It's was nice to hear that you are "hot" but with everything that was discussed, Billy was the last person I wanted to hear that from. Besides, it was too late in the evening for that to be a compliment. I remembered that old joke about how women in bars start to look better as the clock speeds towards closing time and the number of drinks increases. I might be flattering myself, but I always thought that my appearance was probably somewhere between 8 and 9 PM and no more than two drinks. Stiff drinks perhaps, but certainly not more than two.
I went to join the guys and found both of them sitting on the couch talking. I didn't want to sit down next to them so I sat on the chair on the other side of the room while Ray and Billy continued talking about the Chicago Bears. I was just sitting there and not saying much when Billy looked over at me and said, "Hey Beth, I hope I didn't insult you or anything. I guess my idea of watching was kind of stupid. I'm probably not thinking too clearly right now with everything that I'm facing."
I was still a little numb from Ray's suggestion and although I didn't feel angry, I must have been furious at both of them because why else would I have said?
"Well, maybe it really is a guy thing and I just don't understand. But why would you be satisfied with just watching? It seems to me that the real problem is that you are obsessed with this thought of your virginity. Since I'm the only woman here, I guess it's my job to help you out. If it is okay with Ray, you and I could spend the night together in our bedroom. This is all sort of weird, but considering what you will be going through in the weeks ahead, I'll do my part to help you with this. Oh course, it's up to Ray. I don't know if he would want to spend the night sleeping on the couch."
Talk about breaking the ice. Ray tried to appear calm and cool but something must have been stuck in his throat because I could see his Adam's apple going up and down. Billy had better control of his Adam's apple but his eyes got real large and he glanced over at Ray. Both guys were looking at each other with their mouths open. I was sitting there trying not to smirk although I did feel that I was totally in control of the whole messy situation.
Ray turned his head to avoid Billy's stare and looked at me while he asked, "Why would anyone have to sleep on the couch? Our bed is big enough for three."
"Oh Ray, I'm still a blushing bride. You don't expect me to do something as kinky as having a threesome do you? I couldn't do that."
I then looked at Billy and told him, "I hope you are not getting the wrong idea about this. Ray told me how this is bothering you. He said that we have to make you feel better before you go fight over there in Afghanistan. This would be a one time only thing and hopefully we would all keep this as our little secret."
The room got pretty quiet and the three of us just sat there without wanting to look at each other. Billy sat on one end of the couch looking at the rug, Ray was sitting at the other end looking at everything except the rug and I was on the chair with my legs pressed tightly together so that the guys couldn't see them shaking. Regardless of what I said, spending the night with Billy wasn't really something that I wanted to go through with. If Ray would have just stood up and told his brother to forget the whole thing, I would have jumped up and gave him a high five to celebrate our return to normalcy.
But Ray just sat there; looking dazed.
Finally, I stood up and announced that it was a long day and I was going to take a shower to wash some of the day's grime off. "Why don't you guys make a decision and let me know what you want to do. And don't go getting any weird ideas like orgies or watching me put on a live sex show. This is only about helping Billy and his problem and it is only about tonight. Nothing more!"
I went in the bedroom, closed the door and sat on the bed thinking about what just happened. I was really mad at Ray for putting me in that position and since I couldn't think of one plausible explanation he could use to get me to forgive him, I thought that I should probably sit there for a while and try to pull together my emotions.
After a while, I went to the closet to find something to wear. There wasn't a lot of privacy in our small apartment so I found a pair of flannel pajamas and my terry cloth robe and I walked to the bathroom to take my shower. When I finished, I went back into the living room and found Billy and Ray still sitting in the same spot that I left them in.
"Well guys, what did you decide to do? It's getting pretty late and we can't sit up all night. Billy has a flight to catch in the morning."
Billy first looked at Ray and then at me and asked," Did you really mean what you said? You know, about going to bed with me."
"Well yeah, I did. Look Billy, personally I think it is all kind of stupid. You are a young guy and I am sure that you will have plenty of opportunities in the future to get a piece of ass as you so delicately put it. I know that Ray loves you and would do anything for you. If going to bed with you is what it will take to make you feel better, then that is what we'll do. Don't read anything more into it because it's not there."
I should have been feeling sorry for Ray because he was obviously not very comfortable with the conversation. But he was the one who started this and I was still irritated that he put me in the situation we were in. I decided that he was the one who was going to have to get us out of it and I wasn't going to be the naysayer and give him an easy out.
Billy looked over at Ray and said, "This is going to have to be up to you, she is your wife."
Three cheers for Billy! I thought. Poor Ray wanted a naysayer in the worst way and now that the second potential naysayer bowed out, my poor husband had no one left to make a decision for him. I, of course, was feeling no sympathy for him.
"I can't believe this is happening!" Ray looked at me while running his fingers through his hair before asking, "You actually want to fuck my brother?"
"Don't twist things around Ray. This has absolutely nothing to do with what I want. You and him started this whole thing and put me in the middle. What were your exact words? Oh yes, I think they were, 'We really need to do something to help the guy.' This is all about Billy and you, this isn't about me."
I was surprised at how calm my words were because my emotions were just churning inside. And there were all kinds of emotions. There were the scary ones thinking about what all this might do to Ray and me and our relationship together. And then there was Billy. I felt close to him and I really liked him. But being intimate with him was something entirely different. It would change the way we acted around each other for ever. There was also the sex. Up until that point, any experiences I had with sex have always been spontaneous but this was different. There we were sitting in our living room and negotiating about it as if it was some type of business deal.
Sitting there, I also had to admit that I was incredibly turned on. Sitting in a room with two men and not knowing who I'd be sharing our bed with was an erotic thought. Even more erotic was knowing that one of the men was a virgin. I'm still not sure exactly what that had to do with it, but the way my body was reacting left little doubt that I was responding to all of it. My nipples were so hard, they almost hurt. I tightened the robe around me because I was sure that they would be poking out through my PJ's and I didn't want to advertise my hussyness to the two guys.
"Guys, it is really getting late and I'm going to bed. It's your decision who follows me in there. Whoever it is, show me a little respect and make sure you close the door. Don't take too long to decide because I might fall asleep."
I got up, wiggled my fingers "bye-bye" at them and I was going to smile, but the muscles in my face were too tight and I gave them something between a frown and a smirk. I walked in the bedroom and closed the door.
Closing the door to our bedroom made me suddenly feel all alone. No more than just a couple of hours ago, the three of us were sitting in our apartment having a wonderful time. We were laughing at each other's funny stories, reminiscing about past events and gossiping about mutual friends. I'm not much of a beer drinker. Maybe I'll have one during some social event or during a baseball game. But even then, one beer will last me pretty much through an entire evening. But that night, I had several and kept up with the guys. Maybe it was just the beer or maybe it was just the general mood of the evening. But there was some type of bonding going on with us that night and it was almost as if I became one of the guys. I liked that feeling. It was like we were three buddies.
But then something changed. It might have been watching that dumb movie that made their testosterone levels start to increase. I don't have any testosterone and it became pretty clear that although I might have felt like one of the guys, like one of the buddies, they certainly didn't think of me that way. This was only about Ray and Billy. I was only involved because of what I could give them, how they could use me. The "three buddies" idea dissolved pretty quickly once they decided on what they wanted. Billy didn't want to watch his brother making love to me. He wanted to watch me get fucked. Real buddies don't want to watch each other get fucked.
Standing there in the bedroom, I could hear and feel my heart beating. I also felt a pressure in my stomach as if something in my gut was pressing down on my womb. I don't think the idea of having sex with Billy was causing this. I wasn't a virgin when I married Ray. I wasn't even a virgin when I met Ray. Having sex with a man other than Ray wouldn't be something new to me and cause me to feel this way. This was something new, something different from anything that I ever experienced before.
I started wondering about what I should do next. Should I just wait there for one of them to come in the bedroom or should I get in bed? If I got in bed, I thought that I should probably take my robe off but I wasn't sure about my pajamas. I never wear my bra at night but I did have my panties on. Should I take those off also?