Better Than Mom
Reluctance/nonconsent Story

Better Than Mom

by Smallchongles 17 min read 4.4 (6,700 views)
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

DISCLAIMER: All Characters are 18 or older. This story isn't a quick read.

***

Mary and Rex had been dating for nine months now. They were comfortable with each other and enjoyed simple things like their Saturday shopping runs. On this particular afternoon, the sky was overcast, a bit chilly for early fall. The plan was simple: grab a few groceries, get dinner, and maybe go out to watch a movie.

Mary was a 22 year-old fresh-faced blonde was stunning and from old wealth. She had big doughy blue eyes, crimped hair and a slight patch of freckles. Her lips were plump and red with designer lipstick. She spent money on herself, and it showed.

Mary's body wasn't entirely real. Just under a year ago, her parents had gifted her with a pair of tits. They were big, round and full. Her top was a thin, low cut V-neck tee that revealed the inner sides of her breasts and hugged her girls nicely. It was white, a poor choice of color given that the clouds threatened rain.

Her bottom consisted of a blue jean short that barely reached her mid-thigh and left little to the imagination, showcasing her very sexy ass that jiggled as she walked. Men couldn't help, but turn their heads as Mary strutted past them in her knee-high, heeled leather boots that clicked on the concrete sidewalk.

Rex was also twenty-two. He and Mary had been dating for several months. They'd met at a local club, and since then, the two had grown to become comfortable around each other. She had no problems being open with him, telling him about her day or complaining to him about something that bothered her. Rex was, likewise, free to speak his mind. They had developed a level of trust, and that wasn't going to be broken today.

Rex was a handsome boy. He had a baby face and was a little short, but he made Mary feel safe. Mary walked beside Rex, her hand occasionally brushing his as they made their way through the parking lot. He smiled down at her, offering a little squeeze on her shoulder. "You seem distracted today. Everything alright?"

Mary gave a half-smile. "Yeah, I'm good. Just thinking."

In truth, she was distracted, but it wasn't anything she could talk about. The last few days, thoughts of Brad had been creeping back into her mind, unwanted but persistent. Brad--her ex. Her messy, complicated, infuriating ex who had cheated on her with her mom of all people. It had been almost a year since they broke up, but some wounds didn't heal as quickly as she hoped. At least, she got some breast implants out of the deal.

Mary never used to be concerned with the size of her boobs. But now that her mother was the home wrecker and her dad had been too ashamed to stick around, her new rack was a small consolation prize. It helped her feel confident to finally have larger boobs than her mom.

But, they did get her noticed. Everywhere she went, it seemed that her breasts were always getting attention. Whether that was a double take from someone at the grocery store, an awkward conversation starter when ordering coffee, or an inappropriate compliment from an old man at work. Mary grew to like the attention, though she would never admit to it.

Rex had taken a liking to her and her big boobs, and they had started dating. He was cute and attentive, and he didn't care about what had happened to her or why her family had suddenly dissolved. She knew that he wouldn't cheat on her. She loved him. She wore her immodest outfits to please him.

As they walked into the store, the smell of fresh-baked bread hit them, mingling with the sound of carts rolling over the tile. Mary grabbed a cart and led the way, Rex falling in line beside her. They started their usual route through the aisles, grabbing what they needed.

And then, in the cereal aisle, she saw him.

Brad was standing there, scanning the shelves, looking as if he didn't have a care in the world. He hadn't changed much--same messy brown hair, same crooked smile. That smile used to make her melt, and for a moment, her heart skipped a beat. Then reality hit her like a wave crashing against the shore. That's the man that ruined everything, she reminded herself. The familiar anger boiling from within.

Brad was a big man. He was a foot taller than Rex, broader, thicker, more muscular. Mary couldn't see his abs, but she knew they were there. His arms and chest filled out his jacket nicely, and his pants were form fitting. He was 25.

Rex was busy looking at a box of granola when he noticed Mary freeze. He followed her gaze and saw Brad, too. His eyes narrowed slightly. He wasn't the jealous type, but he wasn't oblivious either. He could see the way Mary's expression shifted.

Brad turned and spotted her. His smile faded, replaced by a look of recognition. "Mary. Hey... long time, no see."

Mary could feel her pulse in her ears. She didn't want to talk to him, didn't want him to have any control over her emotions. This wasn't reality though. "Brad," she said curtly, trying to keep her voice steady. She felt Rex's eyes on her but couldn't meet them. She wasn't sure she could explain what was happening in her head even if she tried.

Brad took a few steps toward them, his hands in his pockets. "You look good. It's been... what, almost a year now?"

"Something like that," Mary muttered, gripping the cart tighter. Rex shifted slightly; his presence steady but quiet. He didn't say anything, but Mary knew he was watching everything closely.

"How have you been?" Brad asked, his voice too casual, too light, like he wasn't the one who had shattered her trust and wrecked her family.

Mary clenched her jaw. "Fine. Moved on, actually." She motioned toward Rex. "This is Rex. My boyfriend."

Brad's smile wavered, but he recovered quickly. "Oh, hey man. Nice to meet you."

Rex gave a nod, his eyes never leaving Mary's face. "Yeah. You too."

The tension in the air was thick, and for a second, Mary thought she might just leave the cart and walk out. But instead, she stood her ground, staring at Brad. She didn't know if she was angrier at him for cheating or at herself for still caring or for the way her heart ached even now.

Brad shifted awkwardly. "Listen, Mary, I don't know what all your mom told you about us, but she was lying."

"I don't want to hear it, Brad," she interrupted, her voice shaking now, the anger finally bubbling to the surface. "I've heard it all before."

Rex stepped in, his voice calm. "Maybe we should just go, Mary. We don't need to do this here."

Mary's heart twisted painfully and angrily. Rex's hand was on her shoulder, grounding her. And that was the reason that, instead of saying something, she shook her head, grabbed the cart, and stormed away.

"Mary, wait!" Brad called.

Rex hesitated, his eyes darting between Mary and Brad. In a split second, he made a decision, stepping closer to the bigger boy. His voice was low, threatening. "Leave her alone. Don't come near her again. Do you understand?"

Brad's eyes flashed, and he squared his shoulders, sizing up the shorter boy in front of him. "Who the hell are you to tell me what to do?"

Rex didn't back down. "Someone who knows her worth, unlike you. Someone who doesn't need to cheat. Now, stay the fuck away."

Brad huffed and watched the pair walk off. His fists balled, but the grocery store was not the place to start a fight.

Mary didn't turn around once, didn't look to see if he was following. She could feel the tears stinging her eyes and blinked them away, determined not to cry in the middle of the grocery store. Rex didn't ask questions. He didn't pry. Instead, he silently followed her.

***

A couple days later was a quiet Sunday afternoon when Mary and Rex were lounging on the couch in her opulent living room. The sunlight filtered through the blinds, casting soft golden stripes across the room. Mary was leaning against Rex, her head on his shoulder. They watched an old movie. Everything felt normal and perfect between them. The run in with Brad was in the past.

But as they settled into the calm, there was a knock at the door.

Mary glanced at Rex, confused. "Are you expecting someone?"

Rex shook his head. "No. You?"

Mary frowned. "Nope."

The knock came again, a little more insistent this time. With a sigh, she got up, stretching her arms and making her way to the door. Rex watched her go, a feeling of unease creeping up his spine.

When Mary opened the door, her heart stopped. Standing there, casually leaning against the doorframe with that same infuriating smirk, was Brad.

"Hey, Mary," he said, his voice smooth and familiar.

She blinked, caught off guard. "Brad? What are you doing here?"

"I was in the neighborhood. Thought I'd stop by and see how you were doing," he said, his tone too relaxed for someone who had shown up unannounced at his ex's house.

Mary glanced back at Rex, who was sitting up now, watching the interaction with narrowed eyes. She turned to Brad. "This isn't a good time, Brad. You should go." Her words were firm, her tone clipped, but her body betrayed her. As Brad pushed his way past her, she didn't resist, and Rex saw.

"So this is your new place, huh?" Brad said, looking around the living room. "Not bad, not bad."

"Brad, you can't be here. Mary doesn't want you here," Rex spoke, standing up and positioning himself between Brad and Mary.

Brad raised an eyebrow, a mocking grin tugging at his lips. "Is that so? Let her speak for herself."

They both looked at he. She swallowed hard, her resolve cracking. Part of her, a small but vocal part, still cared for Brad. "You need to leave, Brad. You shouldn't have come."

He stepped closer, his height looming over her. She didn't retreat, her eyes defiant but conflicted. He reached out to touch her cheek, but she pulled back, her expression hardening. Rex, his fists clenched, took a step forward.

Mary glanced at him. "Please, Brad. Please, just go." But, she couldn't hide the tremor in her voice, the hint of uncertainty that belied her plea. Her nipples began to perk under her thin tanktop.

Brad's smile was sly, confident, as he leaned in closer, ignoring the warning look in Mary's eyes. "Are you sure that's what you want, Mary? Are you really happy here with this boy?"

She inhaled sharply, trying to muster up the strength to push him away, but her hands remained at her sides. Rex's fists were clenched, and he moved forward to intervene, but something in Mary's eyes stopped him.

"Leave, asshole. Now!" Rex growled.

Brad shrugged, shoving his hands into his pockets. "Like I said, I was just in the area. Thought I'd check in on you. You seemed a little upset when we last talked."

Rex narrowed his eyes. "She's fine."

Brad laughed, his eyes never leaving Mary. "Oh, I'm sure. Living the high life, aren't we, princess? No doubt the house is paid for, the fridge is stocked, and everything is just peachy. But is that all you want out of life, Mary? Comfort?"

Rex's hand on her arm tightened. "It's not like that at all. We are in love. Mary has the kind of life she deserves. Not some cheap affair on the side. Not some mistress to her own mother."

Brad scoffed, his gaze shifting to Rex for a brief moment before returning to Mary. "Don't you miss the excitement, the thrill of the chase, the adrenaline rush that comes with a bit of danger?"

Before she could say anything, Brad's phone buzzed in his pocket. He pulled it out, glanced at the screen, and frowned. "I've got to go," he said abruptly, his tone shifting back to casual, as if nothing intense had just happened.

He looked at Mary one last time, his eyes lingering on her. "Think about what I said, Mary. You know where to find me." Then, with a smirk directed at Rex, he turned and walked off, disappearing down the sidewalk.

Rex stood there, fists clenched at his sides, watching Brad leave. He turned to Mary, his voice low but strained. "Why did you let him in?"

Mary felt her throat tighten. "I didn't mean to--he just... showed up."

"Right. Well, at least you got to talk to him," Rex snapped. His face was red, his posture tense, as he continued, his anger and frustration bubbling to the surface, "Why would you even let him talk to you like that? Why wouldn't you defend our relationship?"

Mary looked away. "It wasn't like that, Rex. You don't understand."

His eyes widened, disbelief clear on his features. "He was in your house, Mary! He was taunting us, and you did nothing! You were going to let him keep going, weren't you?"

With that, he grabbed his jacket and quietly left, leaving Mary standing alone in the doorway. Her cheeks were wet, her heart was pounding. The door swung shut behind him. And in that moment, in that quiet living room, the shadows of her past seemed to stretch long and dark, enveloping her in a world of memories and emotions she'd rather forget.

***

Less than thirty minutes later, a knock came on the door again. This time, however, it was forceful, almost angry. Mary's heart was in her throat. Rex had returned she thought. But when she opened the door, Rex was still gone and there stood Brad. She hadn't expected him back.

"I never thought he'd leave," Brad declare.

She tried to slam the door, but he jammed his boot inside, wedging it open. Mary stepped back. She knew he was a big man, that his boots could kick down her front door if he wanted.

Brad's hand was at his crotch, massaging the large cock in his jeans. She could tell he was hard. He was huge. Bigger than any of her toys. Big enough to have a visible outline in his tight jeans.

Brad shoved her back inside the house, slamming the door shut behind him. "I thought I'd give you another shot."

"A shot at what?" Mary replied as she pushed Brad. She was scared, but not terrified. Something told her that her life wasn't in danger. If Brad had been that type of guy, she would have seen that side of him years ago. Besides, her neighbors would call the cops if the situation got too violent. Wouldn't they?

"A shot to show me who you really are," he sneered, his eyes raking over her body, stopping at her breasts that bounced in their cage of thin material. Her nipples were poking through her top, betraying her fear, and her anxiety.

"I know who I am. I know who you are. You cheated. You're an asshole," she protested. "Get out!" Mary yelled at him, her hands balled into fists.

"Your tits were good before, but now that you've gotten fake ones..." Brad paused and leered at her chest, licking his lips, "...I bet they're even better. Just begging for a real man."

"They are none of your fucking business," Mary spat. She wanted him to stop talking. "You lost that right when you stuck your cock in my mother." She hoped that saying that would cause him pain, shame, but Brad shrugged it off.

Mary clenched her fists. "Why did you cheat on me, Brad?" Her voice cracked.

Brad sighed, running a hand through his hair. "You're still on that, huh?"

"Yes, I'm still on that," Mary snapped. "You destroyed everything, and you think I'm just going to forget about it?"

Brad smirked, leaning against the wall. "I never said you had to forget. But we've both moved on, haven't we?"

Moved on. The words felt like a slap in the face, especially because she wasn't sure if she had. Not really. She had Rex, and yet here she was, letting Brad into her house twice on the same day.

"You don't get to act like it didn't matter," she said, her voice shaking with anger. "You broke my trust, Brad. You made me feel like an idiot. You fucked my mom."

She took a step toward him, fists clenched. Brad stepped closer too, his eyes darkening with something that made Mary's breath catch. "Your mom's body was better than yours, and she knew how to please a man. "

"You bastard!" Mary yelled and slapped him. Hard.

The sound echoed in the empty house. For a second, they just stood there, staring at each other, the air charged and dangerous. Mary was panting, her heart pounding, her hand tingling from the impact. Brad's cheek burned, but he didn't flinch. He just kept staring at her, the ghost of a smile on his lips.

"Feel better?" he asked finally, his voice low and taunting. The way he had treated her was a betrayal and it hurt, and yet the sight of his smirk, the sound of his mocking tone, did things to her that she didn't want to admit. It made her blood boil, her heart race, and, oddly, her pussy moist.

"Why did you even do it?" she asked, her voice softer now, almost pleading. "What was wrong with us?

Brad's smile disappeared. He pushed himself off the wall, closing the space between them. Mary didn't move, her body frozen in anticipation and fear. "Maybe you should ask yourself that question."

"Ask myself why you broke up my family and betrayed my trust?" Mary huffed.

"I'm not the betrayer here." Brad growled.

Mary's eyes bulged. "What does that even mean? I never cheated on you." She said.

"Maybe not, you never gave me what I needed though. Your mom did."

"Which is what exactly? The ability to take a twelve-inch cock between her big tits?"

"Yes," he hissed in her ear.

She tried to shove him, but his weight barely budged. Her breathing hitched, and she could feel the heat rising in her cheeks.

And then, just as quickly as the moment had built, she snapped out of it. She stepped back, her eyes wide with panic and guilt. "No," she said, her voice shaking. "I can't do this. If you won't leave, I will."

Before Brad could say anything else, Mary turned and fled out the door, her heart pounding as she ran outside to her Range Rover. She slammed the door shut, breathing heavily as she stared at her own house, her mind racing with everything that had just happened.

She couldn't believe how close she'd come to falling for him again. She couldn't believe she had almost let him back into her life, knowing full well that he was bad for her. Tears pricked her eyes as she realized how easily Brad had manipulated her, how easily she had let him.

Mary pulled out her phone, her hands trembling. There was a missed call, probably from Rex. There was no time. She put her car in reverse and went to back out of the driveway, but Brad had blocked her in.

Mary sat frozen in the driver's seat, her breath coming in sharp bursts as Brad knocked on her window, his voice urgent, his expression fierce.

He demanded she unlock the door, his eyes locked onto hers, and slowly, despite the alarm bells going off in her head, her fingers reached for the lock. She didn't have control of herself, her movements seemingly dictated by a primal, animalistic desire that was overriding all rational thought. As soon as the click sounded, he opened the door, yanking her from her seat. Mary felt her body flush with a strange, forbidden heat.

"Look, Mary," Brad's voice cut through the fog of her desire. His voice was low, and his words sent shivers down her spine. "I didn't mean to fuck up what we had. I didn't want to break your trust, or hurt you, or cause your dad to leave, okay? I fucked up, but you weren't ready. You were too much of a coward. All of the teasing, and you were afraid of sucking dick. Your mom wasn't, and she didn't care who knew."

Mary could smell the musky scent of his cologne, mixed with something darker, more primal. Mary's heart raced as she felt the heat of his hand against her skin. She wanted to deny it, to tell him that this was wrong, but something in the way he looked at her made her pause. Her mind screamed at her to leave, to remember everything he'd done, but the attraction--God, the desire--was undeniable.

"I--" She began, but before she could finish, Brad's lips were on hers. The kiss was intense, hot, and urgent, sending a jolt through her body that left her breathless. She gasped, instinctively grabbing his shoulders for support as he pressed her back against the side of her car.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like