Please read Part I of The Scoutmasters Wife before reading this. It will make more sense and a more fulfilling reading experience.
* * * * *
I had a second window into the adult world that Saturday night. I had just experienced intimacy with an older woman, but now I had to make a difficult choice, the kind of choice adults often make. MaryAnn had called twice in my absence and wanted to go out that night. I wanted to go out, too, but Carol was waiting for me, almost begging to be fucked. But I sensed that MaryAnn and I would break up if I didn't go. Plus, my mother was on MaryAnn's side. She liked her. If I ducked out and went back to Carol's my mom would be suspicious. And that might blow everything. I'd lose both.
I'd like to say I was mature enough to have made the right decision on my own, but my mother was really the deciding factor. I showered, made a quick phone call of apology to Carol and left to go out with MaryAnn and two other couples. Carol was very disappointed, to say the least. I heard her voice echo in my ears right up until the movie began. After the movie we ended up necking out by the lake after a stop for burgers. The third couple drove separately and parked nearby. I was glad they drove alone because I found the guy a macho type with few smarts and he annoyed me. MaryAnn and I cuddled beneath a blanket in the back seat of a Chevrolet station wagon that belonged to her friend's mom. I heard the friend and her date giggling in front, which was kind of a turn-on.
Thinking back, it was probably MaryAnn's frustration that made her a little looser that night... or the other couple in front. Maybe she thought she needed to "put out" to help our relationship. Whatever the case, I managed to get MaryAnn's pants and panties off and spent at least a half-hour getting to know her pussy intimately with my fingers. She had less pubic hair than Carol and seemed smoother or softer inside. Maybe because she was less experienced, she came quicker, cutely suppressing her little squeals of pleasure. She came twice in a span of 15 minutes and returned the favor, somewhat timidly. She did it, though, and I made a mess on that blanket. It could have been worse. I had already come in the shower when I got back from Carol's.
I drove home at 2 am through misty fields, braking for rabbits and watching the moon through the trees. Life was good. I laughed out loud at one point, wondering who was going to clean that blanket. Several times I lifted my index and middle finger to my nose and sniffed essence of MaryAnn, then sniffed again. What a day!
I called Carol the next morning but missed her. She'd gone to church. By the time she got home my dad had a "project" for me at his business. I spent the afternoon sullenly moving files and desks and scraping old linoleum from the floor. Dad cheerfully pointed out that I didn't need to workout that day because it was such good exercise. I gave him a disgusted look and attacked a stubborn patch of linoleum adhesive. What would he say if I told him I could have gotten laid instead?
Monday evening Carol and I finally met again for a workout. To my great disappointment her husband was home. I was sooooo pissed.
"How was your date?" Carol asked cheerfully.
"Good" I replied. "Very good".
"What did you guys do?"
"Movie. Eats... The Lake."
"Parking?" Carol asked, sitting down besides me. "How far did you get with "Miss Malted."
"A gentleman NEVER tells" I said, giving her a long and pointed look. She ignored me. I thought I was supposed to get credit for saying that.
"Oh, but you can tell ME! I'm a woman. It's not like locker room talk among men that would hurt a gal's reputation... Did you get as far as this?" she asked, pinching my nipple playfully and giving me a wink.
I tried not to react, but she saw something in my eyes and moved down towards my crotch.
"You did! Oh, well... did you get this far?" she asked, sitting besides me and rubbing my hardening dick through my shorts and looking up seductively.
I said nothing, but smiled. Big time. This was better than I expected with her husband home.
"Hmmm. That MaryAnn is a tart!" (I guess she knew her name after all)
"Did you go all the way with her?"
Carol looked serious now, and a little vulnerable. I debated how to answer, then shook my head. Carol was obviously relieved. The teasing tone left her voice and she spoke quietly.
"Good. I want to be the first, you know... I've wanted you for weeks."
I stopped my leg reps and Carol laid her head on my chest, looking up at me. It was a "wow" moment, even if it wasn't sexual. Carol then surprised me by straddling my body and getting on top of me. It wasn't comfortable, but it was sexy. She kissed me tentatively, then passionately, balancing her body along mine and shifting slightly to feel my hardness.
"I went to church Sunday. Guilt, probably. I don't go that often anymore. It's never been the same since I stopped teaching Sunday School there years ago. Anyway... I was looking for a sign to stop things with you. I got nothing from it. Nothing. I started to get mad after a while. So many hypocrites saying "Amen" to everything. The car dealer screws everybody on every deal... The mayor treats his wife like dirt... What's his name, the contractor, had to give back 15,000 dollars he overcharged the Board of Education... "
"I'm no better" she continued. "I'm Miss Prim, the Scoutmaster's wife. For weeks I walked around with wet panties thinking about a certain young man... then I let him rub my body and take my panties off and touch me like husband and wife."
I just raised my eyebrows. I didn't know what to say. Carol snuggled against me and whispered.
"What's even worse... I don't care. I want you. I want to teach you the right way to make love to a woman... the right things to say... and like the words to that song, I want you to want me. Who wrote that? Rod Stewart?... No, I'm showing my age. I'm totally off."
My position wasn't comfortable with Carol on top of me, but I didn't want her to move, so I slowly took a deep breath and tried to make my voice sound normal.
"You may have wanted me for weeks, but I've wanted you for months."
I reached up and pretended to grab Carol casually to balance her, but really I just wanted to get my hands on her. I held her ass cheeks and massaged very lightly. Carol raised her eyebrows and wiggled slightly, smiling seductively.
It was more than I could take. I spoke up.
"I have a confession to make"
Carol gave me a quizzical look.
"I'm very uncomfortable. Can we move to the floor or something? This bench is narrow and hard".
Carol jumped up and apologized.
"Sorry. Finish your reps. I'll... spot for you".
It wasn't what I had in mind but Carol grinned and stood close to me while I bench-pressed my quota. She stroked my biceps approvingly, then stood and flapped the bottom of her sweatshirt.
"It's hot in here."
It wasn't. Carol just wanted an excuse to tease me. When she pulled her sweatshirt out I could see her yellow bra. I stopped pumping to stare at those beautiful breasts sticking out in that yellow bra, but she let the sweatshirt drop back against her body.