Now thoroughly wiped out, the girls and I staggered upstairs to the master bedroom, collapsed on the huge king sized bed and promptly passed out.
A couple hours later I awoke to find myself spooning Meghan with my rapidly hardening cock resting between those wonderful teenage buns. I started to do a slow grind in her crack, but she turned over quickly, saying
"No way, I'm sore as hell right now!" She slapped my hands away playfully and did some sort of cat stretch that had to be seen to be believed.
Michelle and Elise were up now, Elise quietly and smoothly into my arms as she clung tightly to me, Michelle of course going right for my dick as she knelt over me, stroking it slowly. I tried to slide her into position, but she twisted out of my grip, saying
"Not a chance, cowboy. I need like a week to recover." She gave my dick a long slow lick and added
"Someone still has a virgin butt!" she laughed, but the statement hung there for a moment as Elise froze stiff in my arms.
"Yeah, that's true." Said Meghan as she took my dick from Michele, continuing to stroke it slowly and allowing my girlfriend's little sister to slide up next to Elise, whispering in her ear and roaming her hands all over her ass and tits from behind. She soon slid downwards as she used her mouth on the younger girl's most private regions.
She added a little baby oil to the mix and finally sat back, looked over her work like an artisan, seemed satisfied, and presented me with this impossibly tight rear end, glistening and ready to be taken.
Michelle and Meghan then made a long show of applying the oil to my dick, finally pronouncing me ready. There was a long silence.
"I don't know about this." I protested. Even by my own admittedly low standards this was a little crazy. Elise was clearly petrified but so used to going along with whatever the other two girls wanted she didn't know how to say no. Also, she was by now a little bit smitten with me and wanted to make me happy.
Michelle was having none of my complaints, and slowly pulled my dick into position between the shaking young cheerleader's exquisite ass cheeks.