I couldn't believe the night still wasn't over yet, but I slowly nodded and felt Will direct me towards the bed. Will laid himself on the bed on his back and instructed me to straddle him. I did and I felt Sir come up behind me.
"Be gentle at first, Will, let her get used to it. She's never done it before," I heard Sir tell Will.
Will replied, "Oh I'll go slow," and winked at me. That wink scared me but I was glad that Sir was behind me and I was on top of Will; how much harm could Will possibly instill upon me when I was on top of him?
"I'm going to walk you through this, love," Sir said to me. I nodded. "Do exactly as I say, when I say it, okay baby?" I nodded again in response. "Good girl. Now slowly lower yourself onto Will's cock; let it go into that wonderful cunt of yours."
I nodded again and slowly lowered myself onto Will's semi-hard cock. I felt it stiffen inside me as I lowered myself more, letting his cock finally go all the way into willing pussy.
"Very good, now ride his cock, love. Ride his cock slow at first, and when I tell you to speed up, you will speed up, understand?"
I nodded and raised myself up, letting almost all of his cock expel from my pussy. I lowered myself down again and felt Will's hands reach up to grasp my hips.
"Not yet, Will. Let me do this for a little while, then you can have your way with her," Sir said to Will.
"Okay, okay," Will replied.
"Keep going, baby. Ignore him," Sir said gently to me. I nodded and started to lift myself up and down, creating a slow rhythm. I felt Sir's hands reach around me and fondle my nipples, making me wetter than before.
"Go faster now, love," Sir whispered into my ear as he began to lick my earlobe and neck. I complied, and sped up my thrusting. I had to admit, I really liked this so far. Up, down, up, down, I bounced off of Will's cock. I felt Sir's cock suddenly rubbing against my ass; just very gently reminding me of its' presence. I started to get nervous, but Sir calmed me when he said, "Relax baby. I'm going to make this pleasurable for all of us, I promise." I smiled and kept my steady rhythm.
When I had started to feel another fire kindle inside my loins, Sir whispered into my ear, "I think it's time for you to feel my cock inside you as well, don't you?" as he licked up my ear.
I moaned and responded, "Yes, Sir. I think I'm ready," even though I knew I wasn't really ready. I was surprised that Will had remained almost silent underneath me; besides a few moans every now and then he hadn't said a word to me, and that was how I liked it. I felt Sir's cock head press against my asshole.
"Lean forward, love," Sir said to me. "Help my cock get inside your wonderful asshole again." I leaned forward slightly and put my hands on Will's chest. I looked into Will's eyes and prepared myself for Sir's cock once more. He tried to push into my asshole, but couldn't get his head inside. He leaned down and spat on my asshole, that being the only kind of lubrication handy. "Help me, love. Push out for me like you did the first time," he said.
I pushed my asshole out as he pressed his head against my asshole. I bit my bottom lip and clasped my eyes shut to try and hide the intense pain this was causing. His cock head popped in past my sphincter and I couldn't help but lean forward and almost make his cock exit. I let out a whimper of discomfort and pain as Sir started pushing forward more. He had his hands on my hips and was pulling me back to him.
"Ahh! Sir, please, take your cock out! I can't take two! I just can't!" I screamed at him.
"Shh, hush now little one," he replied.
"No! I can't take two, Sir!" I said as I pulled myself forward and forced his cock to exit my burning asshole.
"Come here, cunt!" Sir screamed at me as he pulled my hips back towards him. He pushed his cock into my asshole once more and I again pulled myself forward enough to make it exit yet again. I felt his hand slap my ass and he said, "Alright, I was trying to be gentle with you, but now Will is going to punish you. Get up and stand beside the bed while we decide your punishment." I let a tear fall down my cheek as I got up after he did. Will got up and stood next to Sir. They began talking quietly, but I couldn't distinguish anything they were saying. I was very scared now; Sir had said that Will was to punish me. Sir had already punished me once and it was horrible; I didn't want to know what Will's punishments felt like.