"What is
she
doing here?"
Carmen's voice was surprised and, to my astonishment, accusatory. Emerald eyes flashed angrily. "This is
my
place. Why would you invite her here? After everything I've been going through!"
"Your place?" I asked. My voice was quiet, and it seemed to have the intended effect.
The girl hesitated. "Well...
Our
place, I mean... Of course, baby. But..."
"And I didn't invite her," I went on. I took a cautious step closer to the teen, who was standing just inside the door. Carmen had entered, seen Victoria on her living room couch wearing just a bathrobe and nothing else, and dropped her purse to the floor with a gasp of surprise and outrage. Admittedly, I should have planned this encounter better. "Victoria came to see
us
. Under a white flag of truce, you might say."
I glanced over at Victoria, but the older brunette offered no aid.
Carmen snorted. "Right," she snapped. "A truce. That's why I come home from a long, stressful day of work to see that my boyfriend has been fucking another woman in my living room while I was gone." She bent, snatched up her purse, kicked the door shut behind her and started to storm past me. Her face was tight and angry, but I could see the first glimmers of tears in her green eyes.
"Woah there..." I said, raising my hands and stepping in the way. "
Another woman?
What does
that
mean? Victoria isn't some other woman. She's a part of our relationship. A big part. And she's here because she could see that our whole family is falling apart and we need to come together to fix it."
The crimson-haired nymph stopped, just outside arm's reach. She stared daggers at me, then turned her eyes to Victoria. "I hope you're happy," she snarled. Her small hands were curled into fists. "You've got what you came for. He's obviously on your side now..."
Carmen's words hurt as they landed, sinking deep as knives, and even harder than weathering them was knowing that they hurt her even more. After my discussion with Victoria, I was finally able to see what the woman had been talking about. Carmen was lost, trapped in a story where she was the constant victim of a thoughtless, uncaring world. Where everyone she loved and relied on had turned against her.
"Angel..." I murmured. I wanted to take a step closer, but I knew I probably shouldn't. "Can you please just hear me out? Just for a second. And then, if you're still angry, you can kick me out, can kick Victoria out, can do whatever you need."
The redhead sniffed, wiped the back of her wrist swiftly under one eye, and then glared at me. "Fine. If you want to leave with her, fine. See if I care."
I considered my next words very carefully. When I spoke, I did it with intention. "I was wrong," I said. "I hurt you, and I'm sorry, but please know that it was never intentional." My unexpected tack was rewarded, because Carmen's brow furrowed and she suddenly seemed almost as confused as she was upset.
"What do you mean...?" she asked, crossing her arms across her chest. She sounded apprehensive. "What else did you do?"
I paused again, resisted the urge to glance at Victoria for guidance, and forged ahead. I met Carmen's eyes and my gaze was frank. "I've been treating you poorly," I said. "I've been encouraging you to hide out here, away from the people who love you, and I know it's been hurting you to be away from them. I know it's hurting you because it's been hurting me. But I did it because I was afraid to go back. Because
I
messed up at Thanksgiving and
you
stood up for me, and you faced the consequences as much as I did."
I trailed off, to give her the opportunity to respond. I couldn't force her into anything, I'd realized. The only thing I could do was accept my blame and, hopefully, show her that I was willing to change. Maybe that would be enough to help her change, too. Or see the light. Or whatever she needed, to find her way out of the dark place where she'd been ensnared.
"What are you talking about, Chance?" Carmen's voice was less angry now. In fact, it was almost indignant. "You know I'm the one who freaked out. I'm the one who blew up and yelled at Day. I'm the one who stormed off... You came after
me
, remember?"
I didn't respond, just watched the 18-year-old's face as a dozen different emotions raced across it.
"You think you can just take all the blame?" she scowled. "You think that that will make everything better? If you just take it all on your shoulders? I've tried that. Don't you think I've tried that? I've been trying to shoulder all the burdens for me and Day ever since we were little. It doesn't work. It doesn't
fucking
work! No matter how much you try to take, things don't get better. They just build and build and then
bang!
Everything falls apart. You think saying sorry is going to fix anything?!"
I shook my head. "I don't think that," I murmured.
"Then what?!" the girl demanded. Her narrow jaw was hard and sharp, but her lip trembled. "What do you think is the master solution that will solve all our problems?" She was staring into my face, and I think in that moment she forgot that Victoria was even there.
I certainly did. All I could see was the wounded, frightened young woman in front of me. She was ready to bolt, like a startled deer, but despite her anger she was giving me a chance. I could see now that she wanted to believe me, she wanted to believe that things could get better, but she had no idea how they could. "I think," I said carefully, "that problems will keep adding weight to our shoulders until we fix them. And I know that
I,
at least, need to face my problems. So that they stop adding those burdens onto me."
Carmen's cheeks were wet, shining in the late afternoon light that filtered through the big windows across the room.
"That's why Victoria is here," I went on. Still, I never looked away from Carmen's feverish eyes. "Because she helped to remind me that there are people who care about us, who want what's best for us, who
love
us. And those people miss us and want us back, but only if we can face up to what we did wrong. Because that's the only way we can put these issues to rest."
The teen's mouth worked quietly for a moment. She sniffed. The tension in her body mounted. Then,
"Fuck!"
she sobbed, and she stumbled back against the closed front door, sliding down to the floor with her legs curled up to her chest. She wrapped her arms around her shins and dropped her forehead to her knees. I could see her shoulders shuddering.
Now, I did look to Victoria for advice.
The woman gestured silently with her head.
Get over there, dummy,
her eyes seemed to be saying.
Right,
I thought. I crossed swiftly and dropped to my knees in front of the girl. "Hey, love," I said quietly, letting my hands rest lightly on her shoulders. I brushed gently up and down her arms.
"I'm such a bitch..." Carmen whispered, not looking up. "All I do is hurt the people I care about."
"No..." My arms wrapped protectively around her, and I kissed the top of her head. "Enough of that, baby. I'm scared to go back, too. But we can do it together, right?"
The teen hesitated until I cocked my head and tipped her chin back with one finger. A thin line of black makeup marred one cheek.
"Right?" I asked. I smiled a little, hopeful smile.
Carmen sniffed. Her eyes flicked past me to Victoria, then back to my face. She chewed her lips for a second, then nodded. "Yeah," she quietly agreed. "We can do it together..."
* * *
The decision was made quickly, but the logistics were a little harder to manage.
I knew that if Carmen and I were returning to the others then there were going to be apologies in order, and explanations required. I had already explained the Amber situation to Victoria — the reason that Lassiter had been at Thanksgiving, and the reason that I'd been so much more withdrawn and preoccupied the past few weeks — but I still owed Daisy the same. And, for obvious reasons, it would be best if Amber wasn't present. I hadn't noticed at the time, but in hindsight it was easy to recognize that my emotional withdrawal toward Carmen was, in large part, due to the fact that she was the only one who was in on the secret. After telling Vi what had been going on, I felt
instantly
more comfortable, like an invisible barrier between us had been lifted.