"This might sound weird," she finally forced herself to blurt out. The guilt gnarled in her gut like a dagger. "But did... didn't we break up already?"
Across the white cotton-topped dining table, Michelle peered into her glass of chardonnay, the only remaining dish from their dinner.
Michelle turned her head up to meet her gaze, holding the same bemused smile. She knew Michelle's eyes well - a lush forested green, almost always obscured by her discerning eyelids, shaded in a deep, sparkling amethyst. With a single glance, she could stir many emotions at once. Ferocity, and compassion. Scorn, and forgiveness. Authority, and unyielding love.
"Hmm?"
That was all Michelle had to say. The knife twisted in her. She loathed having to repeat herself, having to push through this awkwardness again.
"I mean... What I mean is, to say... I remember having a talk before where I... broke up. Called it off." Her eyes darted from corner to corner of the dead Italian restaurant - the empty booth, the 2nd floor window looking out into the night, the other empty booth, the wall-hung planter, anywhere other than her face. They could have picked a busier restaurant to mask the conversation, she realized.
"My dear tulip," Michelle cooed, "is this another one of your dreams?"
Michelle had said something similar when, over coffee, she'd sworn remembering a certain visit to her house. As she'd recalled, Michelle had somehow convinced her to get on all fours and bark like a dog. She'd even "climb" up onto Michelle's couch and lay her head on her lap. The whole affair struck her as so uncharacteristic of her, she was immediately willing to write it off as a weird dream, but she'd since developed a guilty enjoyment of Michelle affectionately scratching behind her head.
On another occasion, she shared a dream she had with Michelle one weekend morning. She regaled feeling lost in a jungle, then awkwardly and timidly described a green anaconda extending down from the tree canopy and tangling up around her body. She held off on the details of the tightening feeling turning her on. Michelle joined her in laughing it off, and agreed with her how odd it was how she'd only just shared her interest in rope play only a week ago.
"I really don't know," she answered, "but you know I wouldn't want to bring it up like this, if I didn't think it happened!"
Michelle refused to falter from her melancholic smile, and watched over her wine glass. "Do try your best to remember."
"Rememb- AH!" All at once, the last two years of dating finally came to her. Michelle's cycle of promises, broken promises, and vague excuses. Michelle's lavish dates and generous gifts, in exchange for pushing her buttons. Mental probes, sexual favors, and a blurred line between requests and demands that left her split between used and aroused. Each memory struck with renewed hurt and distrust, and the familiar, unwelcome sense of being toyed with returned.
Michelle had sort of access to a hidden zipper somewhere on her - one she didn't realize she had, and once realized, she intended to keep closed. Only her most intimate thoughts and secrets were kept behind this guard, and despite her best efforts, Michelle could not only peak inside, but feel around a bit from within. On her worst days, it was the most heinous of personal violations, and on her best, the most erotic experience she never thought she could get off to.
"I DID break up with you!" she shouted, as soon as she could collect her thoughts. "It was months ago!"
Michelle said nothing, and started toying with her wine glass, so she continued. "I said something like... I was tired of being played with, taken advantage of. And I still am!"
Michelle had begun circling the rim of her wine glass with her finger, which fired her up. "Even now, you're ignoring me! Which is FINE, because I have SO much to say to you."
Michelle was maintaining a steady rhythm with her finger. It wasn't even making a cool whistling noise. "You've always carefully ignoring my issues and feelings, and just waiting for me to stop being mad at you. But I'm not going to stop! Or, rather, I AM going to stop... and keep you waiting. You know what I mean!"
Michelle kept watching the glass, unperturbed, stroking her finger around and around. At least, she assumed that's what Michelle was doing, as she kept on watching her finger, herself, as she ranted. "You always just wait and wait until I'm no longer upset, so you can try and make me happy again. Or you just wait until I forget... or something. Even now..."
Michelle's finger glided along the shimmering glass, in a simple miniature ballet with an audience of one. She gazed on. "You always do this... and I forget... I don't understand it."
Michelle's finger twirled around, and around, and around. She thought nothing of this simple, inoffensive gesture. She thought nothing of the overall dinner, or whatever topic they were discussing. Nothing simply came to mind. Consciously, she tried to recall what she was talking about. "I don't... understand", she spoke aloud without thinking.
She might as well watch the lovely display while she waited for the thoughts to come back, she thought. Michelle really knew how to entertain. Even the simplest of gestures, gracefully performed by Michelle, left her captivated.
"Try as you like, my dearest violet", Michelle finally spoke, her cadence matching the pace of her twirling finger, "but I know what you want as well as you do."
She didn't have an immediate guess what she was referring to, but knew Michelle would provide the answer soon, so she waited until she answered: "You want to watch, and you want to listen. And it's perfectly fine to want these things. And I know you want to."
"Try your hardest for me to turn your eyes away." She already knew this would be challenging, since the thought of looking away hadn't even passed her mind. Was the thought to look away supposed to come before the movement itself, or did the movement just happen without thinking? She spent several seconds thinking it over in silence, watching.
"Now try your hardest to speak." While many small and fuzzy thoughts swam around in her mind, none were clear enough to form ideas to be shared aloud. Her mouth dropped slightly open, and hung in a relaxed, open state, but seconds passed, and no words came out.
"You may save your effort, my darling daffodil. We both know that you watch, because you want to watch. And you remain silent, because you want to listen."
She nodded in acknowledgment - or was it agreement? She wasn't in the mood to disagree. Despite this, a small nagging thought wouldn't go away, insisting that she disagree, no matter how comfortable Michelle's voice sounded. It frustrated her how conflicted this nagging thought made her feel, and how persistently this idea tried to pull her away from the lovely wine glass display. Thankfully, each turn of Michelle's finger around her wine glass would successfully recapture her attention each time this discomforting thought came to mind.
"For now," Michelle continued, "You need not bother to listen anymore. You may continue to watch for as long as you'd like, safe and comfortable, drifting into a wonderful reverie."
She welcomed this news, knowing that there was nothing wrong about watching. There was never a problem. Michelle's reassurance was a gracious and generous gift that she couldn't be thankful enough for. With her permission, she took a deep sigh, and leaned in, starting to now feel the weight of her head on her shoulders.
Turn after turn, each rotation relaxed and enraptured her more and more. She began to find new simple pleasures to appreciate. The subtle arcing of length of her finger between the left and right motions. The swaying and shifting of the wine in her vessel. Even the shimmering reflection of her hand from her drink perfectly complimented her view. She wondered if she should sway her head with the motion, completely unaware that her head had already been swaying.