going to give you a hard time." That was the real problem.

He had it easy. He didn't care what people thought of him. After all, it was just him in the end. He had no family to worry about, some friends, but he could always make more. But she looked up to her authoritative figures. Their relationship would be done before it even started. The moment she got home and explained that she was dating a much older man, they'd make her see her error and she'd break up with him.

"They always give me a hard time," she replied, shrugging her shoulders. Her eyes studied him for a moment.

He couldn't help but look skeptical. He had his doubts she could even handle the scrutiny she'd face about dating an older man. Especially from her parents. She craved their validation. They wouldn't approve of it, of him. Didn't matter that he had a good job. His own house. They never really cared for him. They loved his wife, but they didn't really see eye to eye with him.Β  They'd think he manipulated her and possibly raped her to get into a relationship with her.

They wouldn't be wrong. Although, the relationship wasn't a goal. He wasn't entirely sure he had the time needed to strengthen that part of her while simultaneously digging himself deeper into her mentality.

"If you don't want me, command me to leave," she said. The firmness in her voice surprised him. No, she wasn't just saying, she was demanding.

He took her control away for the weekend because he needed to for his own survival. Naw, not his survival, because he wanted to fuck her. Because he wanted to explore some fantasies of his and she was the perfect victim.

But then you had to go and realize she's fucking perfect for you. This won't end well.

He shook his head. He didn't think she'd fall for him, much less come back seeking a relationship with her rapist. It was just about sex.

"Angelica. You're going to want to explore other options. You won't have time to see me. You'll be in another State. Long distance relationships are hard to keep, especially at your age. You'll be around a bunch of guys your age."

Maybe, he was thinking more about himself. Getting emotionally attached to her, only to have her leave him because she found someone else at her university. Best not to suffer that. It was just supposed to be about sex.

She nodded her head and looked away for a moment, before returning her brown eyes off his blue ones.

"Command me to leave," she repeated.

He narrowed his eyes. Dropping his arms to his sides, he took a step toward her. She automatically walked back till she hit the door behind her. He placed one hand by her head and leaned in.

"There is so much more I want to explore, Angelica," he stated, dropping his voice, making him sound dangerous. He had to give her more reasons to leave because he could not tell her too. He didn't want her to leave.

"Will you force me to do things I really don't like?" Her brown eyes searched his face for answers.

What a silly question. She was asking the man who raped her and forced her to stay the weekend if he'd force her. He gave her a look.

Yes.

"Jerry?" she asked. "I mean, I really don't like. If we tried it and I told you firmly that I didn't like it."

His eyes widened slightly at the question

"Will you break me?" she asked. The way she said it, he could tell it was an amendment to her last question.

Never.

"If I wanted you broken you would be broken," he stated. The words slipped out before he could stop them, but they both knew that was true. He couldn't help but brush his fingers through her silky long brown hair for a moment that rested on her shoulder.

Their eyes met. He didn't want her broken. In fact, there was a part of him that wanted her to have more confidence, more power in the outside world. More power that he could take from her as he dominated her.

"Command me to leave," she repeated.

Leave! Before it's too late.

He grabbed her face. His fingers wrapped around her head to pull her in roughly. His lips met her soft ones with a fierceness as he kissed her rough and deep. Desperate. His heart pounded in his chest. His cock strained in his pants, demanding he let it out and fuck her. Claim her. That's what she wanted.

Her hands pressed against his chest, almost as if she wanted to push him back.

Do it.

All he needed was one excuse. One simple "no". He could do it now. Listen to that "no" even though it meant "yes". Push her away and out the door.

Just say "no".

Her hands went down to his pants as she desperately and blindly unbuckled his belt. Her warm fingers pressed against his stomach, before trailing down and slipping under his boxers. He groaned in delight as she grasped his hardened cock, firmly stroking him.

He released her mouth, still cupping her face, he pressed his lips on her cheek.

"You don't want this," he whispered before kissing her cheek. How dramatically opposite the scene was playing out compared to Friday night.

His cock pulsed and twitched, demanding her. The problem was, once he gave in that would be it for him, for her. It wouldn't just be sex.

She let him go. His body cried out in frustration. Leaning back, her eyes gazed into his. They shone with unshed tears.

"You don't want me," she stated. Her voice cracked and the muscles in her throat tensed as she swallowed. "I... I need to hear it. Please. It'll hurt. But tell me you don't want me. Command me to go away."

He placed his hands on either side of her and leaned in, resting his forehead on hers.

You don't know what you're getting yourself into. Remember what I did. This will make you mine.

"How can I not want you, Angelica?"

All mine.

"You're hot."

He kissed her forehead.

"You're sexy."

He kissed her cheek.

"You're perfect."

He kissed her mouth. He couldn't help but slip his hand down her stomach into her pants to feel her vulva. He slipped his fingers into her folds and groaned.

"My cock craves you as much as you crave it." I crave you. He pulled his hand out to show her his wet fingers. Not that she needed to see. She knew how turned on she was.

"Fuck me, please," she begged.

"Okay, Little Angel," he said with a nod. He pulled off his shirt as she pulled off her own. He paused for a moment and watched as she desperately took off her pants. Glancing up, she froze.

He didn't let doubt or nerves settle in on her. He put his hands under her armpits and lifted her up with ease. She wrapped her legs around his waist and looked down at him.

"How did I get so lucky?" he asked, moving her hair back with his free hand while he supported her ass with his other arm.

Her face was already flushed, her breathing deep with desire. But her cheeks turned a deeper shade of red. He teased her with his cock and she reached below to grasp him and led him to her entrance. He groaned as her familiar, delightfully tight walls gripped him and pulled at him. She let him go and put her arm on his neck.

He slammed home, groaning as her warm pussy enveloped him. Her legs squeezed him and her fingers dug into his back as she clung to him.

"Fuck," she whimpered.

"This tight pussy was made for my cock," he growled in her ear.

She hugged him tightly, as if she was worried he'd pull her off him. "Yes," she whimpered.

He lifted her up and let gravity slam her back down. Her smaller, lighter body made it easy for him. Her loud moans of pleasure by his ear drove him wild. She was perfect. Her ass fit perfectly in his hands.

"Legs on my shoulders," he commanded.

She easily moved them up. She cried out. Her legs tensed. Her body shivered and her inner walls rippled along his cock as she came. Her eyes focused on his, distress crossed her face. She truly needed him. He was barely fucking her before her orgasm exploded.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like