This is a work of fiction. All characters are 18.
*****
I've had a lot of sex. A lot. As a straight man in the theatre world I've had my choice of the ladies in most shows; married, single, older, younger. Dancers, ahh...the flexibility and athleticism...singers...they know how to use their mouths and breath.
This particular story begins about 8 years ago. I had been substituting at a local high school. My wife was back in grad school, and I needed to make some extra money. With my background, the district asked if I would help direct the high school show. I agreed, as the money was good and the pool of talent was reasonably sized and passionate. I chose the show with the drama club, and we were off to the races.
I was 30 at the time. Having performed quite a bit I was in exceptional shape, and my last gig had been on a cruise in the Caribbean, so I was tan as well. It became apparent that most of the high school girls had a crush on me, but they were kids. Even the 18 year olds looked like kids...until auditions.
Auditions were held on a rainy night, and I was packing up after everyone had sung their songs and done their cold readings. I heard the door to the auditorium creak open, and I turned, seeing a completely drenched young woman curiously peeking around.
"Here to audition?" I asked.
I must have taken her by surprise, for she let out a little yelp, then answered, "My car broke down. I just ran a mile."
"Yikes," I replied. "If you want to dry off and get your bearings, I'm in no rush."
She seemed relieved, and said she'd be right back, flashing an amazing dimpled smile and leaving the way she came in. That smile. Wow.
She returned from her locker with a towel (she was on the swim team), and filled out the paperwork. I was writing notes on other people's audition cards until she finished, and I sat down at the piano to play for her. She was incredible. Easily the best I had heard all night. I also got a chance to fully see her, on stage, selling it. Her body was toned and tanned, like mine. Her hair, now drying, had lazy curls and it hung to the middle of her back.
"Why aren't you in the drama club?" I asked, and looked at her card. Her name was Carly. A senior.
"...Nerds," she replied. "Just kidding," and flashed that smile again. Her eyes sparkled. "I was until this year. I am trying to load up on different experiences for college applications. Some things had to go."
Over the course of the show Carly and I grew to have quite a sarcastic, flirtatious relationship. We hit it off, you could say. While I found her attractive, she was still a student. I was also fucking the music director (a 40 year old married woman named Mary...who loved it on the piano) most nights, and my wife once a week (because the marriage rumors are true), so I never really had desire rule my life.
After the show was over, she and I became friends on Facebook, and I thought it would be alright because I would probably never see her again. I could keep up with her, and she could keep up with me. Nothing more.
She graduated, and was accepted to a prestigious east coast school. End of story. Or so I thought.
My wife had found out through a friend that a local theatre was doing one of my favorite shows, and she let me know about auditions. I decided to do the show. At the first read through, I walk into the auditorium and who should be there, but Carly. She ran up to me and gave me a hug.
We caught up while we waited for rehearsal to start. She glowed. As introductions were made, I noticed that the rehearsal accompanist, choreographer, music director, and artistic director were all male.
I was in trouble.
The first week of rehearsal Carly was always by my side. We only knew each other, so it was natural for us to cling to each other. We would chat when we weren't needed on stage, and I came to find out a lot about her. She had dated several guys briefly in school, and was still a virgin. She offered that information. I didn't ask.
We grew much closer throughout the show and the production went well. Her 18 year old body was incredible. She was tight in all the right places. Nearly as tall as me, her thighs were delectable. Her chest wasn't huge, but it was a perfect handful, or so I guessed.