So, it was all sorted. She would leave the key under a plant pot in the back garden, go about her night as usual, then we would act out her favourite fantasy.
I'd been dating Carrie for nearly two years. We didn't live together, which was probably the reason we still got on so well! That, and the fact I have never had sex with any other woman in the way I have sex with Carrie. From our early nervous beginnings, we have developed into something quite sordid... I took her anal virginity, she discovered she loved to be dominated and I discovered a pussy made for my cock.
We have a very warm relationship, and everything we do sexually comes from the right place. We are very close and have a lot of love for each other. And we seem to discover or try new things on a regular basis. Recently, Carrie has been blindfolded quite a lot - she enjoys the mystery of the whole affair. When I tie her up as well, it drives her over the edge.
As with many couples, we talk alot about fantasies and scenarios, even going as far as testing the water, namely when she kissed a girl at a party in front of me. It may be the most erotic thing I have ever witnessed first hand, or least it was at the time. When Carrie has a few drinks, she changes from a smily, bashful girl to a serious flirt, and she has a look that can be described as naughty and, in the case of the kiss, almost filthy.
Recently, however, we had talked alot about role play, and the idea of her being taken by surprise. Her downstairs bedroom has a double glass door leading out into her garden. We had decided to try it out, with the stage set for a night-time 'surprise' from her lover. That's me!
However, this is where things become - how can I put it? - fucked up.
Carrie is beautiful. I am not bad myself but she could definitely have her pick of men. She has straight brown hair that falls several inches below her neck, is about 5 foot 7 inches tall and has a wonderful, tanned body, with piercing blue eyes. Her breasts are just my type... medium size and very firm, almost tip-tilted. Her pussy has a small whisp of hair and pink, swollen bald lips and clit. And at 25 (I'm 28), her ass is made for spanking.
This was not lost of some of my close friends who, during our regular poker nights, would often make rude comments about her, which was fine as I often did the same about some of their partners. My best friend, Jacob (we call him Jake), has a beautiful blonde girlfriend who is ten years younger than him at 19 and quite simply stunning. She has a full blody with lips that I would give anything to split open with my cock. Anyway, Jake had similar thoughts about Carrie and we had shown each other picture phone snaps of our respective ladies naked.
During sex one night, I told Carrie that I had shown Jake a picture of her naked. At this stage, she was as horny as hell, sitting on top of my hard dick, and she uttered all sorts of obscene sentences, mainly getting off on the thought of Jake pulling his manhood while thinking about her.
So, I decided to put two and two together and, to be honest, probably got five....
I told Jake about our little game of 'intruder', which perked him up significantly. But when I asked him whether or not he would like a secret look, even he was lost for words.
''You are winding me up Matt, aren't you? Go on, fuck off back to your apartment.''
I just stared at him, smiling mischeviously.
''Are you fucking serious?''
Truth is, I wasn't sure.
''If this is some sort of joke, Matt, I don't find it funny, but if you mean it then I'm in.''
After fifteen minutes Jake soon realised this was no prank, although he did ask me five or six more times. We go way back, so the idea of getting up to trouble together was not completely new.
We discussed the ground rules. I figured that, if he was to try to fuck her or stick his dick in her mouth - which I wasn't entirely comfortable with anyway - she would know straight away it wasn't me. Our relationship was intense and we fucked in every position and knew every part of each other so it just couldn't happen. Also, I am eight inches in length and quite thick so I would bet on her realising something was seriously, wrong. So, the plan was that I would tie her up, blindfold her, then he could move to the open bedroom doors and get a proper look at the dirty side of Carrie in action. During our late teens, both Jake and I had fucked girls in rooms in front of each other so this wasn't a problem.
We also agreed that, if things went well, I would leave her tied up and he could take my place, allowing him to grope her ass and tits, and maybe even slip a finger inside her if she was buying the swap. We also agreed that, the next day, I would tell her what happened. If she took it really badly then I could always pretend I was only joking, but we both reached the decision that, if at all possible, she should know what happened. Hopefully, if our pillow talk was not all bullshit, she should get off on it as much as us. Just like when Carrie kissed that girl, I was looking forward to watching her being touched by someone else.
The next morning I went to Carrie's house before heading to work and she was like a cat in heat, knowing what was coming that night. Worked dragged on for what seemed like a lifetime and, by the time I met Jake in a nearby bar, I was going out of my mind. Jake was beaming.
''Can't fucking wait, man. Can't fucking wait.''
Nice greeting, eh?!
We spent a few hours in the bar, allowing night to fall, enjoying several drinks and going over the plan again. I was sure now that this was going to be something special.
Getting into Carrie's back garden is easy, as there is a simple garden gate and the area is in darkness. It was just after ten at night, and I knew she'd be bursting for things to get started. We had a safe word, just in case she got freaked out, but I knew she wouldn't. We had already indulged in some fairly rough sex, including mild choking, spanking and general pushing and pulling - I knew she was going to like this.
As agreed, I put on my hat and pulled a scarf tight around my face. I was wearing a black t-shirt and blue jeans. Only my eyes were showing slightly but she will see enough to know it's her lover and not a real intruder.
I turned the key...
I slipped into her bedroom and, to my surprise, I realised she wasn't there. I decided to wait a few minutes and, just as I began to worry that something was wrong, I heard the bathroom door open and her footsteps growing closer, so I hid behind the door.
A hand immediately pushed her hard towards the bed. Even though she knew what was coming, she hadn't expected me to hide behind the door. She let out a gasp and fell onto the matress, wearing a white t-shirt and tight, white panties, which were already on show as she tried to gather herself from the blow.