The Grotto
You like to think you're a good person. You try to do what's best, fight for what's right, always stand your ground. All of that kind of stuff. You put a lot of effort into forming that image of yourself, and even if you slip up sometimes, you're still getting by.
"Hey, dipshit! Don't get lost in the reverie, that's a good way to slip and break your neck!" You tore your gaze from the pale stone walls surrounding you and flicked off Eva, your best friend of the last two years and, as she describes it, the reason you weren't yet dead from walking off a cliff or into traffic.
"What's got you so pensive, huh?" she asks, finishing hooking the rope to the cave's wall.
"Just thinking about life and how badly I must have fucked it to end up 200 feet underneath rural Kentucky with a psych major instead of, like, an actual spelunker."
Eva scoffed. "'An actual spelunker'? I'm more of a spelunker than you!"
"Never debated that, I'm just not sure if you're a good enough spelunker that you're 'trespass-in-a-national-park' good."
"I'm above and beyond, Robin." She winked at you as she performed one last yank test on the now-fastened rope. "Above. And. Beyond." She made her way down the rope. You rolled your eyes and followed her.
You had to admit, it was a beautiful cave. The two of you had driven down from Illinois earlier that weekend, and had camped the night before in a tucked-away corner of Mammoth Cave National Park. This morning, Eva had discovered a promising looking hole in the ground, and lo and behold, here you were: following your friend down a cliff with absolutely no chance of survival if one of you twisted an ankle. Living the dream.
So," you started again as your toes touched the floor. "Why isn't Rick here, exactly?" Rick, Eva's boyfriend of three months, was as the British say, a proper knob. He wasn't particularly bad at romance, but he simply shared no interests with Eva. He also carried with him your typical rich-kid-at-U-Chicago energy, which had always given you a bad taste in your mouth about him.
"Oh, you know Rick. He had to go do something or other with his family." Eva turned her face away from you for a moment, before turning back, temporarily blinding you with the flashlight on her helmet. "Hey, maybe he'll get some cash from his mom and buy me something pretty."
You laughed, the sound echoing from the walls. "Well, that'd make it all worth it!" Eva joined your laughter. It was good to be out together. You and her had six more weeks of university before your sophomore years were over and you could finally get to the real part of college. The two of you hiked on, the cave curving and dropping slightly, but never getting claustrophobic.
It was crazy this had never been mapped out before
, you thought before pushing the thought out of your mind.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"WOAH! ROBIN, HURRY YOUR SLOW ASS UP AND LOOK AT THIS!"
Your legs, your poor, poor legs, how they begged you not to continue. It had been an hour, but so long as there was a spot to put one foot in front of the other, Eva would take two. You pushed yourself around a curve, seeing Eva standing on a small incline, turned back to you with a hand extended to help you up. Even illuminated only by the light of your head lamp, she was beautiful: her auburn hair fell in locks across her shoulders, framing her pale face cutely. Her stature was more petite, only being 5'2", but she made up for it in pure adventurous spirit and the ability to consistently outperform you in bad decision making.
Grabbing her hand, you got onto the incline. She was right, the view was gorgeous. From your light, it was a reflectively wonderland of white stone. In the centre, there was a surprisingly clear pool of water. There didn't seem to be an exit, marking this as the end of the trail, but this little grotto was worth it.
Eva let out a satisfied sigh and leaned against your arm. "Isn't this perfect?" You nodded, satisfied with this trip (despite your legs' continued protest). You looked to Eva before-
Oh no.
She had an Eva Grin.
Before you could stop her, she was already leaping off the incline into the water. You braced yourself for the sounds of her screaming after her legs break on the shallow bottom but...
Nothing. She broke the surface laughing, allowing you to let out a sigh of relief.
"Eva!" You yelled as she continued laughing in the water. "All your gear is gonna be ruined! Also, we had no idea how deep that water was!"
"It's fine, it's fine," Eva said between laughs as she doggy-paddled her way back to dry land. "I put all my shit over there." Eva gestured towards a dimly-lit corner by the entrance. "Oh, you shoulda seen your FACE. Too good."
You had serious doubts she could see your face given that, now that you think about it, she hadn't been wearing her helmet before she jumped, but you let her have it. "Well, as long as you knew it wasn't just a shallow puddle," you concede.
"Oh, I had no idea how deep it was. That was a gamble."
Your face, could anyone have seen it, was once again red. You opened your mouth to say something, but then it was all let out in a sigh like a steam vent or particularly bad gas. "Please just don't die when you're in a situation that would leave me as the prime suspect."
Eva giggled adorably. "No promises, R. Now hop in, the water's ice cold and you will
not
get used to it."
Rolling your eyes again, you started to disrobe (Eva took off her already-soaked jacket as you did so). As you took off your helmet, you clicked off the light, leaving you in total darkness.
"Good call, Robin. This'll make it much easier to not drown."
"Oh shut up, you-" But, as you turned towards the general direction her voice had been coming from, you were caught off-guard by a soft blue light coming from the water. "E, you see that?" You took a cautious step towards the water.
"No, Robin, I do not see anything as you turned off the only light. Speaking of that, are you going to undo that any time soon?"
"Huh?" you said, snapping back to reality. "Oh, y-yeah." Fumbling slightly, you turn on the lamp. The blue light was invisible now. Flicking the light on and off again, you saw the light come in and out of existence. It was almost as if you could tell what was projecting it down in the water. Again, you're shaken out of your reverie by Eva.
"Robin, I get you're ADHD and all, but you NEED to learn to not tune people out, especially when you start throwing a rave in their awesome cave grotto." Eva takes your head lamp and puts it with all of your stuff, dimly illuminating the chamber. She then takes her own head lamp and places it on the other side of the grotto, improving the lighting from "sultry mood lighting" to "suburban swimming pool at night".
"Ha, try drowning in that, sucka!" Eva exclaimed. "Alright, let's swim this bitch UP."
You do, enjoying the cold water after that long, annoying hike. After a few minutes, though, your thoughts remain dominated by that blue light. You looked through the water.
It doesn't look that deep,
you thought.
No way in hell I'm explaining to Eva why I'm going deeper into this pool though.
And so, you waited for Eva to turn away before quietly slipping under the water.
The pool was maybe 9 feet deep; definitely nothing to write home about. It remained clear throughout as well. The lower you got, the more the blue light returned, and then you saw it: a necklace, with a spherical blue orb as its clasp. As soon as you touched it, the light died. The burning in your lungs outweighed your desire to question this, so you popped back up.
"Welcome back?" Eva said curiously, sipping her water on the "shoreline". For the record, I wouldn't have had a problem with you diving.
You pulled yourself next to her. "Well I would have."
Eva snorted. "Yeah, because you're boring."
You spent a moment more to catch your breath. "You play trumpet, Eva."
Eva grasped at her chest. "My heart, you wound it so with your anti-trumpet slander!" Finally, she spied the chain in your hand. "Aw, man. We weren't the first ones here."