My affair with Judy lasted almost a full five years. We were never caught and no one ever suspected anything about us. The only two people that knew were my wife, who Judy confessed to last summer, and Judy's friend Jennifer, who Judy told a long time ago and who I hooked up with separately.
Had we wanted to, we could have kept going. Even today, we could still be hooking up once a week and having an amazing affair but it got to the point where neither of us really wanted to continue it. I think Judy confessed to my wife to make herself feel better. Almost as if confessing would ease the burden. It didn't. Not for her at least.
I remain shocked that my wife was cool with it. The truth is that she was very okay with her mother and I hooking up as long as A) she never caught us and B) her mother was the only other woman for me. Those conditions were super easy to stick to but, like I said above, months after the confession, the affair became less fun and we just kind of lost the desire to continue it.
We both realized it was over this winter. My in-laws as well as my sister-in-law and her husband were down in FL visiting our place because my FIL wanted to go to the tennis tournament in Miami. I stayed back due to work obligations and Judy stayed back because she hated sports. The other four went. They would be gone overnight. Judy and I hooked up in the afternoon and, to be honest, it felt forced.
It felt like we had to do it. It wasn't fun and there really wasn't any passion. We ordered delivery for dinner and kind of just stared at each other while we ate.
Finally, since it felt awkward, I said, "So, I guess this is it, isn't it?"
She said, "Oh, thank god you said it."
I continued, "Yeah, that didn't feel the same today. Felt forced. Do you agree?"
She said, "I do. This was fun when we were worried. When we were nervous and eager.
You're great but this isn't the same anymore."
I said, "I know. I've felt this way for a couple weeks, what about you?"
She said, "I started to feel this way when I came over a couple weeks ago while (my wife) was away and you took a couple minutes to get hard. That's never happened and I was worried you were starting to lose interest."
I just shook my head in agreement. We continued talking the rest of that night and amicably agreed that we'd tell my wife together that we were ending things.
About two days later, we finally had the chance to tell my wife. I did the talking.
I said, "Hey, since it's just the three of us, I want to let you know that you don't have to worry about Judy and I anymore. We've decided to end this."
My wife said, "I'm happy to hear that but can I ask why?"
I said, "To be honest, it wasn't fun anymore."
My wife shook her head a couple times and then said, "Well, I'm happy to hear this but you guys need to be honest with yourselves and me. If it's over, it better be over. For good. We've all lived with this secret for about a year now. It needs to be over for good if you're telling me it's over."
I looked at Judy, looked at my wife, and said, "We wouldn't have come to you if it weren't."
That was it. It didn't end in some explosive way that damaged lives or reputations. It ended because the passion was gone.
Thanks for reading this series and for all of the comments for each story. I swear this is 100% true and not falsified at all. My MIL is one of the most attractive, sexual women I've ever met and I will never forget any of the times I spent with her. Thankfully, my wife is the most attractive woman I've ever met while also being one of the coolest, most mature, women ever put on this earth. She let me have fun when she could have put me in a financial, personal chokehold.
As those who've read my previous posts know, I had a torrid affair with my ex-mother-in-law for over five years. We ended it when we both realized that we were over it and needed to move on. Not too long after, her daughter and I got a divorce after months of fighting and a realization that we both needed changes. That divorce completely changed what was a positive relationship between Judy and me.
That was to be expected but part of me did feel hurt that she so adamantly decided to hate me in spite of everything she and I had been through together. That divorce was finalized in 2017 and, until a few weeks ago, I hadn't had any contact with any of my ex's family members.
A few weeks ago, during that time in-between Thanksgiving and Christmas, I was driving home from a client meeting, when my phone rang. It was Judy. My gut told me to answer it, but my heart told me to let it go to voicemail. So that's what I did. Surprisingly, a voicemail was left.
It said, "Hey honey, I know it's been a while, but I wanted to talk to you about something. I won't blame you if you don't call me back but I'd love it if you did. Thanks honey."
I called her back, it rang twice, and then a text popped up that said, "I will call you in two minutes. Promise."
She called back, I answered, we awkwardly exchanged pleasantries and then I finally said, "So, what's up?"
She said, "You have a birthday coming up, right?" I replied yes and she continued, "Remember mine is right after yours?" Again, I replied yes, and she said, "I turn seventy this year. It's a big deal."
I said, "Happy birthday! I didn't realize this was the seventieth. wow!"
She said, "That's why I'm calling. I want you. One more time. One night. In a hotel, your house, somewhere. I'll never get the chance again. I can't think of anything else I want. Will you?"
I was shocked by this and stuttered for a second before I said, "That actually sounds really fun. When?"
She said, "Next Wednesday. Peter is travelling. I have the night without any questions."
I said, "Ok, but if we're going to do this, it has to be right."
She said, "What do you mean?"
I said, "You're going to send me all your current sizes. I am going to buy lingerie for you. And, this one is really important to me, you're not allowed to say no to me that night. I won't do anything weird like piss on you (she laughed) but I don't want to be told no."
She said, "Get a pen so I don't have to text you." She then proceeded to tell me her current sizes. "I'm a 34C now, remember when I was a 32B? I'm still a small in panties but, honestly, if you're buying a G-string, get a medium so I'm more comfy."
I said, "Ok, noted, one more thing though."
She said, "What?"
I said, "I want a naked mirror selfie sent to me tonight."
She said, "No, you've seen me naked already and you're going to have me naked for an entire night next week."
I said, "Yes. Tonight. Listen, I won't show anyone the picture. I've never shown anyone the nudes from you, but I want proof that you asked me in case you lie and talk shit about me like you did during my divorce. You actually told people I cheated on Liz! You were telling a version of the truth but it's strange that no one knows who I cheated with. Isn't it?"
She paused and said, "You're right. Look. I want this. Can I send a pic with underwear on?"
"Deal. Tonight though."