This barely fits in this category as he is definitely not reluctant by the end, but it starts from a place of reluctance.
I had finished work late and went to join the rest of the guys in the pub before heading home. Unfortunately, by the time I made it there, nearly everyone had left. I called Barry a lightweight as he left before going to the bar. It had been a tough day and I just wanted a quick pint before going home. I sat down in the corner table we usually use to nurse my pint for a while and got out my phone.
I'd been there less than five minutes when I felt like someone was looking at me. I looked over to the bar where two girls were glancing in my direction. They were both definitely on the larger side, a bit chubby for my taste. My girlfriend was a gym girl, not much over 5ft tall and petite. That was my type. These girls had curves and some extra jiggly bits. They were both wearing clothes that were a little too tight for them, causing their flesh to spill out. One of them smiled at me and the other waved. I put my head down, ignoring them.
I'm 6ft tall and fairly slim and toned and my girlfriend says I'm an attractive guy, but I don't often pull at a bar so I was surprised when the two girls came over to the table. I didn't think I'd given any indication of interest.
"Hey, can we join you?" One of them asks.
"What's your name?" The other adds.
"I'm John but I was just leaving" I start to get up.
"Don't be rude, John. You're only halfway through that pint." She pushes me back into my seat and I'm taken off guard, stumbling back down. Before I know what's happening she sits down on my lap while her friend sits opposite me. She is heavy but not too heavy and I feel her fat ass squashing down into my lap, pressing against my cock.
"I'm Chantelle and I definitely saw you checking out my sister Kelly at the bar." She starts to rub her ass up and down against my crotch subtly.
"Sorry girls, I'm taken, I've got a girlfriend." I gently try to move Chantelle off my lap, trying to get out of this suddenly uncomfortable situation.
"I bet her tits aren't as big as mine," Kelly pulls her already low top further down. Her big fat tits are bursting out of her big white bra which I can now see the edge of. She leans forward to better display her massive cleavage. Faced with such a brazen display of massive boobs and Chantelle's ass pressing against my crotch, my cock betrays me and attempts to rise, pressing into her big ass. I hope she can't feel it as I will it to get softer.
"Fuck yes, he was definitely checking out your tits Kelly, he's getting hard for you right now!"
Shit, I think, wondering how to extricate myself from this situation. I try to take back control and dignity.
"Well, it's been nice to meet you. I'm going to finish my pint and go now. Have a good evening."
Quick as a flash, Kelly grabs my phone from the table.
"I think you really want to stay with us." She gets up from the table and runs into the toilets nearby. I scoot sideways on the seat, pushing Chantelle the other way, managing to get out from under her as she gives a startled yelp. I rush after Kelly into the toilets, closely followed by Chantelle.
When I get into the room, Kelly is facing me, taunting me with my phone. I'm about to lunge forward and reach for it when she puts it inside her cleavage.
"Come and get it big boy," she teases.
Then Chantelle comes into the room behind me and her body hits mine, pushing me forwards. Both girls are towards the taller end, nearing my own height and Chantelle outweighs me. I'm thrown off balance, wondering how this all went so wrong, as she grabs the back of my head and pushes my face into her sister's massive cleavage. I am completely smothered by her fat tits and can't breathe. I put my hands on Kelly's hips to try to push away but Chantelle grabs my wrists and pulls my hands behind me. This lets me lift my head for a breath before Kelly pushes my head down, holding me against her big fat pillows.
I'm starting to panic now, wondering what these girls are going to do to me. Is it really going to end smothered in some fat fucking tits?
Finally Kelly lets me free and I gasp, sucking in a desperately needed breath. I can feel Chantelle's body pressed all up against mine as she holds my arms tight, trapping them between my back and her fleshy body. Kelly shoves my face back into her ample cleavage again and I struggle against Chantelle, but to no avail. I can vaguely hear her laughing over the blood pumping in my ears.
This time when Kelly lets me breathe again she leaves my head alone, her hand now reaching down between my legs.
"What are you doing?" I gasp, still a bit breathless.
"Checking what you're packing inside those trousers." She starts to rub her hands over my crotch, quickly finding and outlining my cock, which has not gone soft to my surprise, if anything it's even harder now. I groan as I feel myself growing more erect at the touch of her large hands as she rubs my cock and balls through my trousers.
"I bet he loved having his face in your tits Kelly. I bet he's fucking hard now."
"He has a proper hard on. He feels big too, Chantelle."
Her voice overlaps with mine as I try to stop this. "I didn't fucking like it, I couldn't breathe. Let me go."
"We're just having a bit of fun. Don't be a pussy." Chantelle tries to tongue my ear as she whispers to me.
Kelly starts to unzip me. "Your cock is telling a different story buddy. You want it bad. Take a look at this sis." She pulls my cock out from my boxers displaying my erection. I feel ashamed and horny at being shown off like this. My cock is nearly at maximum erection. I keep telling myself I'm not enjoying it and try to think about my girlfriend.
Chantelle whoops in my ear. "That is a big one! I love a nice big cock!"
Kelly pulls my phone out from her cleavage. She gets really close, pressing her body against mine and mines kissing me on the cheek. I can't get away from her as Chantelle tries to kiss my other cheek. I hear the phone click as she takes a selfie of us.
"Oh yes, great pic."
"Give me back my phone." I try not to make my voice sound too pleading.
"Maybe in a bit when we've had some fun." Kelly waves the phone in front of me and then gets down on her knees in front of me and brings her face close to my cock. Then she takes a selfie showing her lips so close to kissing my cock that I can feel her breath on me.
"Do it you slut." Chantelle encourages her from over my shoulder. Kelly looks up at me and slowly starts to slide her lips over the head of my cock.
I let out a moan as Chantelle lets out a whoop. Kelly sucks on the tip of my cock and takes another couple of selfies with my phone.
Chantelle whispers in my ear, "now you've got two options here big boy. You can come back to our place for some fun and earn your phone back, or we can keep your phone and text these pics to your girlfriend."
I think you can guess what I chose.
****
Once Chantelle released my arms they each took an arm in theirs as we headed out of the pub like nothing was wrong, just a wholesome throuple passing through. They ordered an Uber and while we waited, they took turns kissing me in the back alley while the other held my phone hostage. Each time they took me round there, things escalated further. Kelly enjoyed getting me to feel her tits. While I tried to wrap my hands round them she told me they were 38G. Chantelle initially just wanted to feel my cock for herself and so slid her chubby hand down my pants while she kissed me up against the wall. I was so embarrassed that all these things were just making me harder and hornier. I didn't want to enjoy it and part of me was still not into it, but damn if being dominated by them wasn't pressing buttons I didn't know I had. I was also feeling guilty about cheating. I knew it was wrong but that somehow made it worse or maybe better, I wasn't sure anymore as they felt me up and rubbed their bodies over mine.
At one point, Chantelle had her hand up my shirt and was tugging on my nipples (which felt incredible) and I was trying not to moan for her, she warned me what was to come.
"You're acting reluctant now and like you don't want it, but soon we're going to have you moaning like a whore. You're going to be begging us for it."
I shivered as she pinched my nipples and pushed her chunky thigh up between mine to rub against my balls.