It started out as something completely innocent. OK, well maybe not 'innocent' exactly. But that night as the winds howled outside and snow covered every inch of campus, Natalie had no inkling of how her night was about to unfold.
'Are you sure your roommates will be gone by then?' she texted her boyfriend, Mike.
Mike fired back a reply. 'I'm sure. They're getting ready to leave. Just come on over.'
Until they weren't. Natalie had a sinking feeling in her stomach the moment she entered the third floor of Bueller Hall and heard the sounds of voices arguing. Her boyfriend's dorm room door stood ajar, so as she neared she could hear practically everything.
"Sorry, dawg, we ain't goin,'" said a gruff, deep rumble of a voice. Instantly Natalie knew who that was. That was Mike's roommate, Carter. Carter was a big, black, broad-shouldered offensive lineman who played for the football team. His flat, Neanderthal-like face belied his intelligence, and he was a better student than Mike though many people wrongly assumed the reverse was true.
"Why not? Who cares if they canceled? Can't you just... I don't know, just go out to eat at least. Do SOMETHING? Isn't there a party somewhere you can go to? One of the frats?" Mike said.
"Look, brother, we were amped up for the esports tournament you told us about, but with the snowstorm throwing it all to shit, we're not going out in this," a second voice protested. That was Kyle, Mike's other roommate. He was a tall, lanky, handsome power forward for the Jaska University basketball team.
Natalie's thoughts raced. Crap, crap, crap. Tonight was supposed to be special. She wanted to have sex with her boyfriend for the first time. Sex for the first time PERIOD. The 18-year-old freshman was a little nervous but also excited. She'd been looking forward to this all week. Friday night - this was supposed to be IT. And now it was all falling apart.
Then a thought struck Natalie. A thought like a thunderbolt. It was outrageous. It was bold. It was... kinky? Slutty? She could think of other words for it. But whatever it was, it just might be a worth a try, if Mike was okay with it. To Natalie's shock, she found herself liking the idea more and more, the more she considered it.
Now, the petite redhead snuck into her boyfriend's dorm room while the three young men argued. The dorm room wasn't anything special. It was just a 14 by 14 rectangular box with a pull-out bed on one side and a bunk bed on the other. Mike usually slept on the upper bunk, with Kyle on the bottom, and the massive bed on the other side was all Carter's, who was the most dominant of the bunch.
"Hey boys, I know I'm interrupting, but do you mind if I borrow Mike for just a sec?"
Carter and Kyle each nodded, their eyes lingering on her beautiful, slender figure. Natalie was a true hottie, her flawless face beyond beautiful with its delicate cheekbones, perfect complexion, and vivid green eyes. She kept her silky red hair tied up in a ponytail. Even the white wolf fleece she wore above her black leggings couldn't hide her girlish figure.
Mike let her pull him outside into the hallway.
"I'm sorry, Nat. They canceled the intramural esports tournament. The guys want to stay in and play video games all night. I can't get them to budge," Mike said, looking both apologetic and miserable at the same time.
Natalie gave her boyfriend the 'look.' The look that told him she was up to something. Suddenly he was cocking his head and staring at her.
"You don't seem all that worried or disappointed. Why?"
Natalie's gaze darted both ways down the hallway as she kept her voice to a whisper.
"What if we could, you know, bribe Carter and Kyle to go out for the night? Like you suggested, what if they went out to have a nice, long dinner, or possibly crash at someone else's dorm for the night."
Mike's face brightened before settling back into confusion. "That sounds awesome, Nat, but how do you expect to get them to agree to that? It's nasty out there and I can't get them to leave our dorm building, much less trek across campus or off campus to eat."
"I was thinking..." Natalie began slowly, looking at her boyfriend to carefully gauge his reaction, "what if I offered to suck them both off?"
Natalie could have sworn that Mike's jaw would have hit the floor if that were possible. That jaw hung slack, and Mike's eyes bulged in shock.
"I mean... you could watch. I thought, I dunno, I thought you might find it kind of a turn-on too... and then once we get your roommates out, the main event can commence," she added slyly, reaching out to run her hand down the front of his pants. A moment later, though, she quickly pulled her hand back.
"But I mean, if you aren't comfortable with that, I obviously won't. I mean, it was just an idea. Mike? Mike, talk to me." A spike of worry now hit her. Maybe Mike thought she was a total slut now. Maybe he hated the idea. Maybe he was the jealous type. Natalie knew how sweet Mike was normally though. He was a great boyfriend, always a gentleman. He was always so considerate of her and he showed he cared about her in a million little ways. Even with old-fashioned stuff, like holding a door open for her when they entered a restaurant.
"S-sorry Nat, I just... I'm just surprised, that's all. I'm just digesting what you just said. I'm not..." his gaze steadied and he looked at her with curiosity rather than even a trace of judgment. "I'm actually not against the idea at all." He leaned over and whispered in her ear. "In fact, you're not wrong, baby. I think the idea is kind of hot."
"You do??" Natalie replied, her tone brightening.
That boyish face nodded. "Absolutely. Watching you pleasure another man actually sounds incredible," he admitted. At that moment, as if to confirm her boyfriend's confession, she looked down and saw a bulge beneath his pants. One hand flew to her mouth and Natalie almost giggled.
"I can see that, Mister," she purred seductively. "But now for the next question: will they go for it?"
"Only one way to find out," Mike quipped, stepping aside with a sweep of his arm that said 'Ladies first.'
When Natalie stepped back into the dorm room, she was immediately greeted by two sets of eyes. It was no secret that both of Mike's roommates found her attractive. She'd caught them sneaking glances and even staring at her now and then all semester. In the two months she and Mike had been dating, she'd come to realize, beyond a shadow of any doubt, that these two guys had the hots for her. She was, as Carter had crudely put it to one of his teammates when he hadn't realized she was within earshot, 'thoroughly fuck-able.'
"Hey guys. So, Mike tells me you had to cancel your plans."
The broad-shouldered football player and the tall, lanky basketball player both nodded.
"That sucks. Listen, I was thinking... I know this is a lot to ask, but I'd really appreciate it if you could give me and my boyfriend some alone time tonight." As she said this, Mike stepped in behind her and closed the door. "Now again, I know that's a lot to ask, but you two and Mike are more than just roommates. You're good friends. And I know that helping a friend get lucky is the kind of thing good friends would do for each other, right?"
Now Carter and Kyle were both looking a little sheepish, but they weren't willing to get thrown out that easily.
"Look, Natalie, we're not trying to cock-block him," Kyle said. "But this is our room, not just his, and we don't feel like getting forced to go nomad tonight, so--"
"What if I could make it worth your while?" Natalie interrupted. Suddenly she found the very interested faces of two young men staring in her direction.
"Here was my thought..." Natalie continued. Now, with every few words she spoke, she began to remove articles of clothing.
"I could give both of you a happy ending before you go. You know, a way to show my appreciation. Mike doesn't mind watching, do you Mike?"
She turned to her boyfriend as she slipped off her fleece and then began to take off the bright pink tank top underneath.
"Not at all," Mike said, his mouth suddenly going dry as he and his roommates saw the slender redhead strip out of her tight blue jeans, socks, and shoes. Now she was standing only in her matching lingerie - a lacy lavender bra and thong.
"My god," Carter groaned. Kyle was speechless, his gaze glued to the spot between her legs, to that wisp of fabric hiding the delicate treasure underneath.
"What kind of happy ending did you have in mind?" Carter blurted. Now, as Natalie's gaze slid to his midnight blue athletics shorts, she saw an unmistakable bulge there not unlike her boyfriend's.