This story was originally categorized incorrectly. Therefore, the second submission. I ask my readers to be patient about the arc of the story... Thank you for reading.
____________________________________
Lori woke up in sharp pain. She felt disoriented. What the hell was going on? Her head was hurting but there was a sharper pain.
It took her only seconds to realize she was under him and he was entering her ass. His cock must've been half in already. It must've been his cockhead popping in that woke her.
She was about to scream.
But he stopped. He softly whispered, "No one is here and screaming won't help. So I am going to give you a choice."
He slowly caressed her hair. Blew softly on the back of her neck.
"Look I could've taken you like the rest of them while you were drunk and not feeling anything."
Her eyes got bigger. What did he mean? And that's when she realized it. Her pussy seemed to be leaking cum and there was dried cum all over her landing strip, inner thighs stomach and tits.
"Here are your choices. I can take your ass just as we are. You pinned down. No lube but my spit. Or.."
She screamed.
"Hush. I told you that won't help."
She screamed again. Called out.
He let her. "Scream one more time and you don't get the other choice." He pushed his cock in her ass a bit more to drive the point.
"NNNNGHHHHHh owwwwww. Please stop."
"Then listen to me, Lori Eryka Featherston ."
She stopped screaming. Oh my god, he knows her name. Does he really know her?
"Or... I can turn you over... Lube you up. Rub your pussy and clit to help ease the pain of losing your anal cherry. And I promise to be a lot more gentle... Mostly."
How did he know she's an anal virgin? How does he know her?
He ran his fingers through her hair again. Caressed her cheek with the back of his hand.
"Should I keep driving in or turn you over? Choose wisely."
Lori surprised herself when she quietly said, "Turn me over."
"Good girl. Well chosen." He pulled out of her ass and it hurt. She closed her eyes from the sharp pain.
He turned her over and grabbed her hands and cuffed them to the bed.
"Oh, you thought you'd use your kickboxing skills to throw me off, did you?"
Goddamn it, he does know her.
It surprised her when he offered her water.
"Your head must be hurting. Drink this and take these."
Advil. Really? Was he nursing her or trying to violate her ass? The ass that every single boyfriend had wanted since high school. The ass that even her husband hasn't had yet.
The overhead spotlight shining down on her made it hard to make out his face still. But now she could see that he's dark skinned. Indian? Mediterranean? Middle Eastern? She ran through names in her mind... Vijay? Wissam? Alexander?
She took the Advil and drunk the water as he held up the bottle and slowly tilted it. After she drunk the water, she felt him rubbing her down with a warm washcloth. He cleaned up the dry cum all over her body. He got up and turned off the spotlight. Then he lit a candle on each of the bed stands.
WHAT THE FUCK IS HE DOING? He's about to violate my virginal ass and he's making it romantic? WHAT THE FUCK? WHO THE FUCK?
He cleaned up her pussy with the washcloth. Then he started rubbing her pussy lips. Rolling them with his fingers. Squeezing the outer lips.
To her surprise, she felt herself getting moist.
He slowly parted her pussy and she felt his fingers slowly spreading her lips... And then...
A finger sliding in.
He reclined next to her as his fingers continued to do their work. He played with her hair and rubbed her earlobe. Then he softly kissed her neck and planted a few more all over her upper chest.