I thought of taking it to the next level. I told her to come sit on my lap and kiss me, which she did. Then I told her to remove her sweater and top. To my amazement, she did as I said. Now I was almost convinced that I had her under control. I told her to get on her knees and suck my cock. She came forward and kneeled in front of me. She unbuckled my pants and slipped down my boxers. My already hard cock sprang out in front of her. She held it in her hands and slowly brought her head down and licked the pre-cum leaking from my cock. Then she circled her tongue on the tip and slowly took my cock inside her mouth while running her tongue over my shaft. She had no difficulty taking my entire length and deep throating me, which told me she wasn't a rookie. She started boobing her head up and down slowly, almost like teasing me. Then she started increasing her pace and then back to slow. This was edging me and I had to cum. I held her head in one place and started fucking her mouth. After a few minutes, I couldn't hold any longer and burst inside her pretty mouth. I haven't cummed this much in a long while. Her mouth was full of it and some of it was leaking out. I told her to swallow it whole and lick my cock clean.
Then I told her to take off her remaining clothes and get into the bedroom. I got naked and followed her in. I saw her amazing body for the first time and boy, was it a hot sight. Those round breasts and pointy nipples. Her pussy was clean shaved and I could see it glistening with juices. Her body was reacting even though she was unaware of what she was doing.
I started by sucking her breasts and gently nibbling her nipples. She moaned slightly every time I did that. Meanwhile, my hand found her pussy, which was dripping wet. Then I got up and pointed my cock at her pussy. I started pushing it in slowly at first. She was so tight. I knew she wasn't a virgin, but still her pussy was so tight. Her pussy was clutching my cock so hard. I started thrusting slowly and kept pushing it in. Then, with a final thrust, my entire cock was inside her and it felt so good. I stayed like that for a while. Then I started fucking her. I started with slow thrusts and once I got adjusted to motion I increased my pace. It was very quiet, so each thrust was echoing around the room.
The voice of my balls slapping her ass cheeks was driving me crazy. And I guess she was having the same effect because I felt her pussy suddenly closing in on my cock. I looked at her face and I knew she was about to orgasm and I knew I was about to too. I kept thrusting as fast as I could and with each sound I was reaching close to cum. I thought of covering her breasts with my cum but before I could pull out, I lost control and started cumming inside her tight pussy and evidently she had orgasmed at the same time because my cum was oozing out of her pussy along with her own juices. I don't think I have ever cummed this much.
I stayed like that and let my cock get soft inside her. That's when Penny spoke, "So how did you like your Christmas present?" with a evil grin on her face. And that's when it hit me that the pills were indeed a hoax, and she took full advantage of that. I could feel my cock getting hard again. I pulled out of her and smacked her ass and ordered her to turn over. The night was far from over...