Strike one happened on a cool October night our Junior year in college. We were students at UW in Madison, Wisconsin. Fraternities and Sororities dominated the social life on campus and that night was no exception. My frat was having a booze heavy dance/petting session in the basement of the house. I had been on an assignment to help bring in another keg of beer from the cooler and get it set up. By the time I got back to Sara she had been unattended for at least twenty minutes but had been happily chatting with her Theta sisters when I left.
Perhaps I should say a few things about us before getting into the nitty gritty of the story. My name is Jason Edwards. I come from Oak Park Illinois and I was a moderately successful Track and Field athlete and student. Sara is from Evanston Illinois. Her parents are both Northwestern Professors so she has always been comfortable in the Collegiate athletic and scholastic environment.
I first saw her in line before me at Freshman orientation September, two years before. She was 5'4", fresh scrubbed girl next door like features with flaming red hair and the most perfectly proportioned body I had ever seen on an 18 year old. She laughed nicely at my corny jokes and sort of clumsy introduction and we ended up having a coke in the Union and making a date for the next night.
Orientation week was sort of a blur and then it was right into Rush. We both came from Alumni families and were just sort of carried away into our parents legacy Greek Organizations, Sigma Chi and Sorority Delta Gamma. Through the frantic pace of pledging Greek and the start of classes we somehow managed to date half a dozen times and were getting quite cozy. By late Fall we were still at the heavy kissing and roaming hands stage but if there had been just a little more privacy, I felt confident that we would be moving around the bases soon.
With Thanksgiving at hand a few more opportunities were going to present themselves in our Chicago suburban homes. Thanksgiving Day itself was all family, dinner and football but Friday looked promising. We had made a date for that night and I had the directions to her house. I was just about to leave for the date when we got word that my Grandfather had been taken to the hospital and I was asked to come with my folks to check on him. I therefore reluctantly called Sara and told her I had to cancel and why. We set another date for Saturday afternoon and she told me she would be going out Friday night with some High School friends instead of me.
When we got to the hospital we had to wait in the visitors area for an hour before a nurse came out and told us that Gramps had just had a very minor cardiac issue and was only going to be kept for observation over night. The group of us were told to go home as only Grandma and my Dad were going to be allowed in. Now with nothing to do, I headed up to Evanston to surprise Sara. When I rang to doorbell a woman I took to be her mother answered and I introduced myself and asked for Sara. Her mother looked a little puzzled but then said that she was out with her boyfriend..I guess that I looked a little puzzled also because I told her that I thought that I was her boyfriend. The mother shrugged and told me she was sorry and with that I left.
I found a couple of high school friends and we went out, found some underage beer and spent the evening cursing fickle College bitches. The next morning at ten Sara was on the phone sounding really upset. She could explain, its not what it seems, its an ex boyfriend that she was breaking up with, etc etc etc. When I could get a word in edgewise I told her that I would get together with her that afternoon to straighten out this misunderstanding. I also pointed out that we had never said that we were exclusive and that I couldn't expect to hold her to a standard that neither of us had agreed to. Before she could get a word in after that I told her I would pick her up at 1:00 and with that I hung up.
I really liked Sara and had fallen in lust with her but at this point I wasn't sure if it was love. I guess that I was really just very disappointed that she had neglected to mention her boyfriend to me and me to her Mother. I do know that I had told her I was unencumbered and I suppose I had expected her to share her relationships also. Women.
I don't know what I expected when I pulled up in front of her house that afternoon. What I didn't expect was to see her flying through the front door, throwing herself into my arms and kissing me frantically. With tears streaming down her face she cried over and over how sorry she was and how much she loved me. After several minutes of display in front of her family and neighbors, I maneuvered us into my car and we headed out looking for some privacy and waving to the onlookers as we left.
We found a quiet park and pulled in as she started to calm down and began her explanation. The guy she was out with was her old boyfriend by the name of Rob Anders. They had been steadies in HS but she assumed broken up as they left for College. She was surprised when he called on Friday and only went out with him to complete the break up. She had told her mother that she was seeing someone at school but Mom had always liked Rob and was good friends with his parents. That was the reason she had referred to him as "the" boyfriend. She went on and on about how she was falling in love with me and would do whatever it took to repair the damage she had caused.
My answer was simply to lift her chin up and give her a really deep soul kiss. As our tongues tangled our hands began roving a little more freely and shortly all the good stuff was getting attention and my pants were just about to burst open. As we sat there we did just about everything two 18 year olds could do in daylight hours in a public place. When we came up for air she asked.
"Are we OK?"
In answer I just said "I think it's time to advance the baserunner."
The way she moved back into our kiss told me she understood what I was saying perfectly.
That afternoon, in a seedy little Motel 6, the baserunner got in three runs. In our earlier experimentation we had only seen bits and pieces unclothed. Today we had the time to leisurely investigate every nook and cranny. Granted, the first time was a little frenzied as our genitals got to know each other. Despite the frantic pace of our first fuck I managed to get her off with a big orgasm followed immediately by mine. Happily she told me she was on the Pill and so I had the extreme pleasure of coming off inside her for the first time. As I splashed seeming gallons of cum, she squeezed me hard and screamed her pleasure out loud. As I pumped the last of my first emission into her, I grabbed her butt with both hands pressed old faithful fully fully in and yelled right back at her.