I get this email one morning.
Dear Jack,
I enjoyed your visit so much and so did Gary. It was poor weather but it is much improved now. Perhaps we should have postponed Jack junior's christening a few months. Do you think we would have been tempted to consummate our relationship if we hadn't have been in that room by ourselves?
I guess we will never know. What we have done is done and we can't change it. I wonder if it was worth it. I have to explain. You see Jack, you left me a souvenir to remember you by. Do you remember how vigorously we indulged ourselves in each other in intercourse while Gary was away?
It just happened he had to go out of town for a two week period just after you left so we didn't have a chance for sex. Remember I was still nursing the baby. The point is I was not taking the pill at that time so your deposit was the only deposit in my pouch when my egg arrived.
I'm pregnant, Jack and it's not Gary's this time. I have thought to have it aborted or whether to try and convince Gary it is his but now I realize you have some say in what course I take. I need a speedy reply since it has been three months now since your visit. Please tell me your wishes.
Gina
To say you could have knocked me down with a feather was an understatement. So many things ran through my head. 'It was only sex!' 'Why didn't she tell me?' 'Did she even think of it?,' 'OMG but it was good sex!' 'What does she want me to say?' 'If I don't reply she won't know I saw it and she can make the decision.' 'That would be so rotten.' 'Damn, it was good sex!' 'I wonder if I can lure her down here some time?'
I send off a reply to her email.
Dear Gina
I doubt you will ever share this email with Gary. I wish you were here to tell me in person. I think I would be overjoyed at your news or at least feel good about it. It proves our short time together now means we have a permanent bond.
As for what you do about it I know I cannot advise you to have it terminated. I think your idea of letting Gary think he is the father is a good idea. The two of you must have had sex just before my arrival or close enough since the baby was nearly a year old and you were still off the pill. Are you sure its me? What does your doctor say about how pregnant you are?
Anything you need from me will always be yours. I think you know that. Please let me know how you decide it.
Jack
Co-incidentally my firm informed me my presence would be necessary in Kalamazoo, Michigan the next week. The minute I got the news I sent off a new email to Gina telling her I would be in the area and leaving it up to her what she wanted to do about it.
She called me.
"Jack, are you there?"
"Gina, it's a real thrill to hear your voice. What ever happened to leave you in the spot you claim to be? Why didn't you tell me you were off the pill?"
"Oh Jack. Its such a foolish mistake. Gary and I only had sex for a few weeks before your arrival down here and I hadn't started the pill again after the pregnancy. Remember he was out of town much of the time before your visit so when we did it that was really special. It had been a while for me and it was just so damn good with you. I never realized how good it would be with you, my sweet friend."
"Well I guess we can't make you any more pregnant than you are." I chuckled, "Do you want to try for some more?"
"That's why I called. Gary is out of town again for another two weeks. Can you make it into the city? I'd love to jump in the sack with you again." She is laughing likely.
"Are you and Gary not doing well? I mean are you not getting along with each other?"
"I'm glad you asked, Jack. I don't want you to think any less of Gary or myself because of what we are doing. This is specifically recreational sex with you, there are no feelings involved. I'm not secretly in love with you or anything like that. "We just have terrific chemistry. Don't we?"
"We do have that! I can remember the ski lodge like it was yesterday and the long empty time before we could finish what we started back then. Just your voice is now making me drip precum in my pants."