Both the women were laughing now, as Karen unbound Lisa's hands. They stood, hugging each other as Karen scanned over the room. Everyone else was back to playing with each other in smaller fuck and suck groups throughout the room.
Lisa squeezed Karen's ass, and asked, "What's next...my Mistress?"
Hearing Lisa call her Mistress filled her with a glowing pride and brought another smile to Karen's lips. She responded, "Oh, I have oodles of ideas." Clapping her hands for attention, Karen projected, loudly, "Okay everyone, sorry to put a damper on all the fun you're having, but it's time for another game. Gather in a circle around the middle of the room."
As directed, all the guests gathered in a circle, some sitting on the furniture, others languishing on the floor, and all were piqued with excitement waiting for what Karen had in store for them.
Her Highness, Queen Mistress, resumed her position alongside of me on the lounger. She began by saying, "I call this little game Fantasy Island. Now, I know some of you already, so I'm just going to involve the newbies in this. Each of you women new to our little gathering will take a turn in the middle of the circle and play out your deepest, sexually darkest, fantasy for the rest of us. It has to be something you've never done before and no one else knows about. Does everyone agree?"
Everyone nodded their head.
"Wonderful. Lisa, since you were last during the previous game, why don't you be the first, now."
I could tell Lisa was nervous as she sat on the floor in the middle of the throng.
"Okay Lisa," Karen asked, "What's that one fantasy you've always harbored and never told anyone?"
She thought for a long minute before answering, and when she did, she spoke with embarrassed hesitation, "Well, for the longest time now, I've daydreamed of Bob catching me with another man." She paused for a moment, then looked directly at her husband as she continued, "Ever since you didn't feel like doing it, I had this dream that I'm fucking another guy, and it's really hot, but I'm really stupid because he's fucking me in our bedroom. I figure, you're always working and Barbara's at school, so why not fuck him in our bed. It makes me feel so hot, and so much like a naughty slut that some other guy's doing me where you should be doing me. And the guy gets really turned on knowing he's fucking another guy's wife in his bedroom."
"Is the other guy someone we know?" Karen chimed in, and winked.
This was a dangerous game Lisa was playing, relaying a fantasy so close to her own adulterous behavior. It was also a brilliant ploy. I didn't think this was as much a fantasy of hers, per se, but more of a way she could lay the foundation for forgiveness in case Bob ever found out about Lisa and me.
Clever girl.
"No," Lisa answered. "I mean he doesn't even have a face in my daydreams. I know he's handsome, in a general way, and has a great body, and a...and a pretty big dick."
All the women clapped and hooted approval at that.
Really ladies, keep telling me size doesn't matter and I'll keep laughing.
Lisa let the revelry die down before returning her eyes to Bob, and continued, "Well as you can guess, you come home unexpectedly. The slut wife caught cheating on her good and wonderful husband. But you don't say anything right away. Instead, you stand in the doorway watching us for a long while. The guy's lying with his head on the pillow with his eyes closed, while I'm giving him a blowjob with my back to you, and I'm kneeling as I suck his cock. And you watch as his cock slides in and out of my mouth, and my ass is high in the air pointing back at you. And instead of getting mad, the whole scene is turning you on as I blow this other guy."
Bob was momentarily shocked and taken aback by what he heard from his wife, especially because she didn't like giving blowjobs, but now it was central to her fantasy. He became curious to know what else she was dreaming about, "Do you do anything else besides blow this guy?"
"Other times, you catch us as he's fucking me doggy style, or when he's going down on me." She hesitated again, not sure if she should say anything more, but she decided to let Bob hear it all, "And sometimes he begs me to...to...you know...fuck me in the butt...and I let him...and I like it."
Clever girl, indeed.
Now, all the men clapped and hooted their approval.
Lisa quickly broke in to amend her last confession, "But I like the blowjob version the best."
There was unmistakable hurt in Bob's eyes, hearing her fantasies about sexual acts she rarely, if not outright refused, to perform with him. Then he asked, with a little anger in his voice, "So what do I do, just turn around and leave and let you finish sucking the guy off?"
She saw his hurt, and with pity in her eyes, mouthed a silent, "No," while shaking her head slowly. She stared hard at Bob, unblinking, her eyes beginning to water, "Please don't be mad. It's just a fantasy, honey. I love you and you only!"
Her sincerity was obvious and real. Everyone uttered a long, thoughtful, "Aw." Even Bob blushed, hearing her public and affectionate declaration of love for him.
Lisa wiped the moisture from her eyes, and continued, "Of course you're mad at first, furious in fact. You yell, 'What the fuck are you doing, you stupid whore?!'" She said it in a deep voice, trying to mimic Bob, making everyone laugh. "I just about bite the guy's dick off when I hear you, I'm so startled. I turn around and see your angry, hurt face, and I'm terrified and ashamed at the same time for what I'm doing, mostly because I know I hurt you. And I'm wondering if you're going to call a lawyer right then, or hit me first and then call a lawyer. But you don't do any of that, because it was turning you on. Instead, you stand over us on the side of the bed. You still have this angry look, but it's fake. I don't know that, so I'm shaking, not sure if you're going to hit me. Then, in a really rough voice, you tell me to keep sucking his cock. I'm confused now, and not sure what you're doing, and I'm still scared shitless. The guy's scared shitless too, and his cock is soft, but I know I better do what you say, so I suck it anyway because I don't want to make you madder. And as I'm sucking on him, you start spanking me, just like Mark did to Linda, but it's way harder. And you call me a slut and a whore, and tell me to keep sucking on him like the cheating cunt I am, all while you keep spanking me.
Everyone yells, "Yeah, go Bob, spank that little slut!"
As we all quiet down, Lisa finishes her fantasy, "My ass is on fire from all your rough slapping, but I don't care because you got me so horny. I mean, I could feel my cunt juice dripping down my thighs I was so hot. You stick your fingers in me and feel how drenched you made me, and you're turned on even more than me. When you go back to spanking me, I come, really hard, and keep coming every time you hit my ass. By now, the guy's figured out you're not going to kill him, and he's hard as a rock in my mouth. And I'm sucking on him hard and fast, your spanking me hard and fast, and I'm coming hard and fast, and we're all fucking on fire. You finally tell me to turn around, and then shove your hard cock all the way in my mouth. Both you and he start slam-fucking me hard for both directions. He's got a hold of my hips, pounding my pussy like there's no tomorrow, you've got a hold of my head as you're fucking my mouth and making me choke and gag, and I'm loving every second because I keep coming like a slut in heat. Then he comes. Then you come, and it's such a turn-on. You just shove your cock all the way in and shoot one heavy load after another down my throat. It's like a gallon of come. And feeling you fill me makes me come even harder. After that, he leaves and we fuck again, and again, and again. And the best part of my fantasy, from then on, you can't stop fucking me. You can't keep your hands off me. Every day, you come home for lunch for a quick blowjob. When you come home for dinner you slam-fuck me against the wall denting the drywall with my ass or you fuck me hard in my butt until I scream from one shattering orgasm after the other. And when you come home from your second job, you spank me again until I come, and fuck all my wet holes for hours."
After she got done telling her fantasy, everyone was ready to start fucking in frenzy, we were turned on so much. Bob flew into the middle of the circle with Lisa, pushed her flat on the floor, as he kissed her deeply. Everyone cheered, hooted and hollered at their display.
Karen asked, "Okay Lisa, we all know whose playing Bob, but who do you want to play your mystery fella'?"