Blacmail Bacfires
Reluctance/nonconsent Story

Blacmail Bacfires

by Hyphenatedname 17 min read 4.3 (21,500 views)
creampie noncon spaning blacmail reluctant
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

It was normal to be nervous when blackmailing someone. Or, she thought it was normal. It has to be normal the first time, she figured. Maybe big lawyers and politicians weren't nervous when conducting their fiftieth blackmail, but, wait, did they even conduct their own blackmail at that point? Surely, they had guys for that; fixers, they were called, or aides or associates.

This is ridiculous. What the hell am I buzzing about? Just stick to the script.

She had a glass of water in her hand and it had been stuck in her hand for about a minute as she went on and on and on in her head about what she was about to do. Quickly, she took a couple of gulps to calm her pounding heart. She looked around the opulent kitchen that was about the size of her mom's living room and bedroom put together. No one was in here. Mrs. Morgenthau didn't come in here often and the cook had left an hour ago. It was quiet in the Victorian style manor. Mr. Morgenthau hadn't come yet and little Tad was sleeping.

Wetting her hands, she pressed them against her cheeks before tip-toeing out of the kitchen. The carpeted hallways were dimly lit as she moved through them, adding to her anxiety. She reached the foyer and climbed up the dark wooden stairs. Checking up on Tad, she found him still fast asleep. Such a sweet child he was. It was truly a shame he was a bastard.

No reason not to now,

she thought, gently stroking his dark curls. A different voice piped up, saying,

Plenty of reasons not to, for example, morals?

But she shut that part up and left the bedroom.

Morals

.

What have morals ever brought me?

Just as she reached the master bedroom in the east wing of the manor, the huge grandfather clock began to chime in the distance, indicating midnight, exactly when her shift ended.

Now or never.

She knocked on the glossy ebony door. It only took a second knock and a minute of waiting before she heard movement and the handle twisting down. Not that she was surprised. Mrs. Morgenthau was a haughty, dark beauty in her late thirties who liked to sneer and scowl and stare everything down her fine Greek nose. She was the classic evil-looking wife from those Disney movies.

"It's time for you to go then is it," she began, her hands already reaching into her purse. She could smell the wine in her breath. "Please, tell your people to fix their bank issues

quickly.

Handing over cash like this is just..." her voice faded out, not bothering to finish that sentence as she counted out the bills.

Now or never.

Her heart was pounding but somehow, her lips began to move.

"Ma'am, I just wanted to take a second to expr- extend my sympathies to you," Christine managed to spit out.

Mrs. Morgenthau looked up from her wad of bills, her green, mascaraed eyes narrowing. "Sympathies for what?"

Christine took a breath as she tried and failed to remember what to say. "About little Taddie and Mr. Morgenthau," she blurted out. "I can imagine it's a difficult situation for you, ma'am."

Fuck. Fuck. Fuck. What was I thinking?

The two women looked at each other in silence. Mrs. Morgenthau's face had gone paler than normal even though her eyes screamed danger. Christine stood stock still, blue eyes wide, sweat beading across her forehead and other, very uncomfortable places as she realized she had made a huge mistake. She wasn't ready for this. God! Where had her brain gone?!

Suddenly, Mrs. Morgenthau smiled. "My dear, was that an attempt at blackmail, I just heard?" she asked, her voice so sickeningly sweet.

"No, no, no, I- I just- my intenti- I didn't mean..." She shut her mouth, unable to speak. Her horror at the unravelling of the whole situation was growing, burrowing into her stomach and weakening her legs.

I'm so fucking screwed.

Instead, Mrs. Morgenthau kept smiling and resumed counting the bills. The whole act seemed to take forever. Her pedicured nails, painted jade green, moved back and forth and around before a hand stretched out, green dollar bills clasped within.

Christine swallowed and took the money, shaking all the while. Without another word, the ebony door slammed shut, causing her to flinch.

Dismissed. Like a fucking ant, just swatted away,

she thought, self-loathingly, feeling like she deserved it. She quickly exited the grand old house and made her way over to her car, a silver, reliable old camry, and started her way home.

Idiot. Moron. Stupid. Fucking failure.

The five words that summarized the thoughts swirling violently in her mind. Various types of 'I told you so' thoughts arose too, basing themselves in morality, self-doubt. That perpetual doubter inside of her was loving this, she knew. That same doubter that had stopped her from applying to the top universities, the one that told her she couldn't pull off the best dresses for prom or that she couldn't compete with her other, more educated coworkers at her day job. By the time she arrived at her house -- well, technically, her mom's house -- tears and runny makeup covered half her face.

Goddamn miracle, I didn't crash,

she thought, wiping at her face using the sun visor mirror.

Fucking would have been better if you had,

a voice whispered in her head. She closed her eyes and took deep breaths. It wouldn't do to walk into the house at midnight looking like an emotional wreck. That would only invite unwanted questions.

After a good ten minutes of calming nerves, she headed inside into the small, blue house. Immediately, the sounds from the TV came rushing to greet her. Laughter from the audience, then quiet as the comedian continued with his routine, setting up the next punchline, the next joke.

That would be me,

she thought glumly. Wandering into the living room, she saw her mother sleeping on the couch, her wine glass unemptied.

"Mom. Time to get up and go to your bed," she said loudly, clicking the TV off.

No response.

She looked at her mom and studied her for a moment. Had she been twenty years younger, Christine and her would have been regularly taken as sisters, unquestionably. They had the same light skin, same flaxen-blonde hair, same blue eyes that were startling bright and vivid. Even their body types were the same, if her mom's old pictures were to be trusted, although these days, her mom had put on some weight and added more curves. Still, Christine was prettier. She'd always known that.

"Mom!" she cried out, this time shaking her. It took a good bit before she was responsive; probably the effect of those prescription pills she'd started taking after Dad had run out on them. After groans and much frustration, the nightly routine of cajoling her mother to bed was over and Christine hit her own bed as the clock blared one thirty AM. the red LEDs screaming failure.

Seven AM found her groggily getting to her feet and beginning her morning routine of exercises and bathroom activities and breakfast cooking and etcetera etcetera. Healthy body, healthy mind and all the other advice she'd read across various sources. By nine, she was pulling into her workplace at Conrad Consulting and half an hour later, Christine was at her desk, mulling over her stupidity from last night.

What a bright idea. Attempted blackmail of the wife of a soon-to-be billionaire.

She needed to get tested for mind-altering drugs, she decided. And maybe also stop watching all those dumb procedural TV shows with cops and crimes and insanity. They were making her stupider.

She wondered when her agency would give her a call, letting her know of Mrs. Morgenthau's complaint and her subsequent removal. It was even likely she would get fired if Mrs. Morgenthau wanted to twist the knife and ensure her misery which sounded much like her. Christine had risked it all for a biscuit and now, not only was the biscuit gone, but the crumbs would likely follow. A reliable revenue stream, gone. But it was what it was. There was no point in getting emotional. She would be fired and job hunting season would begin.

By noon, the call had still not come. She'd gotten calls, yes, but mostly from her superiors in accounting, calling just to pile on more tasks. Arrogant jerks. They were very happy with Christine, of course, given how willing and eager she was at accepting more responsibilities. They thought they were reducing their workload while not realizing their facilitation of her education. College might have been a pipe dream for her because of her dad's debts, but a practical education was still available. In the two years since being hired as a receptionist, the twenty year old had risen and traversed through most of the departments, gaining knowledge and the fondness of most of the higher-ups for her competence.

And yes, she was willing to admit that her beauty had helped her along, but she'd never done anything illicit. In fact, she had done her best to shut down any pats on her ass or late-night dinner invitations. She wouldn't sleep her way up.

At least not without a guaranteed pot of gold,

she thought while sending a smile towards Mr. Henderson waddling over to lunch.

As the clock hit quarter till five, she glanced through dry weary eyes towards her telephone. Not a single call from the agency.

Ah fuck it.

She struck her computer's power button and picked up the receiver to dial.

"Hello. This is Rosemary Nannies and Babysitters, how may I help you?"

"Hey, Peggy, it's me."

"Oh hey, Christine! How's it hanging?"

"Super great. Listen, um," she thought for a second, "Mrs. Morgenthau, she just wanted to know when the bank issues will be fixed. She's not too happy paying cash, it seems." It was a good misdirect. Any answer to this question would answer her more burning question.

"Oh that again. I don't know. Mrs. Black doesn't tell me shit, you know how it is." For the next ten minutes, Peggy rambled on and on while Christine encouraged her. The receptionist was such a sieve for gossip and Christine loved being up to date with all the inner workings.

Knowledge is power,

she thought as Peggy told her about Mrs. Black's emotional affair being the reason somehow for the bank troubles.

If only I could use that knowledge...

At five thirty PM, she was already at the Morgenthau manor for her shift. Stumbling out of her Camry where she had changed into more comfortable clothes, she noticed one of the curtains of a closed window swaying.

What...

she thought for a second before putting it out of her mind.

Lola greeted her at the doors. Lola was the Morgenthaus' full-time nanny who, until a recent cancer diagnosis, had lived and provided full care for little Tad. An old woman of seventy, she had the type of kindness one could find in children's books. It was a shame she wasn't long for this world.

"They'll be heading over to a dinner in an hour and a half. I've already laid out Tad's outfit, you just need to get him into it," she instructed him.

"Of course! Is there anything else?"

"Oh well, let me think..." Christine waited patiently as she frowned and shook her head. "Ah, no, I don't think so. You know, all this chemotherapy and treatment is simply terrible on my mind." She noted the tremble in her old, wrinkled hands. "If Mr. Morgenthau wasn't paying himself and insisting on it, I wouldn't have bothered, but he is such a sweet man, thinking about me, knowing the debt my family would have to rack up for this."

"Yeah. Debt isn't the most thoughtful farewell gift," Christine replied, thinking of her dad.

Lola left after a few more exchanges; a taxi paid for by Mr. Morgenthau was ready to drive her home. Christine quickly jumped into her duties. She got little Tad bathed and groomed with time to spare and so spent it reading a book to him in the foyer while waiting for his mother to show up. She wasn't sure what type of reaction to expect, but considering that she still had the job, she figured mercy had been granted. Testing that mercy wouldn't be wise, so as the familiar clicks of Mrs. Morgenthau's high heels arrived down from the stairs, she decided to forget it ever happened.

"My handsome boy," she cooed warmly, bending down to hug and caress Tad. She was dressed exquisitely, her black long dress glossy and tastefully adorned with emerald and jade in small patterns that made her eyes pop. Everything about her was so well-put together, beating even A-list movie stars or runway models. Standing stiffly before her in normal blue jeans and a red flannel shirt, Christine looked like an absolute peasant.

"Christine." The look in her green eyes was unreadable, adding to her low anxiety. "We'll return at eleven at the latest, be ready to prepare Tad for bed. Marvin left dinner for you in the fridge. Make yourself comfortable until then. Come along, darling." She grabbed his hand and headed out to where the black, sleek Rolls-Royce was waiting for them. Lifting Tad into the back seat, she looked back, her eyes still unreadable. "Take a shower, Christine. It'll do you good," she said before turning back.

What the fuck?

she thought, peering after the departing car. Lowering her head, she sniffed her shirt and her armpit. Nothing bad, Christine always showered in the morning and right now it was just her normal body smell mixed with faint perfume. She wondered if that was a code and something had flew over her head, but she doubted it. When she had been hired after a few interviews, she recalled being told of the servant's bathroom available for any of her possible uses, though she had never gone all the way and felt so free as to take an entire shower there.

She's just fucking with me,

she decided.

But a shower doesn't sound so bad. And I have hours of free time...

Forty minutes later, Christine found herself stepping out onto the cool tiles of the steamed up bathroom. The near scalding wash had been the ultimate stress reliever, relaxing her muscles and getting blood rushing to every single inch of her body. Oh, and the consistency! No oscillating water pressure or heat growing tepid as hot water ran out. The perfection of it all had set the neurons firing in her brain. Her groin grew hot and she had rubbed off a quick orgasm, the sensations reaching to her curling toes and tips of her ears.

Damn, I should have done this from the start,

she thought, drying off and gazing around. The bathroom may have been for the servants but could have easily passed as the master's. Exquisite construction and design combining rich browns with golden hues and white tiles. The shelves built into the walls were stocked with towels and every other possible necessity such as brushes and toiletries.

It's a rich man's world,

she hummed the ABBA song.

Money, money, money. Always sunny...

Utterly relaxed, she floated barefoot through the dimly lit halls to the kitchen, already her embarrassment forgotten and her constant debt reminders temporarily gone. Now, all she needed was a delicious Marvin meal and a nap until Tad returned and Christine would be golden. For a little bit at least.

Reaching the kitchen, she flipped the light switch on, and nearly flew out of her skin.

"OH! Oh my god! Oh god... Mr. Morgenthau..."

The handsome and graying man peered up, his blue, shiny eyes immediately stopping her dead in her tracks. He was seated on the kitchen island with a drink in hand, totally relaxed, his tie missing, edge buttons released. Yet something still felt off.

Christine swallowed. "... I apologize, sir, I wasn't told you would be here. I'm sorry for interrupting." She turned to leave but his voice stopped her.

"Sit." So simple and so confidently spoken. She turned slowly and took a seat. After a sip, Mr. Morgenthau stood and walked over to his fancy mini-oven microwave. Opening it, she saw him grab a plate of pot roast and white rice before placing it before her.

"Enjoy. It's one of Marvin's bests."

Christine tentatively picked up the spoon, peering back and forth between his eyes and the plate. She couldn't even comprehend what was going on. Her fucking boss, who had at most glanced at her direction a few times over a few months, was serving her food.

Is it fucking...

"It's not poisoned. Go ahead." Moving to the fridge behind her, she heard the door open and close and other noises before a glass of cold milk was placed before her too. "Your favorite," he said, plonking down just a few stools away from her.

How does he- Something's wrong.

She eyed the food and gripped the spoon. Taking several deep breaths, she fought to control her shaking.

You're not a little bitch, just breathe.

She raised her eyes to where Mr. Morgenthau sat silently, contemplating and sipping his whiskey or bourbon or whatever. In her mind flashed images of her body drugged and unconscious being stuffed in a suitcase or dragged into the trunk of a car, never to be seen again. That could be arranged, easily even, she guessed, for someone like Mr. Morgenthau.

A babysitter blackmailing a billionaire. She had truly fucked up.

"You're not eating."

Her conviction faltered. She was just being silly, right? Silly and very rude to not eat the delicious offered food.

No! Safety first,

she thought.

"...It feels a bit wrong, just, one person eating, the other watching. Feels like I'm being rude or intruding," she managed to put out. What else could she say?

Sorry, you're scaring me and I think you drugged the food?

She wouldn't leave the house in one piece that way.

"Am I causing you to feel impolite, Christine?" A shiver travelled down her spine at the way he emphasized her name and rolled it around his mouth.

"No, sir. I- um... my mother always told me um... that you'll get a stomach ache if you eat in front of some- someone that's not eating... Silly superstition, I guess." She couldn't stop quivering.

Mr. Morgenthau pondered that, his eyebrows raised in interest. Meanwhile, she tried to consider her possibilities. Could she run? Make some excuse to go to the bathroom maybe? Her hair was still damp. Maybe she could say she forgot her hairband or something else girly and cosmetic. Men didn't like inquiring further into girly stuff.

My period! I could say-

"I'd never heard of that before," he admitted. Downing his drink, he put down the glass and swiveled to face her directly. At once, she noticed his blue eyes, shiny but still in control. And playful, she realized. "I suppose it's one of those sayings, meant to encourage selflessness in children. My mother never told me that one. She wasn't really interested in selflessness."

She stayed quiet, still confused as to what was happening. Maybe Mr. Morgenthau was just on some bender?

"Christine Bennings. Christine," he said, again weirdly emphasizing, even tasting her name. "Born 1984. Only child. Your father disappeared one night with a suitcase when you were fifteen, leaving you and your mother in unknown debts. You studied hard in school and were near the top of your graduating class from Fleamont High. Had offers from a number of universities, but couldn't go due to aforementioned money issues. You've been working odd jobs since sixteen, then got a job at Conrad Consulting where you've been for the past two years, working your way up. You're well liked by your coworkers and management, so likely you're a good worker and not just someone sleeping their way to the top. Or you're just good at hiding it."

What the fuck,

she thought, wide-eyed with horror.

He continued, "No boyfriend. Most of your friends left town for college. Your mother is having troubles with alcohol and pills. Understandable given her own two jobs, as well as slow progress in terms of ridding the debt. She keeps an illegally-purchased revolver in her drawer but hasn't fired it yet... Should I keep on going?"

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like