This is not a true story. This is Pure Fantasy.
A week after the event, Rick and Jim were just finishing for the day and saw notes attached to their timecards. They clocked out and headed up to the office as instructed. The front receptionist smiled and handed them an envelope apiece as she was gathering up her purse and book bag her day now done. "Those came in todayβs mail. I don't know why they were sent here. There's no return address, but I figured you'd want to get them right away." she said, then motioned for them to leave ahead of her, as she was the last to leave the office thanks to them. Both men thanked her and they held the door for her then walked her to her car before getting into Jim's truck together. They often rode together, taking turns driving to work, saving on gas and wear.
"So, what's it about?" Jim asked as his cousin tore into his envelope while he started the truck to let it cool off.
Rather than answer Rick muttered, "Shit!", as his cousin was opening his as well.
"Oh, fuck." was all Jim could say as he began reading the letter inside.
"It's a bill for five grand. From some place called 'The Tie-Dye'. Who the hell is that and why are they sending me a bill?"
"Didn't you get the letter?" Jim asked as he looked over from his bill, which had been the second page, not the first.
His cousin shuffled the two pages and started reading aloud. "Gentlemen (dare I say that?), I am contacting you to let you know that I know who you are. Thanks to you I had to redo the order I'd spent the week making and now am behind schedule. All the batches I'd been working on had to be redone so I'm sending you the bill for the supplies from that, and then some, for the labor as well as the pain and suffering I had to go through when I should've been resting in my bed recovering from the abuse you dealt me. So you will know, I will go to the police if you do not pay these bills and I have evidence to back up my story, including finger prints on the oil bottle and pantyhose packages, not to mention DNA. And while I may not have a boyfriend who lives with me I do have loyal friends who will support me. Pay your bill. Seriously, Emma Walker"
The two men sat there for a long moment staring at the bills, then both swore again before Jim muttered, "Sorry, Cuz. I swear I don't know how she found out."
Rick shook his head. "I knew I shouldn't let you talk me into that. It's my fault for going along."
"No, I talked you into it. I'll pay for the damages." He said as he took the papers from him, folded them up with his and crammed them over his visor. "I'd like to know how she knew it was us. We neither one made a pass at her while we were working on her pump. We were real careful not to say anything in our regular voices and you can't tell who it is from a moan." he muttered, scowling as he put the truck in reverse and backed out.
"Think she could see through the pillow case?" Rick asked after they pulled out onto the main road as he stared blindly out of his window.
"Naaah. No more than shadow at most. We could've, should've been anyone that way. No, something gave us away that night."
"You were right though. We got in real easy. Are you sure you've never done this before?" Rick asked, still looking out the window.
Jim was already shaking his head adamantly. "Naah, just thought about it a time or two. Probably wouldn't have this time had you not agreed to go along." he murmured as he pulled the papers down and glanced at the bill again. "Won't be doing it again either. Not at this cost. No matter how good looking or tempting." he muttered with disgust.
Rick reached out and took back his papers. "I'll pay mine... somehow."
"To bad we didn't have a recording of her enjoying the hell out of what we was doing. All we'd need was a video of her begging us and we could say it wasn't rape." Jim snorted.
They rode in silence for several miles, listening to the music playing low on the radio while they thought about what had resulted from their night of 'fun'. It was only meant to be fun. Exciting, kinky, harmless fun. Okay, so Jim had gotten a bit more 'fun' out of it than Rick had thought he should've. And, true, it had been rape. But Rick hadn't meant to hurt her... and he hadn't thought Jim would. They hadn't really talked about that night either since then... and perhaps they should've. Jim had beat her with a belt and would've kept at it for who knew how long had Rick not been there.
"Why'd you hit her with the belt?" he asked suddenly, needing to know. "And on her legs of all places? Why not her ass?"
Jim shrugged. "She kept running her mouth. Her legs seemed more... I don't know, attention grabbing. Didn't do as I'd thought it would."
"We could've gagged her. We talked about that. You said you didn't want her gagged. You wanted to hear her begging you not to fuck her you said."
"She did too."
"And what happened to making her want us before we took her?" Rick demanded, turning to look at his cousin now, wanting to know."
Jim shook his head and frowned heavily. For a long moment he didn't say anything, just continued driving. As they turned into his cousins apartment complex, he finally muttered, "I don't know. I just got so angry. We did wrong, I know, but... Hell, Rick. She was a fine little thing. She lived out there all by herself, seemed so... knowing. Like when she greeted us that day. Gentlemen. I don't know, it just seemed uppity. She seemed uppity."
"You're nuts, Jim." Rick said, staring at him in disbelief. "The woman was lovely, I agree, even better looking once naked, but she never once acted uppity. She probably does know a lot. Especially if she really does fetch thirty dollars for nighties like the one you ripped off of her. She was nice to both of us, leaving us to do our work, not getting in the way, not whining over the price, and not standing over our shoulders. You were angry at her from first sight. Why's that?"
"Perhaps it was the way she looked at us. She thought you were worth a long look while she barely glanced at me." Jim snapped gruffly.
Rick's brows flew up in shock and for a moment he could only sit there gaping at his cousin. "You're nuts! And jealous to boot? Unbelievable!" he growled with disbelief. "She didn't like your looks so you decided to beat her and harshly rape her? Is that it?"
Jim's lips were drawn low and he did his best not to look his cousin's way as he pulled the truck up at the curb in front of the walkway of the apartment he was renting. "She enjoyed it." he muttered, looking out his window.
Rick shook his head. "Not until we put the oil on. Good thing I went into her bathroom. If I hadn't found that oil, I would've gone into the kitchen for something. Jim, you dry fucked that poor girl ...and beat her with your belt. Hell, had I not been there, there's no telling what abuses you would've reaped on her. And did you happen to notice how big her vibrator was. We were both three times the size of that thing. And, yet, you went and crammed that little thing into her ass without even giving it more than a swipe in her own juices. Hell, she could've been a virgin for all you'd known and you rammed your dick in her so hard that first time that I'd actually expected to see blood after the way she screamed." He again shook his head and muttered then, "I truly hope you meant it when you said you won't be doing this again. Your little rape fantasy is going to cost us five grand a piece and that's if she doesn't change her mind afterwards about going to the cops. You got the pantyhose and we each opened a package, not to mention the facts that neither of us used a condom. Fuck! I just now remembered that too. We didn't use any fucking latex! Shit!"
Jim's head jerked around at that and stared at him wide-eyed for a moment. Then, as the implications of that settled in he returned his gaze to the windshield before him. Both men groaned as they slid down in their seats, thinking of all that could come of this now. "She wasn't a virgin. That means she was sexually active. Think she was clean? I don't feel sick down there. No itching. No redness, swelling or pain. You?"
"You're worried about STD's?!" Rick barked jerking up and around to glare at him as if he'd lost his fucking mind. Actually they both had. "How about the ultimate in incriminating evidence and DNA, idiot!"
"Well, yeah, semen. She said she had DNA evidence. Semen, perhaps hair from our bodies and heads." Jim agreed, nodding.