I got dressed as quick as I could and wiped my face on the sheet. Both were sopping wet with cum. My head spun as I snuck straight upstairs to the bathroom and showered. I made it quick, but felt my poor ass. It was stretched and burned like hell. I can't believe what had happened. I got dressed and ran downstairs. Even after all I had tonight, I needed a drink! The party was going strong. Everyone was wasted and having fun. Most of the guys were gathered in the kitchen talking.
Joey: "... that whore knew what she wanted. She was sucking my cock then told me she had always wanted to be fucked up the ass!"
David: "What the fuck? I can't believe I missed it! I've never had a girl who would even try it. What a whore. And she liked it?"
Joey: "She fucking loved it. Barely take it at first, but I broke that bitch in. I think she was a virgin. Haha. Not anymore."
They all laughed and a couple high fived Joey.
David: "And now she just left? When will we get her back? I need a turn."
Joey: "A dumb slut like that will be back. Stupid bitch begged me to take the condom off and give it to her raw. A cumslut like that will be wanting it again."
I couldn't believe he was telling everyone what a slut I had been. It wasn't even true. Except that I had been a virgin. At least my ass was. I couldn't believe I had this cocky fuck's dick in my ass. What the fuck? He had tricked me like some dumb sorority slut. But he actually fucked me in that dirty basement spot. Even the sluts wouldn't do that. I'm not some fag or some girl. All the guys were laughing about something when David saw me.
David: "Yo, I heard you got in there first! How was it? Could you tell who the basement whore was? She'll be the most popular bitch in school if we can figure it out."
I faked a laugh "I don't know who it was, but she sucked my dick pretty good."
They all laughed and high fived me as Brian walked up, totally wasted.
Brian: "Still trying to figure out who the bitch in the basement was? Well she sucks dick better than most. Course I had to test out her sweet ass. I think I might have broke her." He laughed. "At least I won't get her pregnant."
Joey: "She was purring for dick. Did you really cum in her?"
Brian: "The cunt was begging for it. She was so disgusting. The bitch came while I fucked her ass. I could feel her tighten up on my dick. So I just dumped in her. Fuck that bitch. She got what she deserved. I even sent her home with a parting gift. Not only does she have my load up her ass, she didn't even realize. But she'll find it eventually. And I saw what you left her Joey. I almost died when I noticed you had fucked a rubber right up in her. Dirty bitch had a used condom in her ass. I figured I'd add a little more jizz." He grabbed his crotch and laughed as he stumbled off. I couldn't believe they were talking about fucking me. This was terrible. Then I realized I was standing there with two loads of cum up my but. AND a dirty used condom. I was going to be sick. I had a beer and went to bed and cried a bit. My ass was so sore and still felt loose.
I woke up the next morning and my roommate Robbie was up getting ready. He was a sophomore, but as big as a house. He played on the football team, so everyone liked him. But we all gave him a hard time about being a 6'6 virgin. But for a corn fed hick, he was a fine roommate. He asked right away if I had got head from the "house slut". I guess that's what everyone called her. "I heard she got fucked by Joey and Brian. God, I wish I got in there. I'm ready to lose my V card. Or at least get some head. Shit, how was it?"
"I got a BJ. It was great. But I don't know if I'd believe everything the guys say. Especially Joey. Plus we can't even know who she was." I said.