"I saw the angel in the marble and carved it until I set it free."
The students, buried in their work, only listened as the tall, older man walked by them and shouted the quote. The sunny day drifted in through the large windows, illuminating the mess of art and the products of it. Paintings, sculptures, and works in progress littered the room. In the middle, a small circle of young men and women worked on various pieces of art. The man paused by one such student. Early twenties, with freckles all over her body. Her red hair tied up in a ponytail as she sculpted a man holding an apple in clay. Transfixed by her art she worked even as the instructor stood behind her.
"Michelangelo is attributed with that quote. And I believe it. Artists do not see a piece of paper or a lump of clay and wonder what they can make out of it. An artist sees the finished piece in their mind, and goes about freeing it onto their canvas for the world to see."
The man put his hand on the young woman's shoulder. He gave it a slow and easy squeeze until she paused and looked at him. She smiled.
"So, how do you think I am doing in that regard, Mr. Pelletier?"
The man smiled, showing wrinkles from a life of luxury and sun. He looked at the sculpture and nodded.
"It is missing something, Ava."
He walked away without another word, continuing to talk about art and artists. Ava stood there, stunned. She looked back at the sculpture in disbelief.
For the rest of the class Ava only heard water sloshing around in her ears. She paid no attention to anything else except trying to figure out what Mr. Pelletier meant.
When the class dispersed, she felt no closer to the answer.
"Are you going to stay here all day, Ava?"
She looked to her left to see Mr. Pelletier watching her with an amused look in his eyes. The man reeked of professionalism, from the sharp suit to the perfect skin and hair. She turned to face him and wiped her hands off on a rag.
"I'm trying to see what you see."
"Well, that is impossible, Ava."
"You know what I mean. I was on a roll. And, with one sentence, I'm completely taken off my game. I've been looking, and looking, and I can't see what you mean. Can you help me, please?"
Mr. Pelletier chuckled softly. "My dear Ava, is one man's word enough to throw you from the artistic fever I caught you in? Are you that insecure about your own ability?"
Ava gripped the rag with her hands, wringing it in frustration. "No, sir, I am not. You know I am not. My work and the awards I have won with it prove that. But, we don't come to you for anything less than razor-sharp feedback. And you know that I've followed your work for years. Your feedback above anyone else means a lot to me."
Mr. Pelletier nodded, tapping his bottom lip with his finger. "I see."
He walked back to the sculpture. Ava followed behind him, curious. He regarded the sculpture for what seemed like days to Ava. She clenched her jaw, wanting to ask but knowing to stay silent.
Mr. Pelletier caught her nervous stature out of the corner of his eye. He smiled.
"It is technically proficient. It has a good style, and I like the pose. You have found your voice."
"But."
"You always expect a 'but', don't you? Tell me, were your parents supportive of this endeavor for you?"
"My Dad was a little hard on me. Said if I wanted to waste money being an artist I needed to be good."
"Ah, and so that has manifested in you being unable to accept a compliment without hearing the negative. Because to you, there must be a negative."
Ava stood there, stunned as Mr. Pelletier walked around the sculpture.
"Yes, yes. I see it now. I think I have an idea. See me tomorrow, and I think I have a solution to what you need."
"O-okay," Ava said, looking around. "Can you at least tell me what you see?"
Mr. Pelletier stopped in front of Ava. "You will be a great artist. You are only missing one thing."
He jabbed her in the chest with a finger. "Heart. You need to understand what it is to be the art, to be revealed to the world."
Ava raised an eyebrow. "What?"
"To understand art, you must be art."
Ava chuckled. "Well, how can I be this?" She said, motioning to her sculpture. "Be a statue?"
Mr. Pelletier's smile unnerved Ava slightly. "Perhaps. Now. Go. I'll see you tomorrow."
Ava walked out of the room, her head spinning but hopeful for the next day.
***
"Ah, Ava, perfect. Come here."