Note: you will understand this story a lot better if you read Part One first.
***
Chapter Eleven
By the next evening, I had come up with a pretty good plan to enjoy time with both present-day Erin and 18-year-old Erin. Of course I was anxious to get things underway but I had to be patient. After she'd put her boys to bed, I watched her change into a very sexy, dark green nightgown that looked fantastic on her body and against her fair skin. I'm not sure how she ever got close to drowsing off since she seemed as amped up as I was but, as she followed my suggestions, she was going through my online profile when her eyelids finally started to get heavy. I didn't even bother to plan something to wear since I knew it would be coming off immediately. When I felt the moment was right, I just appeared, kneeling near her feet, naked and sporting wood. I'd been there already while waiting since I had a nice view under her nightgown which is why I was already rigid. I had to resist the urge to lower my head and eat her pussy but I knew I'd get the opportunity before the "dream" was over.
I had reached over and put her tablet to sleep just before I appeared so everything seemed copacetic when she realized I was there. When she noticed that the screen was blank, she set it aside while gazing at my rigid cock. Once I was sure she was awake enough, I pulled her down the bed so she was lying flat on her back rather than propped up against her pillows and headboard. This caused her sexy nightgown to ride up almost all the way to her tits, so I pushed it the rest of the way up to expose them. Her nipples were hard so I leaned down to suck them then guided my cock into her and supported myself over her. As I started to slowly fuck her missionary-style, I brought my lips to hers and we made out while I was sliding my cock in and out of her hot, wet pussy. As good as her pussy felt from the moment I slipped into it, I was still anxious to feel young Erin's pussy again so I started thinking about one of our make-out sessions in my old bedroom.
In addition to Erin's pussy becoming tighter mid-fuck, I could also feel clothing and a few other more subtle differences as we went back. I propped myself up so I could look down at her, noting that the same long skirt was up around her waist and her halter top up above her tits as well as her long, black hair spread out on my pillow. I smiled down at her then we went back to making out. She was raising her hips to accept my incoming thrusts so I was getting maximum penetration and her young pussy, though apparently not virginal since she clearly wasn't experiencing any discomfort, felt outstanding. Since getting us to my former bedroom had gone so smoothly, I went ahead and relocated us again after a few minutes of flashback fucking. This time, we were in my college dorm during Christmas break, about a year and a half after that afternoon in my bedroom.
Erin had received a pair of tickets to see Les Miserables on Broadway as a Christmas gift. Because I was attending college in New York City, she invited me to go with her, supposedly with no ulterior motive and solely to take advantage of my knowledge of the city. I'd given her a tour of the campus and we stopped by my dorm but nothing happened while we were there. I was prepared to change that. When it was clear that the scene had changed again, she looked around as I continued to slide my cock in and out of her. She smiled when she realized where we were and when. While I had the opportunity, before we went back to making out, I looked down to see that her black skirt, which I recalled being fairly short and pretty snug, was up around her waist, she was wearing black stockings with garters and her blouse was unbuttoned and her bra unfastened and pushed up above her titties. Aside from the skirt and blouse, I wasn't sure whether any of the rest of it was accurate, but it didn't really matter. It did cross my mind, however, that it might be fun to start that whole scene from the beginning and see how it had started. For the moment, though, I just continued to fuck her still snug pussy as we went back to making out for a bit longer before I changed things up again.
I didn't want to remain over her and not get to see her young body but the plan I'd come up with also didn't involve just suddenly getting naked. While she appeared to be enjoying my return visit to her "dream," she hadn't cum yet and I wanted to make sure that happened then I'd get her naked and work on my own orgasm. After fucking her in the missionary position for a bit as we were making out, I stopped and slipped out of her then got to my knees. I had her turn over and get on all-fours then I guided my cock back into her hot, slippery pussy. Holding her hips, I went back to fucking her, slowly at first but gradually picking up my pace. Her skirt was still up around her waist so I could watch her ass jiggle slightly each time my hips tapped against it. She dropped her head down and reached back under herself, presumably to stroke her clit, which had to be a present-day Erin technique.
I savored the pleasurable feeling of fucking her and hoped that she was feeling even more pleasure and building toward an orgasm in this position. Even though I wasn't seeing much more of her naked in this position, I still had a plan, but the goal was for her to cum first before moving on. I was certainly having a good time, not only because I was fucking both young 18-year-old Erin and present-day Erin but also because of how smoothly everything was going despite the insanity of the very idea that this could be possible. I had a feeling that I had barely tested the limits at this point and that I was going to continue to be pleasantly surprised.
I could tell when Erin was approaching an orgasm not only by how much hotter and wetter her pussy was feeling but also by how she was pushing back against my thrusting. My hips were really smacking against her ass and she was moaning louder and longer. I'd been planning to reach forward to fondle her tits as I was fucking her but, since she was setting a hard, fast pace in pursuit of her orgasm, I didn't want to throw that off. Instead, I held onto her hips and pushed into her each time her ass hit my hips. Her pussy felt outstanding and I was once again amazed that I'd been able to go back to this moment in time and experience it differently. When she finally pushed back and just stayed there, I held my cock deep inside her and, when she started shaking, I could feel her pussy working on my cock. Her orgasm was long and appeared to be quite intensely pleasurable.