The Usual Disclaimer: This is a work of fantasy. All characters featured in sexual situations are over 18. The characters in these stories are fictional. Any resemblance to actual persons living, dead or undead is purely coincidental. Do not try this at home.
Thanks to Aurora for helping me work out the details of this sequel, and to Geek_Writer and Gobred for their assistance in making the story more consistent. Naturally, I have to thank Joseph again for the original story prompt and for his constant encouragement. Thanks, bud!
This story picks up right where the first left off.
* * * * *
Sharon couldn't get that one night with Frank out of her head, and it was killing her. Every time she saw him in the hallways or in front of the school, she shuddered. Her mind immediately replayed the way he had taken her, the way his mouth had driven her to distraction. Her pussy and her asshole both twitched and flexed as she recalled the way he had filled them up with his thick cock.
She had hoped her fiancΓ© could make love to her the same way, but that had not gone well. Jack was a great guy, but he just didn't have what it took to be like Frank. Jack had been delighted when Sharon offered her sweet ass, but it had been awful for her when he actually took it. The first time, he took her dry with no lubrication at all. It had hurt like hell for both of them. The second time, he used lubeβfar too much of itβand then he came almost instantly inside her.
He still refused to lick her pussy, but he wanted her tight asshole every time they were together after that. Sharon thought that asking him to be a little rougher might do the trick, but that was a disaster. Jack just had no skill at being rough. Either he hurt her terribly and then tried to apologize for it, or it came across as some lame role-play. It hadn't been good for Jack, either, and they had agreed to "take a break."
Their engagement was off.
She might have been happy to be free of Jack, but now Frank was clearly off the market. He only had eyes for Sarah. Sharon had been thinking of little else since that one night with Frank. She wondered how it might have gone differently if she had just told him how amazing it had been, thanked him, and begged him for more. Sharon had nothing against Sarah, but she wanted Frank.
She was desperate for more.
What was worse for her was that she began to suspect that Desiree was also getting some of Frank's amazing loving. She knew that Desiree had looked at Frank the same way she had, and suddenly Desiree was walking around on cloud nine. Clearly she was getting some amazing sex, but she refused to talk about it.
Then Sharon saw the two of them exchange a knowing glance in the hall and a secretive smile. Her eyes widened, and she was sure of it. Frank was fucking Desiree! She actually
liked
Desiree, but she was outraged that she was being left out. Mostly, she was mad at herself. If she had just managed to say the right thing after that first amazing time with Frank, then she would be the one getting pounded by him every night, instead of Sarah and Desiree.
She was wrong, of course. Those knowing glances were just because Frank had watched Raul making love to Desiree right there in her classroom, and Desiree had seen him looking. Raul gave Desiree everything she had ever desired, and she knew Frank was protecting their secret.
Even though Sharon had misinterpreted that exchange, it gave her the determination to do something. She steeled her resolve and marched up to Frank right after school let out.
"Frank, I really need to talk to you," she said.
He had just emerged from the library, and he looked around at all the kids passing them in the hallway.
"Oh, hi Sharon," he said uncomfortably.
She leaned in close to him and whispered, "It's personal. I don't want anyone to overhear. Can you come to my classroom so we can talk?"
"I don't think that's a good idea," he murmured.
"Please?" she begged. "Just give me five minutes."
Frank sighed and looked around again, then glanced at his watch. "Give me about twenty minutes, and I'll be there."
He chewed his lip for a moment as he watched her walk away. Unlike Sarah, who wore such conservative and loose-fitting clothes, Sharon's snug, fuzzy sweaters and form-fitting skirts really showed off the curves of her body. It was impossible for him to look at her now without picturing her naked and moaning as he fucked her in his apartment. After all, it hadn't been that long ago. She disappeared into the press of students and teachers in the hallway, and Frank had a sinking feeling that she would be trouble.
He blew out a long breath and focused on everyone else in the hallways as he made his rounds.
* * *
Sharon was fidgeting nervously at her desk when Frank knocked at her door and poked his head inside. Her heart leapt in her chest when she saw him.
"Please, come in," she said, getting up out of her seat.
Frank stepped in, pushing the door open wide. Sharon shook her head and walked over. Her eyes pleaded with him as she carefully closed the door.
"Please, Frank," she whispered, "I don't want anyone to hear me. It would be embarrassing."
He chewed on the inside of his cheek, regarding her narrowly. Then he gave a curt nod. As soon as the door closed he said, "What do you want, Sharon?"
"I want..." she swallowed heavily, and her voice was still barely above a whisper. "I want to apologize, Frank."
He jerked his head back slightly in surprise. His eyes were still narrowed in suspicion. "Apologize?" he asked. "Why do you think you need to apologize to me?"
"I never thanked you, Frank. You were amazing. I just...I never knew it could be like that, and my mind was a complete mess." She had been leaning back against a desk, but she leaned forward and started pacing as she continued. "At first, I was shocked and I wanted to be mad at you. You took my virgin asshole like it belonged to you, without even asking."
"Oh," Frank uttered. His eyes widened in surprise at that revelation. Then he thought,
Wait, why is she apologizing to me, then?
Sharon shook her head at the recollection. "At first, I wanted to cry out, to tell you 'no!' to try and stop you. I just couldn't catch my breath to say anything after the way you had made me come. By the time I could say anything, I was shocked." She turned and looked at him with heat in her eyes. "It was absolutely amazing, and I had never imagined it could be anything like that. When you were finished with meβ" she shuddered, "I was such a wreck I didn't know what to say. So I left."