Keeping with the theme of posting real experiences I've had before diving into fiction. Another short but sweet one. I really only posted this because I very much enjoyed that this happened.
*All parties involved were over 18 at the time this happened*
Background: my gf and I met while she was screwing my friend. They weren't dating, she just liked sex and he had a big cock. Eventually she got tired of him and we got together and she (for the most part) stopped seeing him. I have a decent cock, and have no issues with my size but his is on the large side and she couldn't QUITE ger over being a size queen so I let her occasionally hook up with him, mainly because he had started dating a new girl and he secretly enjoyed cheating and I liked having dirt on him. He didn't know I knew about it and in his mind was a total boss for fucking his best friends gf behind his back. I am very sexually open minded so it didn't bother me one bit. She would tell me about him "seducing her" and we'd laugh about it and then go about our day. He also liked to tell me about "this side piece he was always fucking" because I guess he really got off to the idea of telling a guy about fucking his girlfriend. I never really thought about it much because she saw several guys on the side and I saw other girls on the side as well.
Well one night at a party we (me, girlfriend, my friend, and his new gf) were all having a good time playing drinking games in the garage. I can't remember the reason, but the majority of the party congregated inside and upstairs. My gf had just lit a cigarette and my friend conveniently pulled out his own pack to light one, so they were the only two left in the garage.