After a minute I said, "The ducks are still out there. You and I are still here."
She looked up at me then shifted her gaze to the two ducks billing and cooing on the lake. She said, "They still love each other."
I answered, "We do too."
She moved closer to me, so I could put my arm around her. She almost whispered through her whimpers, "Luke, I know I'm not worth it but please love me and help me with this."
I said, "Listen, Little One, you are worth it. Remember, nothing bad has happened, and I will always love you. Your part of this is over, you have told me the story. Now you can rest. Let your mind shift the burden to me. You have been carrying it too long, alone. I will find the right solution, and we will get through this."
I was still angry and there was still some pain, but my mind was more settled. Rational thought had returned. All I had to do then was sift the data, select the proper solution, make a plan and execute the plan. Problem solved, game over. I will handle this, my confidence rose.
She whispered, "I will always love you." There was a long period of silence, then she said, very quietly, "You promised."
That didn't register. I knew I had heard her right, but I didn't know what she meant. "Promised what?" I asked.
She looked at me through teary eyes, and the little quiver in her lower lip was back. She said, "You promised, if I ever got in a situation like this, you would give me a hall pass."
To use an old aviator's term, my gyros tilted. Mentally, I made no sense of that at all. "I can't even imagine a scenario where I promised you I would let you have sex outside our marriage," I said. "Please help me remember."
Her sniffles disappeared. She had come completely back to the problem at hand. The problem as she saw it was she needed me to condone an illicit tryst with this dickhead she was running with. What I should do is take her into my den, give her a good spanking, tell her no and go kill the dip-shit. That seemed like the best solution so far. I put it at the top of the list.
She was about to argue her point. She'd had a lot of time to think about it. I've argued with her before. She is damn good at it. I'm sure she has a memorized speech already in her head. I should be making notes. I can't let her win this one. If she does I'll have to kill the bastard. That's what I want to do anyway. Maybe I should let her win.
She said, "Remember the night you asked me to marry you?"
I nodded.
She went on, "I told you that I had one serious reservation." The tremor, in her voice told me she was losing it. I had a chance. She said, "I told you it might not be good for me to marry the first man that I ever slept with. Most girls have several lovers, before they choose one to spend their life with. I would wonder what other men were like. We had given each other hall passes, while you were overseas. I did that because I knew you had had several girls older than me, before we started dating. I knew you wouldn't go two years without sex, and I didn't want you to have to cheat. While you were gone I know you nailed every one of those cute little slant eyed girls you could catch. I read about their mores and folk-ways. There were a lot of them, and they were easy to catch.
"I only used mine to date, so I could go to the proms and parties, in the last two years of high school." She continued, "I never had all-the-way sex with anyone else, before you or since."
"Okay Babe," I broke in, "I remember. I told you, I would give you a hall pass if the problem ever came up."
She nodded her head and said, "Yes, you did. You promised."
Her green eyes welled up, and she started pouting. That, of course, is a ploy she has been using since she was four years old. It always worked on her father, her Uncle Gus and me. In her mind it should work now. If this argument was about anything else this is where I would say, "You win Sweet Heart," kiss her on the cheek and write a check. I can't let her win this one.
"Little One," I said, "That was twenty years ago, and we were talking about something that I thought would never come up. In my mind, I thought those were just some words I had to say, to get you to wear my ring.
She answered, "We were talking about a real problem. Something I thought would come up. I had looked at other boys. It was a real problem, and you offered a good solution. It has come up. I want a hall pass, and you promised."
I thought, "I can't believe this shit. Killing the bastard might be the only answer. It's alright that's how I want to handle this anyway." Then I said out loud, "Baby, are you going to hold me to a promise like that?"
It seemed like a long time before she responded. Finally she answered, "No." She paused for a few seconds then said, "but I want a hall pass, and you promised."
She let that sink in then said, "I won't hold you to your promise. If you say no, it will never happen. I will never talk to him again. I could never cheat. If I could it would have already happened."
There was another pause, and she went on, "Before you decide, I have two more reasons that you should give it to me, if you love me."
I thought, "Now she is fighting dirty." I said, "You're fighting dirty now, but go ahead and shoot. I'm listening."
"Both of these things will show you how much and why, I need for this to happen. I'll try not to fight dirty any more, but I reserve the option in case I need it to win."
I thought, "Shit, she didn't have to say that. There is no way she can win. If need be I'll kill her sweet little perfect gentleman, shit-ass friend."
She said, "The first thing. Do you remember my first orgasm last night?"
I nodded and said, "Yes, it seems a lot longer ago than that, but it was the one you wouldn't let me have credit for. You said it was too easy."
She said, "Yes, we called it the easy one. Now listen very closely to what I say. It is very important for you to understand what I am telling you. This is not going to be pleasant for you. I am sorry, but you must know. You said you wanted the whole truth."
I said, "Go ahead, I think I can handle anything now. The things you have already said have been very hard for me to hear."
She went on, "The real reason I couldn't give you credit for the easy one was, because it wasn't yours. It was Ben's. It was heat for him I was carrying in my belly when I got home. It was he, who had made me so wet I had to carry my panties home in a baggie. I know that it was your hand that I was holding against my cunt, your hand that I was humping, your fingers in my G-spot.
"In my mind it was his body, I had my legs wrapped around. It was him I was humping. It was his magnificent cock thrusting through my rough spot. It was Ben who generated that powerful orgasm in me. In my mind, he filled me with his cum. He had such sexual energy. I gave him more pleasure than he had ever had. This all happened in twenty seconds. It made me so very happy when he smiled. I had to have this fun fuck with him. I had to pleasure myself and satiate him. I had to satisfy our animal lust before I could make love with you."
I remained silent.
"Do you think that was bad, Luke? Am I cheating? Is a deep, strong fantasy that satisfies a need a bad thing? Was I lying when I said nothing bad happened?"
I answered her, "No Linda, we all have fantasies. I have fantasies. You have had fantasies before, haven't you?
She said, "Yes, all my life. I had fantasies about you when I was a fourteen-year-old child and all the time you were separated from me. They served a need. I had fantasies of other men many times through the years. Sometimes they were fantasy men, but sometimes they were men I knew. None of them have ever been as powerful as the one I just described to you. I didn't have the words to describe how powerful it really was.
"I need to make my fantasy with Ben real. I am very afraid that you will hate me. If you can't find a way to help me through this, just tell me no. It will never happen behind you. Please don't tell me no, Luke. I need this young man at least once. If I can't have him my curiosity will never be satisfied."
"What the Hell am I going to do?" I thought. I said, "Enough of the fantasy story. I get the picture. What is the other thing you mentioned?"
She said, "Luke, I told you to listen closely. You missed the good part in the fantasy. I know you did, or you would have made a comment about it."
"Linda," I said, "truthfully, the whole thing was hard for me to listen to. I didn't see anything in it that was good. Damn girl, try to see this from my side. The only woman I have ever loved, is fantasizing about fucking another man and asking me to tell her it's all right to do it for real. I am trying hard to hide the pain I feel. I don't think there is anything remotely good about what you just described to me."
A tear escaped the corner of her left eye and ran down her face. She sniffled once and dragged herself back together. She said, "Did you hear me when I told you, that this was just a lustful fun fuck and I had to get it over with, so I could make love with you. You and I have our fun fucks all the time. He and I will never make love."
I didn't say anything.