A First Date Nightmare
Reluctance/nonconsent Story

A First Date Nightmare

by E_onyaygin 18 min read 4.3 (16,200 views)
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

It was a chilly autumn night in the city. We zoom into a busy street in the shopping district, to a late night café announced by old neon letters spelling out the name of a person who once owned it. Inside, we spot our two protagonists, a girl and a boy. The boy is talking now, telling a story about the time he ditched his high school prom to go ice skating with his buddies, the last time they all hung out together before going off to college. It's been a few years, but he recounts the details with fervor, his lively pupils darting about the room as if he was first learning to skate again, grasping with his eyes for solid ground, trying to keep balance.

Our young man, Harry, a 21 year old junior in college, finds unexpected joy in talking about his youth. People aren't typically interested in listening to him ramble about his past, he thinks to himself. But occasionally his eyes, in their search for balance, land on the girl across the table and for an instant he freezes, as those dark brown ovals penetrate his gaze and hold him down, at once imploring him to continue and yet demanding he tell her everything, every last secretive thought in his soul. Harry was aware of this, and throughout the night he had been sipping at his coffee strategically to break the cycle of interrogation she seemed to perpetuate with her gaze, but he had long since run dry and silently cursed at this. Now he had no defense against her truth elixir stare, and he found himself mentioning increasingly personal thoughts about his own life.

Harry was a nervous wreck. Megan figured this out 10 minutes into their date. She studied his face while he spoke, following his dark eyebrows and long lashes, his pronounced brow ridge complementing his slightly angular jaw. Honestly a pretty boy. They had organized this on Tinder, so the intentions were obvious, but he didn't seem to have much experience with dates. Every time he wrapped a story up Megan made a sound evoking her surprise and approval and interest all at once and then watched as he squirmed against the silence for a few moments before coming up with another remark. "It's like playing with your food", she thought. She smirked at the thought of how much she had learned about him compared with how little she had revealed about herself.

Megan looked at her watch and suddenly rose. Harry betrayed a moment of alarm, and hastily tried to hide it by coolly commenting "It's getting late, huh? I should probably get some sleep before class."

"Well, it was very nice meeting you!" Megan flashed him a smile slightly too wide for a natural parting, and extended her hand. Harry's heart jumped out of his throat. A handshake? That didn't seem right at all. Oh god, she doesn't give a shit about me. He limply reached out and met her hand, once again betraying every ounce of his panic by the flushing of his cheeks.

"Uhh, it was nice to meet you too..." His hand lingered in hers for a moment, but he quickly thought better of adding anything else and with a slight nod of his head turned towards the door. "I'm out that way" he said, vaguely gesturing to his right, "but uhh, if you ever wanna do something like this again, just shoot me a text, okay?" That was good, he thought to himself, keep it cool, noncommittal, pretend like you don't care either way.

"Actually, I live that way too! Can you walk me home?" Megan widened her oval eyes and looked up at him expectantly. She fought hard not to burst out in laughter as he turned an even brighter shade of red.

"Uhm yeah, of course. Uh, show me the way," he stammered out. What the hell? A whole cacophony in his mind erupted. What was Megan thinking? Just a moment ago all his hopes were dashed away by that miserably platonic handshake, and now it seemed she wasn't completely repulsed by him. Did she like him? Did she dislike him? Was this some kind of weird friend-zoning maneuver? It was all too much to figure out and Harry was starting to short circuit, so they walked in silence for a few moments.

"You know," Megan suddenly interjected, "I think you have a lot of potential."

Dead silence. What the hell does that mean? Harry couldn't figure out what to say.

"As an engineer, I mean!" Megan flashed her wide friendly smile at him. "I mean, you work so hard, and you really care about the details. That's all super important, isn't it?"

Harry stammered for a second, but picked up the thread just before it got awkward. "Oh yeah, I hope you're right." He chuckled artificially.

"Oh, you self deprecate too much. Woman like more confident men." Megan burned with delight as he watched Harry blush once again, this time not even trying to hide his dismay. "You can totally ignore this, but since we met on that app, I just wanted to tell you that I think you would make a wonderful friend. I'll invite you to one of my dorm parties later this month, okay?"

Harry took a deep breath and swallowed twice, desperately stifling the pain suddenly burning in his chest. It's okay, its just one rejection, don't worry about it dude.

"Oh, uhm, thanks for letting me know" his voice croaked out in a whisper. He subconsciously stepped away from her as they walked. "Yeah, I'll invite you over if I host anything too," Harry said in his best attempt at maintaining an air of calm. "I can handle this. It's not that bad." He repeated this to himself several times as they walked in silence. But something was off. Harry noticed his vision blurring. He saw two sidewalks, and after glancing over at Megan, saw two of her as well.

"Hey, you're turning a little green, are you okay?" Megan asked. Oh god, is this dude about to go crazy on me? Panic suddenly flashed in her mind. It was all fun to her, flipping back and forth on this innocent boy, building up his hopes and turning them to dust. She cast a sidelong glance at him, taking care to hide any fear in her demeanor, but was at once assaulted by a feeling of dizziness. Megan stumbled forward, seeking out a nearby bench as her vision narrowed. "Hey, Harry, I'm feeling a little off," she said, more to herself than to him. But Harry was suddenly at the same bench as her, vomiting over the railing. In the next moment she saw black.

"WAKE UP EVERYBODY!" A booming voice echoed in what felt like a narrow and chilly room. Megan blinked her eyes. She reached over to rub them but suddenly realized her arms were not moving. She gave them a tug. What the hell? They were fastened by her side. She was on her knees, but couldn't move her head to look around. Something was holding her in place, a cool metal bar she surmised was running along her back, holding her neck and head in line. Lights suddenly flooded the room, and Megan's eyes widened in terror. To her left, a naked man was tied to a pole, his arms fastened behind him, his junk hanging inches in front of a naked woman who seemed to be fixed in a kneeling position, her head held high to the point of her back arching, causing her perky tits to point out. She was blinking rapidly, obviously trying to adjust to the new lighting. What is going on? Panic set in as a thought dawned in Megan. She shifted her gaze to a flaccid penis not more than a few inches in front of her, attached to slender, tan legs. Her eyes slowly moved up his body, scanning his thin torso, tracing the faint outline of abdominal muscles and the beginnings of a muscular chest. Her eyes darted upwards, and she immediately registered Harry's sleeping face, his jaw slack, a line of spittle dripping down to his groin.

"WAKE UP!" the voice boomed again, and Harry snapped to attention, an expression of alarm animating his features. "What the fuck? what in the fuck?" Harry repeated to himself as he glanced around the room, taking in the scene of multiple couples in the same predicament. Then, with dread he lowered his gaze and locked eyes with Megan, taking in her kneeling, naked body. Her back arched to match her erect head, her eyes aimed up at him as if pleading. Harry drunk in her small, round breasts, whose quickly hardening nipples pointed straight forward. The total picture of her kneeling figure, her overly erect body and head held high, while her arms lay fastened by her side gave her an artificial air of determined subservience, at odds with the terrified expression on her face. A rush of blood flooded his penis. Megan's face morphed with irritation.

"Dammit Harry! Stop that! Don't look at me! Fucking help me out of this!" She shrieked at him.

"Shit shit shit, I can't fucking control it!" Harry freaked out as he realized he was now rock hard, the head of his dick pressed lightly against Megan's nose. She was desperately trying evade its touch, but the bindings didn't offer enough leeway.

"Harry, I need you to focus, dammit" shouted Megan. "I don't know what the fuck is going on, but now is not the time to get horny! Just see if you can wriggle out."

Harry budged and pulled, but the ropes were too tight. A low hum started to build up in the room. The other couples were all facing similar arguments, some shouting while others spoke rapidly in a panic. Harry looked back down at Megan, guilty that his swollen penis was now pressed up against her lips. But her flushed expression showed no hints of the demanding boss she was moments ago. "Hey Megan, are you alright? I'm trying my best here," he weakly managed.

"Oh Harry, uhm..." her voice trailed off momentarily. "Harry, they've got something pressed up against me here, its -- " Megan interrupted herself with a soft moan.

"Pressed where, Megan? Are you in pain?" Harry asked, forgetting his own helplessness.

"Oh Harry its not painful," --she let out another moan-- "I just, I think they're... stimulating me."

On these last words Harry ventured his gaze down and noticed a vibrator positioned right under her pussy. "She's turned on". This last thought was too much for Harry, still a virgin, and he instinctively lurched forward with his pelvis, dragging the tip of his penis across Megan's face. A dribble of precum settled on her upper lip, but she was oblivious, her eyes closed in ecstasy from the increasingly fast vibrations.

"TDOAY WE ARE GOING TO PLAY A GAME!" a voice boomed over a megaphone. "We are slavers looking for our latest product. We gathered you all here tonight to find the best and horniest slaves!" The speaker was interrupted by laughter. The couples all looked equally horrified. Even Megan had tightened out of her pleasure momentarily as the panic set in.

"Here is the deal. Women! You have the chance to avoid slavery. All you have to do is bring your partner over the edge, and we will release you. However, if you fail to make him cum before you reach your first orgasm, and believe me, we will know," again, the speaker was interrupted by laughter, "then we'll pack you up and sell you."

The speakers last words set in and Megan's heart began to pound. The constant vibrations got faster and faster and the feeling of helplessness, of being displayed before Harry, forced to kneel before him and accept his cock while she pathetically moaned was too much, and she felt an orgasm distantly approaching. Harry's cock poked at her face. It would be so easy to take in, to nurse and stimulate until he lost control. And he clearly couldn't control himself. Megan looked up at Harry's worried face, his flushed expression showing just how much he internally desired this, desired towering over her, forcing her to accept his manhood when she had just dashed his dreams away, forcing her to give herself up to him. Suddenly, Megan swelled with hatred towards Harry, Harry who seemed to be deriving nothing but unearned pleasure from this whole predicament. She hated how subservient she was, lowered to the level of his cock, forced to reckon with submitting herself now or submitting herself to a life of slavery.

"BUT!" the speaker echoed out, breaking Megan's train of thought. "But, since we are in need of the most pathetic male slaves, we will add one more little detail. The first man to cum will be sold to slavery as well!"

At these last words, Harry felt the hot whips of panic. Just a moment ago he was sure he could save Megan just by how eager his member seemed to be, but now, looking at the other couples with mostly older men, he noticed his dick was the most erect, the most engorged, the only one already dripping.

Megan took in the final condition with calculated coldness. So be it. He will suffer far more than me. Harry shot a worried glance at Megan, who wordlessly opened her mouth and began licking the head of his penis. The new stimulation sent shockwaves through him.

"Megan!" Harry groaned under intense arousal. "Megan, ple--" Harry gasped for breath as she took his whole cock in. "Megan, please don't do this to me" he pleaded. "Just go a little slower, wait until---" again Harry let out a low moan as Megan began bobbing her face back and forth over his cock. She expertly guided her tongue over the tip of his penis while her lips wrapped around the shaft, and she pushed deeper and deeper till she started to gag. "Megan, please just slow down a little bit, I can't help it!"

Megan felt his cock twitch in her mouth, the start of his orgasm nearing. The vibrator kept building in intensity, sending shockwaves through her body. Her heart rate quickened with it, and she felt herself automatically undulating her hips over the vibrator. "I'm almost as fucking pathetic as he is", she thought, looking up at the terrified boy, unable to contain the explosion of pleasure he was trying desperately to hold back. "But I am the one in control". Drool ran down her mouth, a line of spit and cum dripping between her breasts and down to her swollen pussy, and she felt the final twich of Harry's cock. Locking eyes with him, showing none of her pleasure and all of her hatred, she pushed forward and enveloped his full member.

Harry thrust forward, fulfilling a program hardwired into his brain from eons of evolution, and shot out his load. He kept spurting for several seconds, filling Megan's mouth, and all the while she held it in. His heart sank as a man dressed in black stepped up to them, holding a megaphone.

"WE HAVE OUR FIRST WINNER!" The man looked down at Megan, who hatefully opened her mouth and let Harry's cum seep out. Her face grew contorted and pained, and her torso jerked momentarily, her back arching even further.

"Oh, and looks like it was just in the nick of time. Well missus, we will be sure to set you free, but your man here will be coming with us as per our agreement."

Harry's eyes welled up. "You could have saved us both!" he shouted before sobbing. The man pulled out a cloth and began dabbing it with chemicals.

Megan shot a look of blood and daggers at Harry. "You mean nothing to me." She spat out the rest of his cum onto his stomach. The man held the cloth over her face, and she went limp. Harry blacked out moments later.

Harry awoke in a cold, metallic room. He immediately recalled the entire, humiliating experience, but there were no physical hints. In fact, he realized his entire body had been cleaned and shaven. So it was all real, he thought to himself. He noticed a door on the far side of the room, and walked up to it. After giving the knob a dejected turn, it surprisingly opened, leading to a dark hallway. It seemed to beckon him forward, and assessing the situation, Harry cautiously tiptoed out, past several locked doors lining the hallway, until he reached one with light emanating from under the frame. This one was unlocked, and as Harry eased open the door, he was greeted by a pair of slender, lightly tanned legs joined by a beautifully round ass, all kneeling in doggy style, while the torso fed into a hole in the wall where presumably the rest of the woman was. He watched her breathing by the undulation of her abdomen, and was momentarily transfixed by two soft dimples on her back marking the mounds of her soft, tanned butt, centering a purple, neatly shaved asshole. Her legs had been secured somewhat apart, so that her posture naturally 'presented' her holes to him. In a few moments he was rock hard. His eyes traced her delightfully supple legs down to her feet, where he noticed a little paper note taped to her left sole. Frowning, he crouched down and carefully lifted it into the light. It read:

"Hello Harry. We apologize for having to sell you into the slave trade, but as per the rules agreed upon, you lost first, and thus you have lost all your rights. You will probably never have the freedom to fuck again, and we felt bad for how your lady friend treated you. So, you are being given a little consolation prize. Please fuck her as much as you like. But one condition. If you use her asshole, we'll have to sell her as a slave too. Otherwise she will go free once you are shipped off, as per the rules. Enjoy"

Amazed, Harry stumbled back on the last sentence. The paper lightly fell back on her sole, and suddenly the woman flinched.

"What? Who's there! Help me!"

Harry at once recognized Megan's voice.

"Get me out of here! Please get me out! We had a deal! I'm supposed to go free!"

Harry quickly regained his senses. This was Megan. She was somehow restrained on either side of this wall. The hole her torso went through was fitted with a seal that seemed to be taped down to her body. He began digging at the edges, peeling the tape back, when Megan shrieked and jerked away, obviously reacting in pain to what he was doing.

"Oh shit, I'm sorry! I'm trying to figure out how you're held down and --"

"Harry?" Megan interrupted, dumbfounded. "Is that you? What are you doing here? What the fuck is going on now? I can't fucking move anywhere, they have me tied down."

"Yeah, I can see that..." Harry's eyes drifted over her bare ass again, lingering over her exposed holes. He quickly snapped out of it. "They have you secured pretty tight here."

"Harry, where are you? I can't see anything, it's all dark in here!"

"I don't know, I'm on the other side of the wall, I can't get to you from here."

"But you just touched me! Try to find a light switch."

"No, Megan, I mean, you're also on this side of the wall."

"Harry? What the fuck does that mean?" Megan realized the naivety of her question a moment too late.

"Oh, uhm, well, I'm in the room with your lower half..." His eyes again drifted over her soft round ass, to the mound of her cleanly shaven pussy, so perfectly presented for him. Was she a little wet?

"For fucks sake Harry! Don't you dare look at me, okay? Can you do anything about the bonds?"

"Oh sorry, let me look" Harry again snapped out of his reverie. "They've got metal rings holding you in place." He traced his fingers around the cuff holding her feet in place and lightly brushed over her toes. Megan jerked at the touch. "What happened? Are you good?" he called back.

"I'm just a little... ticklish" she admitted hesitantly.

Megan's shy confession sent a shockwave of heat through Harry's body. He felt his face blush and his penis stiffen even more as he stared at her soles, so helplessly open, so easy to torment.

"Do you see anything else?"

Harry shook is head to push the demons out of his thoughts. Focus. "Oh, they left a note taped to your foot" he mentioned as he stood up.

"What? a note? What the hell does it say? Why didn't you mention that before?"

Harry froze, instantly regretting his last words.

"Harry? What does it say? Tell me right now." Her voice cut like daggers, sensing something was wrong. The whole time Megan had been stirring with an unconscious desire, the helplessness of her plight, the way she didn't even know how much Harry could see, the question of why she was being held captive in the first place. When she sucked his cock, she had at least been the one in control. But now, forced to her hands and knees like an animal, her ass spread apart, she confusingly felt the undercurrents of desire. Can he tell? Does he see my pussy? At these last thoughts, Megan only felt a resurgence of swelling and heat. She moaned softly, humiliated by the revelation. Her back tensed up subconsciously, arching and further exposing her groin. Noticing her own behavior, Megan quickly tensed up her pelvis, trying desperately to hide her horniness.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like