"No more stalling, bitch."
Jake's eyes locked with Natalie's and the naked redhead felt a thrill of fear shoot up her spine as Jake clasped her wrist and removed her hand from his cock.
'Oh god, he's going to fuck me now,' she thought. A burst of arousal and anticipation vied with shame and dread. Her boyfriend Mike had already seen her fuck two other cocks tonight, but those had been his close friends, his roommates, and he'd been on board with the kinky idea behind it before she'd set everything in motion. This was different.
"Hold on, baby. Before you fuck the little bitch, don't forget to take your medicine," Rachel purred. Jake's girlfriend and chief enabler now walked up to her man with a bottle of water and handed him a pair of white pills. "Let's keep you hard tonight," she added with a seductive grin. Jake popped the pills into his mouth and gulped then down with a quick swig.
"Thanks babe. Give this slut's pencil-dicked boyfriend some too. We want him hard while you play with him tonight."
Rachel smirked. "Believe me, baby, I was planning on it." She turned back to Mike, who still sat on Carter's bed naked with his wrists tied behind his back. Rachel drew out two more pills and ordered Mike to open. Natalie's captive boyfriend obeyed, accepting the water from the bottle Rachel tipped to his lips.
"There now. That's better, isn't it?" Rachel purred. She then proceeded to strip out of her fleece and clothing... all except for a lacy thong, dark as ebony, which seemed to taunt Mike's gaze and leave little to the imagination as it hugged her hips and just barely hid her sex.
"Wh-what a-are you going to do with me?" Mike stammered as he watched the pale brunette's breasts sway before him. She knelt down and clasped the base of his cock, pumping it with her hand.
"That depends on you. That depends on if you behave like a good little boy or not," she added with a husky tone. She indicated the action about to unfold over her shoulder. "I'll punish you if you don't play nice. Got it?"
Mike licked his lips. His mouth had gone bone dry. "W-what do you want me to do?"
"For starters, watch my man fuck your girl senseless." Rachel's smirk had returned, dark as night. Saying this, Rachel took Mike's glasses off the shelf and re-positioned them on his face so he could watch every second of it with perfect clarity.
Meanwhile, Jake hadn't wasted any time.
"Turn around, slut."
Natalie almost yelped as the big football captain spun her around. She felt a hand in her hair grabbing the scrunchy which kept her ponytail in place. He drew it from her hair with surprising care. Soon her wavy red tresses were falling down to just below her shoulders. He spun her back around to face him.
"That's more like it," Jake said. "You look sexier with your hair down, bitch." He gestured at his stiff erection. "Now climb on, you cute cunt. Bust your pussy and give your boyfriend the show you know he wants to see."
'Please let us go!' That was the plea that died before it could leave Natalie's lips. She was too afraid of what would happen to her and Mike if Jake reported them to the RA. Too scared of getting kicked out of housing and of her parents finding out why. It was a set of dominoes that could fall if she didn't do what this bastard demanded of her. More than that, though, a tiny shred of primal femininity embraced what was coming. The petite girl stared at that turgid, vein-engorged shaft, all 11 brutal inches of it. She jumped up into his arms with surprising confidence and grace and lassoed her arms around his neck. Then she felt the bulbous tip of his cock start to press against her labia. She looked into her blackmailer's eyes.
"Mmmm. That's it, bitch. Lower yourself. I changed my mind - I'm in no hurry after all," he groaned. Readjusting her grip on Jake's neck, the gorgeous freshman did just that. She slid her wet cunt down the long spear of Jake's manhood. Biting her lip, she found herself stifling the moan that yearned to slip free as her pussy fully sheathed itself with maddening friction along the length of Jake's meat.
"Fuck..." Jake groaned. "This tight pussy is squeezing me good, bitch. Mmm. Now give me a kiss."
What happened next wasn't what Natalie had expected. Instead of the ruthless coupling she'd been dreading, Jake was almost... oddly gentle with her. He tipped his head downward and their lips met. His kiss was passionate but tender, and he let her dictate the pace. Natalie tightened her hands on the back of Jake's neck for leverage, raising and dropping herself. A few moments later, she felt Jake's massive hands sliding beneath her hips, helping support her as she fucked him. The easy melding of their bodies continued at a steady rhythm. She couldn't see Mike, but behind her he had all his attention glued to the scene. Mike could only stare as he watched his girlfriend's ass cheeks descending again and again, her cunt pumping up and down Jake's now shiny cock.
"Mmmm!!! UHHH!!!" The traitorous sounds which tried to escape Natalie's lips were thankfully stifled by the big football player's mouth. This wasn't so bad though. She could live with this. If this was what it took, so be it. Natalie redoubled her efforts. Her hands gripped Jake's neck more firmly. Her pale figure rose and fell a little faster, and she kissed him back now with the enthusiasm of a horny slut. Her supple breasts felt the heat of his body pressing back against her, the girl's nipples bombarded with frissons of sensation as they rubbed against Jake's muscled chest.
"You beautiful bitch, you're enjoying this, aren't you? Keep kissing me. Your cock-squeezing paradise belongs around my dick and nowhere else," the football player growled.
"Yes, Sir," Natalie panted. And then her tongue found his again, and the taste of him made tatters of her thoughts.
But not everyone was enjoying themselves. Rachel had been frowning, and now that frown only deepened.
"Apparently Jake's in a romantic mood. This is no fun. No fun AT ALL," she groused as she eyed Mike. Mike now became hyper-aware of the dominatrix woman's fierce gaze. "And YOU, you little shit. You're having too much fun watching your girlfriend getting all lovey-dovey with my boyfriend. I think you need punishment."
"B-but I've done everything you asked. I'm c-c-cooperating," Mike whined. It didn't do him much good though. Soon Rachel was sifting through her duffel bag for toys. First, she pulled out a red rubber ball-gag with a cock-shaped end on it. She proceeded to force it between the freshman boy's lips and then fastened it on tight. Mike groaned as he felt his jaw begin to ache.
"There, that should shut up your pathetic whining," Rachel hissed. Next, she pulled him upright from the mattress and proceeded to pull out a toy even more terrifying and dread-inducing. She held up a long, pink silicone dildo with a wide base that ended with a curve of two lifelike testicles. The brunette proceeded to attach the base of the dildo to the low nightstand beside Carter's mattress. Then she drew out a vial of a heavily scented oil - the smell of peppermint hit Mike as he watched the sexy girl slather the stuff all up and down the pink shaft.
"UHHH!!!! UHHH!!!!" He looked at her, shaking his head.
"Yeah, you know what's coming, my little pencil-dicked slave," she said with a smirk. "This cock is going up your ass. You're going to sit on it now, slave. Sit and WATCH as your girlfriend gets fucked."
Mike tried to struggle, but it was no use. The nerdy, almost rail-thin freshman was no match for the strong, curvy senior. Rachel was a tough woman, beautiful but fierce, and she soon had the helpless, 18-year-old, glasses-wearing boy easing his ass onto the artificial pink penis.
Mike groaned loudly. He tried to keep out the foreign object, but eventually his sphincter muscles gave out and he felt it pop inside him. With tears streaming down his face, he tried to acclimate to the strange sensation of unbearable fullness. He squeezed his eyes shut with another mighty groan and began to sob.
"SSSHHH. It's not so bad, Pencil Dick. Hmmm. Yes, I think that's your new name, slave," Rachel taunted. But she eased his discomfort now too. Kneeling before him, the girl slid her thong down to her ankles and off altogether. She then proceeded to lap gently at the tip of Mike's erection. Soon the crown of Mike's manhood was glistening, bathed in the woman's saliva. Rachel fondled Mike's balls and continued to lick tenderly up and down the sides of Mike's manhood as he panted and trembled.
"Mmmm. Feels good, doesn't it boy? You love that cock in your ass while I torment your tiny dick, don't you?"
Mike's comparatively smaller but by no means paltry 7-inch shaft was fully elongated now. He couldn't help himself. He felt ashamed and horny and awful and intoxicated with need, all at the same time. He felt disoriented and confused and tortured beyond belief. All he could do now was miserably stare at Natalie's display. He could see the seal of his girlfriend's cunt lips now leaking little streams of Jake's pre-cum, off-white tributaries of liquid which trickled down the football player's cock and even oozed down to make those balls glisten too.
"Mmmm. He's gonna CUM in that pussy soon, Pencil Dick. How jealous are you?" There was laughter in Rachel's voice. She redoubled her efforts. For the first time, she fully engulfed him in her mouth. Mike looked down with shock and alarm as Rachel looked up at him and smothered his cock between her lips. Her mouth slid down, nearly bottoming out on him as her hands slid upward to pinch his nipples.
"UGGGHHH!!!" The feeling of fullness in his ass had abated to a dull yet persistent ache as he felt the heavenly warmth and wetness of her mouth on him.
Mike couldn't hold it. He desperately wanted to, but he couldn't. He was helpless. Utterly at this woman's mercy. He stared at Natalie's petite naked figure clinging to the massive bulk of the football player, impaling herself on that raging shaft. He imagined all the sperm housed in those big, jostling testicles soon finding its way deep inside his girlfriend's pussy, possibly impregnating her despite the birth control she was on. For some reason that thought sent him over the edge, the idea that he was watching the sexy girl he loved getting impregnated against her will.
'What's wrong with me?!' Mike thought in despair, and yet the flood of pleasure overwhelmed any sense guilt and replaced it with sheer bliss. He groaned and trembled now, his toes curling as he came. His shaft gushed its sticky treasure down Rachel's throat. The brunette kept gently squeezing the freshman's balls until the last drop had been emptied. Then she sat back on her haunches and showed him his creamy load in all its glory, a sticky mess still not yet swallowed after all, globs of white coating her tongue and the insides of her mouth.
