"So," Paul intoned breezily. He regarded Olive across his coffee table as he used his chopsticks to wrestle a chunk of Mapo tofu. "You made it back to the city, and presumably not to see me again. How did you end up here?"
Olive sat on the floor with her legs crossed under the table, intently sawing away at an egg Foo young with a plastic knife. At his question, she looked up with a weary smile.
"I've been asking myself that question a lot today," she admitted ruefully. Then she narrowed her eyes and turned the knife on him. "But I think I deserve to ask some questions here," she said, punctuating her words with the utensil. Paul regarded her serious face with subdued amusement, but kept his mouth shut, which felt wise to do at knifepoint.
After showering off, Olive had slunk back into her comfy hoodie for dinner. Paul's loft wasn't drafty, but goosebumps had raised along her arms when he had swung the door wide open to greet the Chinese delivery guy while she was still lounging, disrobed, on the couch. Just when Olive thought she'd insured herself by stealing a photo of Paul with his freshly sucked cock out in the open, he'd had to move to put her back in her place like that.
He can never play these games of his on an even playing field, can he?
She could see him drink in her embarrassed indignation with great indulgence. The possibility crossed her mind that he might have been showing her off, too. Or, maybe the delivery guy was just as accustomed to seeing cum-drunk submissives in Paul's place as his neighbors were to hearing bumps (and moans, and screams) in the night.
As if to put the subject to rest, Olive stated matter-of-factly, "I started working at a law firm the same way you did, I went to school. I applied myself, or whatever. That's all." She took a crispy bite off the end of an egg roll and held Paul's gaze. Chewing, she pointedly added, "I've always been smart enough."
"I know."
Olive raised her eyebrows with surprise, then furrowed them with doubt. "Do you? I remember myself as pretty stupid." Her eyes searched Paul's face for his reaction to her words before clarifying, "When we last...did this, I mean." She gestured vaguely between them with her hands. "I feel stupid about it."
"You feel stupid about submitting to me, Olive?" A strange smile arched his cheekbones. "Do you think I enjoy spending time with stupid girls?"
She paused to consider how she could best convey all that she wanted to say. After swallowing Paul's cum, her mind felt mercifully clear, clearer than it had been since she was pulled out of her good sense and into his orbit.
Was that really only this morning?
It felt like ages away.
"Well, yes, I kind of do." She stared back at him, unyielding. "I was in a...volatile chapter of my life when we met each other." She swallowed. "Vulnerable. Impulsive. And several years younger than you. I made bad decisions. I feel like you recognized that my head wasn't quite screwed straight. And you dominated me anyways."
Paul listened calmly, then responded, "That is true. You were a wild, nasty little college girl. The first one to ever call me Daddy, too. Thanks a lot for
that
, by the way, I'm stuck with that kink forever now." His joke broke the tension and they both chuckled. He rose from the couch and joined her on the floor, pulling her head into his lap. She hugged her arms across her chest and looked up into his face, trying to gauge his earnestness.
"You're not stupid," he continued, "and I'm not either. I could see that you didn't think as highly of yourself as you should have...I could see that you were being reckless because you felt out of control."
Olive's lip quivered at the memory. "It was painful...I was dealing with so many things at once. I don't understand why that motivated me to seek out more pain." Her voice was coming out hoarse. "Punishment. Maybe I was so angry at myself for struggling, that I thought I deserved it. Or being wanted by someone, in any way, when I felt so worthless, made me feel special, I don't..." She curled up into a ball and rolled to the side, scrunching her body into the fetal position in his lap. "I don't know," she croaked. Somehow, it made her feel more ashamed to open up like this to Paul than it did to open up her asshole to his exploration. How could that possibly be?
Paul seemed to take Olive's sudden wave of emotion in stride. His hand snaked under her hoodie, resting not on her tits but softly on her stomach. He had always been good at aftercare.
"I have my own theories," he said calmly. "But do you want to ask me some more questions first?"
She unfurled her body and sprawled on her back, nestling her head in his crossed legs as she enjoyed the comforting warmth of his hand on her belly. "Thank you for giving me the choice. I do have questions." Paul nodded and brushed a stray strand of hair out of her eyes with his other hand, then moved to cradle her head. "I...don't feel alone in my head when I get an order from you. I don't really understand why I lose control like that. It's only with you. Did you do that to me? It's been years since I've seen you. How is it still so strong?"
Paul blinked as he took in her concerns. "Is that so?" he asked slowly. "Here I was thinking you were just a good, obedient girl..."
"There, like that!" she exclaimed as she jolted up in his lap and pointed at him. "You're doing that on purpose. Using those words."
Paul grabbed a handful of her hair, playfully tugging her head back downwards. He smirked down at her. "Are you suggesting that you have some sort of easily-exploited trigger phrase that allows someone like me to override your free will and turn you into my ideal submissive plaything?" Those last three words slid out of his lips with great relish as he dragged his fingernails along her scalp.
Olive's eyes rolled back into her head at the combination of sudden pain followed by pleasure. Her accusation sounded silly when he put it like that.
Paul said, "When I met you, you were...how to put it...generous. You'd go above and beyond to make any guy's fantasy a reality if they were kind to you and took you out for a nice dinner. You seemed to revel in making wet dreams come true. I got the impression that being a slut made you feel powerful when everything around you felt so chaotic."
Olive scoffed. "I don't feel very powerful right now."
"I don't think I have the answer you want to hear, unfortunately," Paul continued, playing with her hair. "Even if it'd scare you, I think it'd be pretty cut and dry if I was the one who made you this way. Submissive. Pliable. Compliant. If that were the case, then I'd be the only guy you'd have to worry about. And you could avoid me, and leave, and get away, like you did last time this became too much for you... "
Olive cleared her throat and clarified, "I didn't leave because I was scared of submitting to you. I left because I was scared that..." she hesitated at what she was about to lay bare, but pressed on, "my submission... didn't matter to you." She laid her hand over his hand on her stomach. "That