Rachel Grant managed to find a free afternoon every week for a month, but never felt the need to make Lewis Carter do anything except strip naked and then kneel while she remained fully clothed. That was enough to reinforce her feelings of powerful control and was in many ways similar to what her friend made him do on Sunday mornings although they never discussed it. The only real differences were that Rachel fucked him after he'd spent five or ten minutes with his 23-year-old head between her 50-year-old legs, and Claire just sent him on his way with a painful boner that took Lewis two minutes in the shower to get rid of.
Neither woman cared what the other did with Lewis, although Rachel kept expecting her friend to at least mention the marks and scratches on his back, even though she never seemed to leave any of her own. She didn't know that her friend never saw their shared pleasure toy without a shirt on, and Claire simply assumed that Rachel made Lewis do exactly what she did: go down until she couldn't take anymore and then tell him to go.
The mutual cover stories worked like a charm, with Rachel even telling friends and family that she helped out at the church before playing tennis every week, until one Monday evening Emma Payton overheard the pair of them tell Lewis's mother that they'd been to a gym together after the service, when she knew that it had been closed for repairs to the roof. And not only did she know that Claire and Rachel had lied, but she also knew that Lewis hadn't been with her son all day either as he'd spent it working on that very same gym's roof for over 12 hours due to an emergency leak repair.
Emma didn't know if the two lies were connected, but as they'd been told to the same person, she started to wonder if one of her friends had been with an attractive, possibly available, 23-year-old, and the other was providing an alibi.
Emma Payton got home an hour or so later, picked up her son's phone while he was in the shower, and knowing that her birthday was his PIN, tapped it into his keypad. She then scrolled through the contacts until she found Lewis's number, added her friend's son's details into her own phone, told her husband that she was having an early night, and went upstairs.
She sat down on the edge of the bed, spent twenty minutes thinking about what message to send, and eventually settled on a simple nondescript lie: "I know about yesterday, and I've got some very interesting pictures."
She sniggered to herself and waited. Emma knew absolutely nothing about what, if anything, Lewis had done the day before, and didn't have any pictures, but unless he was bold enough to call her bluff, that wouldn't matter. She'd known her friend's son since he was a naive teenager, and now he was an attractive but easily manipulated, young man who was in her opinion more likely to panic than stay calm if he had something to hide.