Better Than the Real Thing
Reluctance/nonconsent Story

Better Than the Real Thing

by Rabblelaid 17 min read 4.7 (29,600 views)
strapon lezdom lesbian sex submissive humiliation rivals homewrecer revenge
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

Amber Koch had a passionate hatred for popular girls. And, more often than not, the feeling was mutual. It had been that way ever since middle school.

As far as Amber could tell, the only thing she had done wrong was growing tits earlier than the other girls. That was all it took to be labeled a slut. All through high school, Amber hoped that she could change the minds of the pretty, popular girls by acting meek and kind and chaste. But that didn't matter. Those beautiful, bratty girls, with their cute outfits and catty smiles and eyes shining with mockery and hate, never seemed to need a reason to call Amber a slut. Everyone already knew she was one after all; it had been common knowledge ever since middle school.

In her senior year, Amber made a life-changing decision: fuck it, if she was going to be called a slut no matter what she did, she might as well become one.

So she started sleeping with her bullies' boyfriends. It was easy. A lot easier than she thought it would be. It turned out that when you had Amber's curvy figure and sultry good looks, all it took was a little encouraging dirty talk for even the most loyal of boyfriends to be putty in your hands.

And yeah, maybe after her early successes Amber got a little drunk on power. Maybe her choice of targets got a little broader. By the end of her freshman year of college, Amber had expanded her campaign of revenge beyond people who mistreated her. Any girl who had a certain look became fair game in Amber's eyes.

Girls who were slim and pretty, with a sort of lithe grace were the problem as far as Amber was concerned. For some reason, they just set her teeth on edge. They made a strange, jealous fire burn inside her... she felt an irrepressible need to reach out and ruin them. To Amber, even if skinny bitches seemed nice on the outside, it had to be an act. They reminded her too strongly of her bullies.

Once, her roommate Clara, shaking her head at yet another story of a hot and steamy tryst with a "skinny bitch's" boyfriend, told Amber, "Girl, you need to be careful. One of these days you're going to mess with the wrong woman."

But Amber had just laughed. "Clara, I've had a girl slap the shit out of me, I've had hair pulled out... hell, I've had a bottle broken over my head. I've run into the wrong woman plenty of times. They can do their worst, but they can't make me unfuck their boyfriend. If there is a skinny bitch on this campus who can beat me at my own game, I haven't met her."

And that was true. She hadn't met Hannah Lind yet.

...

Hannah Lind embodied all of the qualities that Amber loathed about "skinny bitches".

She was jaw-droppingly beautiful, with cascades of dark, wavy hair, startling blue eyes, and curvy lips that always seemed to be faintly smiling at some hidden secret.

Her body, although not as eye-catching as Amber's thick, luscious curves, sent Amber into a fuming rage when she saw it. Lithe, toned, and petite, it showed off the hard work that Hannah put in at the pool with its subtle, smooth muscle tone.

Because Hannah wasn't just a pretty face. She was the star of the college swim team, taking home trophy after trophy. Not only that, she also found time to serve as the president of the student body. She was intelligent, talented, charming, and the darling of everyone she met.

In other words, perfect. Not a hair out of place, never flustered or cranky or caught off guard. When Amber first met her, it was hate at first sight.

Amber first crossed paths with Hannah when she started using the university pool for exercise. She had just been kicked out of a second gym after drama between her and a skinny bitch that worked there. Just like her first gym before that. But Amber couldn't just not exercise. Although she had come to love her big tits, wide hips, and round bubble butt, her build meant that she was always at risk of getting pudgy. Amber couldn't have that; her favorite pastime of hunting for taken men meant she needed to look her best at all times.

So she decided to give swimming laps a try. And it was on her very first day there that she saw Hannah. The first time Amber saw Hannah, the skinny little bitch was standing and chatting warmly with the handsome, muscular lifeguard. Hannah had been wearing a one-piece suit: modest, but unable to hide the willowy grace of her amazing body. Even without makeup, Hannah looked dewy and perfect, with little beads of water decorating her lashes and skin like jewels as she smiled and flirted coyly with the lifeguard.

It normally took a little longer for Amber to decide a girl needed to be taken down a peg, but with Hannah, it was almost immediate. She knew who Hannah was, of course. It was hard to not at least be aware of who the student body president was. But seeing her in person set a fire inside Amber.

When she found out that Aaron Foss, the lifeguard Hannah was speaking to, was actually Hannah's boyfriend... well, that made her next course of action simple and straightforward. Amber would steal Aaron right out from under Hannah's nose, and all that skinny bitch would be able to do was watch and fume.

The fact that Hannah had never personally done anything to Amber was unimportant. At this point, fucking with skinny bitches was its own reward.

And so, as she returned to the pool on a daily basis, Amber's swimsuits got a little more revealing. She started having friendly, flirty conversations with Aaron. The boy turned out to be dumb as a rock, which made everything much easier. Poor blushing Aaron didn't know where to look when Amber leaned over to talk to him in his lifeguard chair, water dripping off her ripe, hanging tits.

Hannah clocked Amber's actions immediately, of course. Her perfect, pretty face fixed itself into a bitter expression every time Amber made an excuse to chat Aaron up. But what could Hannah do? She made a point of marching up and calling Aaron's attention away from the interfering temptress whenever she could, but she was at the pool to train; she couldn't guard her boyfriend the entire time.

At some point, Hannah clearly decided that Amber's shameless flirting had crossed the line and had a talk with her man. Amber almost laughed when Aaron nervously told her that his girlfriend didn't want them to speak anymore. It was cute. He was trying so hard to be a good boyfriend. But in the end, he wouldn't be able to resist.

Amber ignored the fact that Aaron was nervously staring across the pool at the stone-faced Hannah and leaned over to whisper in his ear.

"Don't try to resist, big boy. We both know what I want, and we both know I'm going to get it. I'm going to feel the heat of that big cock in my hand. I'm going to wrap these pretty little lips around its thickness. I'm going to feel what it's like to have you inside me. Soon. No matter what she says."

Amber strutted away from the lifeguard chair, leaving Aaron red-faced, with a noticeable bulge in his swim trunks. She smirked and twiddled her fingers at the gorgeous, furious bitch watching her from the pool. Maybe that little display would make the couple break up. It had happened before when Amber rubbed a popular girl's nose in her seduction attempts. If that happened, Amber would fuck Aaron anyway, just to show that the breakup hadn't deterred her, but she hoped that Hannah would fight a little harder than that. It would make it so much sweeter when she succeeded anyway.

She never even considered that the intelligent, talented young Hannah Lind might have more creative ways of fighting back than the average popular girl.

...

Amber looked at herself in the locker room mirror. Tousled dirty blonde hair, rich brown eyes, and pouty lips. She looked as sexy as usual. But her face wasn't the reason that boys found it hard to resist her.

She smoothed the tiny pink triangles of cloth over her big firm tits, arching her back a little to admire them. Then, with a confident smirk, she turned to see her profile from the side, eyes tracing the thick, luscious swell of her ass. Looking good. She was a bit worried that she had been spending too much time on seduction and not enough on exercise lately, but there were no signs of chubbiness detectable, just full, ripe, tempting womanhood.

Today was the day.

Today, she would turn up the heat and coax Aaron into following her. She planned to take him by the hand, march him right past his prissy little girlfriend, take him to a storage closet or pump room or something, and screw his brains out. He would protest at first no doubt, but Amber had seen the look in his eyes and the bulge in his pants when she had dirty-talked him the other day, and she was confident that it wouldn't take much to get him to crack.

She strode confidently over to the exit of the locker room, and pushed on the door to the pool, ready to seductively strut across the room toward her latest prey, modeling her slutty bikini for him.

*Clunk*

Amber frowned. She pushed again. *Clunk* The door was catching on something. As if someone had moved something heavy in front of the door.

'It's a doorstop sweetie," said a cool, amused voice from behind Amber, "You're not going to be able to push it open that easily."

Amber whirled to see Hannah Lind sitting on one of the benches. she was wearing her regular tight black one-piece swimsuit and was leaning casually back on both arms, her legs crossed with a foot swinging. As usual, not one of her lovely dark hairs was out of place. Amber could have sworn she had been alone in the changing room just a moment before. Had this crazy bitch been hiding? Hannah wore an expression of faint amusement. The sight of her sent a thrill of deep-seated annoyance through Amber, like usual.

Amber scoffed, backing away from the blocked door and facing Hannah with her arms crossed beneath her impressive chest. "I've seen a lot of desperate moves, but this has to be the most pathetic," she said, raising an eyebrow with a pitying smile. "Do you really think that this will keep me away from Aaron?"

If Hannah felt intimidated or desperate, she didn't show it. She shook her head and said, "Not forever, no. But long enough." The way she said it sent a prickle of apprehension through Amber, raising goosebumps on the back of her neck. She immediately felt defensive, shifting her eyes around the locker room. Did this bitch have friends waiting to jump her?

But the locker room was empty: the only sound was the drip of water from the showerheads in the adjoining room. Amber turned her suspicious eyes back to the strangely confident woman on the changing room bench.

Hannah leaned forward, her elbow on her knee and her chin on her fist. "Let's talk, Amber. Woman to woman. You told my boyfriend that... well, let's see... that you were going to feel his cock in your hand. That you were going to wrap your lips around it. That you wanted to feel him inside you. Do I have that right?"

Amber smirked. "So he told you, huh? Good for him. Yeah, I might have said something like that," she said airily, "But it's really up to him. If you aren't able to stop him from fucking other women, it's hardly my fault. Do you think you have what it takes? To stop us?"

Hannah shook a finger with a wide grin on her face. "You misunderstand me!" she said with a chuckle. "I'm not trying to stop you. Quite the opposite in fact. Today I want to make sure you get exactly what you want!"

That brought Amber up short. What the fuck was wrong with this girl? Did she actually want Amber to fuck her boyfriend?

Hannah reached down and picked up a duffel bag sitting on the changing room floor behind her. "Let me show you something, sweetie," she said, rifling through the bag. "Aaron is a great guy. Not the smartest man, but very kind and supportive. And, take it from me, he has a world-class cock. I'm not surprised you wanted a taste."

Hannah seemed to find what she was looking for, but didn't pull it out of the bag yet. She raised shining, excited eyes to Amber and said, "So this past Valentine's Day, I knew just what I wanted as a gift. I'm afraid that I'm not willing to share Aaron's cock itself, but today, you're going to get the next best thing."

Hannah pulled her hand out of the bag, revealing a big, flesh-toned dildo. Amber stared at it, bewildered. It was hyper-realistic: someone had lovingly recreated a life-like cock out of soft silicone with some sort of rigid core. Amber connected the dots. "Wait," she said, her eyes widening, "You mean that that's..."

"Aaron's cock? Yes ma'am!" said Hannah happily. "Not from one of those cheap 'clone-a-cock' kits either. a real professional recreation. It cost him a fortune. Worth every penny when I have to travel without him for swim meets, believe me."

Amber examined the fake dick again more closely, fascinated despite herself. It really did look like the real deal, and, based on the gentle squish of Hannah's fingers, it would probably feel real as well. Amber's eyes flicked back up to Hannah's, seeing the strange, manic light burning there. This was getting a little too weird for her. What was this skinny bitch's problem? Was she really offering to lend Amber a dildo?

Hannah waved the realistic cock back and forth, making it wobble slightly. "Do you know what you do with a naughty teenager when you catch them smoking, Amber?" asked Hannah in a light, amused tone. "You make them smoke a whole pack." The dildo made a fleshy *Thwap* as Hannah slapped it down into her hand. "You wanted to know what my boyfriend's cock felt like, and I intend to show you. I intend to burn the feeling of his cock so deep into your mind that you don't even need to try the real thing."

Hannah held out the fake dick with a teasing smirk. "You want to feel his cock in your hot little hand, didn't you, sweetie? Well, come over here. Let's get started."

Something about Hannah's smug face, her aggressive, obscene statements, and her as-always gorgeous looks sent that familiar old feeling flaring red hot in Amber's core. Jealousy, annoyance, and, deeper, a flickering feeling of arousal that Amber would hotly deny, even to herself.

"You're fucking crazy," snarled Amber, turning away with a rapidly beating pulse and heading toward the entrance door.

*Clunk*

A feeling of panic swelled up in Amber and she pushed against the door frantically.

*Clunk* *Clunk* *Clunk*

Amber's breathing grew quick and shallow as she connected the dots. She should have realized that this crazy bitch would block both doors. Hannah must have had friends standing by outside to spring the trap. Amber looked over her shoulder at Hannah, still sitting in her swimsuit, her legs calmly crossed. The confident older girl raised her eyebrows and waggled the dildo. For some reason, the surge of panic didn't diminish the strange hot feeling inside Amber at all. Instead, it made the flames inside her leap higher.

Amber closed her eyes and took a deep, steadying breath, forcing herself to calm down. So Hannah wouldn't let this go without a confrontation. Fine. It wouldn't be the first or last time that Amber had gone toe to toe with an angry victim of her games.

"Ahhh, running away, huh?" said Hannah in a gently mocking voice. "I have to admit that I'm disappointed. I thought you would be at least a little more brave than that."

Amber's eyes flew open, wide with anger. All of the fear and jealousy (and that sneaking, growing little sprout of lust) were drowned out in an instant by white-hot rage at the taunt. Amber forgot all about the blocked doors, marching right up to the cocky little bitch. "Afraid?" she asked scornfully, "Of what? A rubber cock? A skinny little bitch like you? Please. You want me to touch your dildo so badly? Fine. Hand it over."

Hannah looked up, delighted at the response to her taunt. Her deep, evident confidence put a bit of a dent in Amber's momentum. Where did this girl get all of her certainty from? That sneaking, elusive little trickle of arousal began sending fluttering tendrils through Amber's belly.

"Hand it over?" asked Hannah incredulously. "No, Sweetie, I have a better idea. We're trying to give you a realistic experience, right?"

Amber watched in stunned silence as Hannah pulled some sort of leather harness out of her bag and swiftly strapped it around her waist. Comprehension dawned as Hannah slotted the round base of the dildo into the front of the strapon device. It was a perfect fit.

Hannah sighed in satisfaction, spreading her legs to display the results of her handiwork. It was an obscene sight. What looked like a real cock now jutted up from Hannah's slim, feminine hips, a strange, perverted, but not wholly unappealing mashup of male and female sexuality. "There. Perfect. That's going to give you a lot more realistic experience, don't you think? I want you to feel like you really got to play with my boyfriend's cock after all."

"You're n-nuts," said Amber blankly, her mouth suddenly dry. She felt more than ever her gnawing dislike for pretty, popular girls like Hannah, but for some reason, the combination of Hannah's teasing forwardness and the sight of the cock sticking stiffly up between her spread, feminine thighs were made a fuzzy warmth and confusion spread through Amber's overtaxed mind.

"What's the matter?" purred Hannah, reaching down to play with her new cock with slow, languid strokes. "I thought I was just a skinny bitch with a rubber cock. Nothing to be afraid of, right? Why are you pussying out now?"

The mocking words sent another twinge of complex emotion racing through Amber that she fought to repress. She couldn't let this bitch know she was afraid. "Fine," she said through gritted teeth. "I'll play your game, you freak. This means nothing to me." Taking a deep breath, Amber tentatively reached out. She was so focused on the strap-on between Hannah's legs that she didn't even notice that her posture placed her hanging, barely-covered tits right in Hannah's line of sight. Unseen by Amber, Hannah's eyes widened slightly, then looked away, a slight stain of pink briefly coloring her cheeks.

Just as Amber closed her slim fingers around the fake cock, Hannah let out a breathy, performative moan. Amber looked up from the strapon with wide shocked eyes, the erotic sound sending a wet, hot, squirming feeling through her belly. Hannah just smirked at her and giggled.

"Very funny, asshole," growled Amber, trying to fight back the sudden wave of arousal the unexpected moan had caused. It wasn't her fault! She was just responding to the obvious sexual imagery and undertones. She would just play Hannah's game just long enough to show that it didn't bother her like Hannah was implying it did. Then she would demand to be set free. By force if necessary.

Amber began moving her loosely gripping hand up and down the fake cock. It really did feel like the real thing. It was even slightly warm, probably from when Hannah was handling it. Her hand didn't move completely smoothly though, sticking a little on the soft rubber surface of the dildo.

"Where are my manners!" said Hannah with mock politeness. "Let me help you, sweetie." Hannah leaned forward, delicately tucking a stray dark curl behind her ear. Amber realized what was about to happen just an instant before Hannah opened her lips and let a thick stream of warm saliva drool out onto the dildo.

A part of Amber's mind recoiled in disgust, but for some reason she didn't quite understand, her hand kept moving, sliding over the slick, lubricating saliva and quickly coating the lifelike cock with it, turning her handjob into a squelching, silky-smooth glide.

"There," said Hannah in a low, sultry voice, her ocean-blue eyes flicking upward to meet Amber's with a strange, unwelcome jolt of sexual electricity, "That feels better, doesn't it?"

"Yes," said Amber automatically, the word puffing from between her lips before she could stop herself. Her cheeks flushed red as she internally cursed her stupid mouth. She was supposed to be showing this stuck-up bitch that her teasing had no effect, not playing into her sick little fantasy! But Hannah's eyes didn't look as mocking as they had a few minutes before. There was an odd, dangerous smolder there now echoing the odd feelings inside Amber.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like