At the end of chapter 1, I confessed I was divided in mind about how the tale should end, and asked for comments. Quite a few suggested I leave it as it was, finished in one episode, and I admit to being tempted. But the implication that there would be an ending seemed an obligation. Some said, "take your time," others said, "don't make us wait." The theme suggestions were all over the map, but one captured my imagination. It started, "Please don't have the therapist be some man hating moron..." As you'll see below, that's the one I took to heart.
==============
The marriage counselor looked up from the notes she'd been taking. "So, you'd like my professional opinion about your situation. Do you mind if I develop it through Socratic questions, Mrs. Anderson?" she asked.
"Not if that helps. Call me Lisa."
"Thank you. And I'm Karen if you will. So, Lisa. Why do you want to stay married?"
"What!?"
"The statutes in this State and the judges in this jurisdiction bend over backwards to accommodate long term stay-at-home mothers. You'd get the kids, the house, half the other assets and most of your husband's paycheck for years. Why don't you just put your dilemma behind you in divorce court?"
"What kind of marriage counselor starts by suggesting divorce?" Lisa demanded shrilly.
"These questions are intended to focus
your
thinking, not to reveal
my
thinking. With that in mind, let's take it from the top. Why not just serve your husband Lars with papers?"
"Because I
love
my husband! Haven't I made that clear?"
Karen made an elaborate show of paging back through her notes, as if scanning them for evidence. When she reached the end of the pages, she caught Lisa's eyes with her own and slowly shook her head "no."
Lisa's outrage deflated visibly. "I love my husband. He's my mate, not my meal ticket. I never want to be parted from him," she said, subdued.
"You've given me a lot more disclosure than you've given him lately. If
I
couldn't work that out from what I've heard, isn't there some chance
he's
in doubt?"
"I guess he might well be," Lisa murmured, chastened.
"Does he love you?"
"I never doubted it until this crazy time. Even now, wouldn't it be hard for him to continue to be giving, month after month, if he felt
no
love?"
"What have you done that's unforgivable?"
When the question registered with Lisa, multiple emotions flashed across her face, terror prime among them. Then she noticed Karen's composed face. Slowly, the correct answer dawned on her. "Nothing."
"Clarify, please."
"I took the kid's side in the matter of the promotion. I withheld sex for three weeks. I spent family money on a wild goose chase. These are serious faults, but they're faults the Lars I married could forgive."
"What has your husband done that's unforgivable?"
"Nothing. He seems to be training himself to do without me, and that makes me sad. But if there
was
anything to forgive, I'd do it in a heartbeat."
"If a husband and wife still love each other, and neither has done anything unforgivable, prospects are favorable. Why
didn't
you start with a couple's session with me?"
"The reason I didn't do that yet is that when a wife drags her husband to a marriage counselor, the default assumption is
she
has complaints. His mental narrative could be, 'I'm giving everything and taking nothing, and she
still
has complaints! What does a guy have to do these days?' I wanted to hear your take before I risked that."
"What are some of the ways you used to give to him that he's avoiding?"
"With all modesty, I am a
great
cook; he's got to be missing his favorite recipes. I made sure we had a good social life, and he hasn't made full use of that like he used to. I always strive to choose things
he'd
like, even if they're not
my
favorite." Lisa smiled wanly. "I haven't dragged him to a 'chick flick' in years."
"What are the ways he kept giving to the family so that you didn't diagnose this earlier?"
"All kinds of ways. We went to family events together, we had good date nights, he rubbed my tired feet while listening to me talk, and brought home flowers from time to time. Lots of little stuff, too."
"How cognizant do you suppose he was, doing all this?"
"Beg pardon?"
"To what extent was he following a conscious plan, and to what extent was he following subconscious desires?"
"Um...There had to be some planning. Partially cognizant, I guess you'd say."
"Why did he bother to hide his intention to be less mutually dependent? Wouldn't a more open approach have prompted you to make changes? What advantage does he gain from stealth?"
"To make me hurt more when he walked out?" Sheila's doubt was manifest on her face.
"Doesn't that sound like a lot of work for little benefit?"
Sheila suddenly got Karen's point. "To have an abort switch! To be able to pull the plug on his plan if he changed his mind so that I'd never know."
"What does that make you think you should strive for?"
"My best result will be to get him to decide to use that abort switch."
"You said you considered a 'slow and steady' approach. What are the potential disadvantages with that?"
Lisa thought about it for a bit. "If we hit some shock, my fragile position might totally shatter, even if up until that moment he hadn't wanted to
actually
leave me."
"What are the disadvantages of a 'provoke jealousy' strategy?"
Karen's 'Socratic method' was challenging, but Lisa conceded mentally that it was working. Once again she pondered at length, and Karen waited patiently. "My goal is to make him comfortable taking marital rewards from me as he used to. Showing him evidence that I could easily shift my rewards to someone else would only make him more fearful of depending on an unreliable source," she finally reasoned.
"What are the disadvantages of a 'sexual domination' strategy?"
"It could fail disastrously."
"Think back to the matter of the promotion and put yourself in his shoes. What were his emotions when he conceded your point?"
"Disappointment."
"Mostly disappointment, but also some..."
Lisa's eyes narrowed briefly in thought. After a beat she answered. "Humiliation."
"A teaspoon of humiliation caused him to give up on a twenty year habit of mutual dependence with you. What would happen if you tried to force feed him a bowlful of it?"
"Ka-boom." Lisa pantomimed an explosion with her fingertips. "You've blown up all the ideas I came in here with. Thank you for that. What
do
I do then?"
"What are your assets in this situation?"
"His past is all bound up with me: our friends, our home, our many memories of good years together."
"True. Does his 'don't stop giving' strategy provide a loophole you can use?"
Lisa frowned in thought, then a slow smile crept across her face. "If I ask for something reasonable, he has to give it or risk the revealing of his ruse."
"How can you use that to rebuild your marriage?"
"I could ask for something that also requires him to take something reciprocally."
"In the interest of generating some momentum in your favor, is there anything he's always wanted from you that you've never given?"
Lisa turned bright scarlet. "He...we..." She paused to gain composure. Karen waited with the patience she seemed to have in abundance. Finally Lisa restarted. "I give him oral sex, but I've never let him go all the way. I just couldn't bring myself to do it, and he gave up asking years ago."
"Does he give you oral sex?"
"Oh, yes. He's good at it. It's my favorite part."
"Does he get your vaginal lubrication on his face when he does it?"