Jane stared at the clock in her physics class. 5 minutes left in the school day. It was torture. It was impossible to think about anything school related. All she could think about was Olivia. Ever since they hooked up, things had been weird. Olivia had left the next morning without saying goodbye. Jane texted a few times but Olivia's responses were short and generic. "Let's catch up later when things calm down!" or "Finals suck!" or sometimes just an emoji. Had Jane made a mistake?
And worse than the anxiety about Olivia was the constant horniness. Now that she knew how good sex could be, she couldn't stop thinking about it. When would she have it again? Would it be better or worse with a guy? Should she try again with Brian? Every night, when she went to bed, she tried to fall asleep without obsessing about Olivia. But eventually she would start thinking about that night. How Olivia brought her lips together to suck on her nipples. The way Olivia's ass felt in her hands. How hard Olivia made her come. And without even realizing it, she would find her hand in her underwear, wet as fuck, on the brink of an orgasm. Even in class, she couldn't stop thinking about dirty things.
For some reason her eyes drifted to Mr. Fitz, her physics teacher. He was very popular with the students. He was tall and good looking, with a great body, probably from all of the time he spent hiking or windsurfing. He loved being outside. He could also really nerd out about science but was a great teacher. Most of the student body wanted to fuck him or be his best friend. Jane had watched her classmates try and flirt with him but he never reacted. Jane didn't know whether he was clueless or had phenomenal willpower.
Finally, the bell rang. As Jane gathered her things, Mr. Fitz called on her. "Jane, could you stay for a minute?" Jane nodded and let the other students file out. Mr. Fitz shut the door and walked to her seat at the back of the classroom. He sat down on the stool next to her. "I am a little concerned about you, "he began. "You have been very distracted this week. I know you aren't worried about grades- I am sure you could ace the final if I gave it to you right now. But this is out of character for you. Is everything okay?"
Jane was torn. Between the fact that someone she respected was offering some guidance. And the fact that she couldn't stop staring at his lips and wondering what they felt like. She really needed to get a grip. She decided to go with option A and tried to figure out a way to explain what happened with Olivia without going into too much detail.
"Olivia and I had, well, kind of a moment and I am trying to figure out what it means, "Jane said.
"You had a fight?"
"No, "Jane looked down. "The opposite."
"Oh, I see, "said Mr. Fitz. He clearly hadn't been expecting that.
"And now I don't know what to do. Did I ruin things with Olivia? Am I gay? Am I bi? What if Olivia doesn't want to talk to me anymore?" Jane started to tear up a little at the thought.
Mr. Fitz was silent. He looked like he was trying to figure out a good response. He seemed to care about his students but also maintained that teacher/student boundary. After a moment, he finally said, "I think preferences are something that are fluid and that isn't something you have to figure out at this moment. It seems like the most important thing to you is how Olivia feels. Have you talked to her? Are you sure she interpreted the moment the same way?"
Jane couldn't help herself and started laughing through the tears. "Well, we spent a night together naked in my bed! I don't know how many ways to interpret that!" And before she knew it, the whole story came tumbling out. How Jane was not satisfied with Brian. How Olivia offered to show her what feels good. And what started as nipple play and kissing turned into hours of oral and heavy petting. Jane couldn't believe that she was telling this to a teacher. But he wasn't stopping her. And it felt good to tell someone.
Then two things happened. The first thing was that Jane started to get turned on again. Since that night with Olivia, it was as if her pussy was always on simmer. And now she had just turned up the flame. The second thing was that Jane noticed Mr. Fitz was definitely turned on. While Olivia had always been the outgoing one, Jane had always been an observer. She could read people well. And she saw how Mr. Fitz had become completely still. Every muscle in his neck was tense and is powerful hands were clenched into fists at his knees. His dark eyes were fixed on her. And she detected a bulge in his very sensible khakis. The old Jane would have thanked him for listening, made up a reason to leave, and let him collect himself. But she was a little different now.
Jane tentatively continued, testing the waters. "My problem is, I don't know if everything was so amazing because it was a girl or because it was Olivia. Nothing like that had ever happened with my boyfriend. Do you think it's possible I was just with the wrong guy? Should I try a different guy?"
"I think that's not the best question for your teacher." But he didn't say it very convincingly. He tried to loosen his collar but he couldn't move too much or it would expose his growing erection more. He turned to look her in the eye once more. Maybe he thought he would appear more certain in his refusal. But Jane only saw lust in his eyes. And now he couldn't seem to look away. Jane saw an opportunity.
"Maybe I need someone with more experience, "she said and she picked up his closest hand and placed in on her thigh. She picked a very good day to wear a sundress to school.