I guess, looking back, I could have swallowed my pride on 26th October 2015 - when this whole thing kicked off, and insisted that Susannah's interpretation of what I'd suggested was off limits. But it felt cheap to do that when I had just finally worked up the courage (after months of false starts) to ask her if she would consent to a threesome. She'd looked shocked for a few seconds, and I honestly thought my beautiful wife of just four years - and the pride of my life, was going to slap my face and walk out on me then and there. But she thought for a minute and I allowed myself to think maybe she was considering it. Then came the words that showed me things were never going to be the same.
"Ooooo-kay, honey. But on one condition."
"Sure, anything you say, darling. What is it?" I said (my imagination entertaining thoughts of fucking Susannah and that cute receptionist at the office who'd been flirting with me ever since she'd joined a month ago).
Susannah looked me directly in the eye. "I get to choose him," she said.
There. Bang! Dreams blown. In an instant!
But I found it impossible back out. For a start, Susannah quickly grew wildly keen on the idea, and if I'm honest, our sex during the three or so weeks it took for us to find Steve (the guy who became the third wheel in our eventual threesome) was dynamite. Susannah was always a little wild but this was off the scale. She'd use vulgar language and beg me (in a voice loud enough to leave the neighbors in no doubt as to what was going on in our little part of suburban Scottsdale) to fuck her harder and "PUSH!" and "GRIND THAT DELICIOUS COCK DEEP INTO ME!" and "OH GOD I'M CUMMING!!!!" All the while thrashing around on the bed and exciting me into ever more daring feats of sexual expertise.
Susannah later told me it was the thought of being fucked by two men that really got her juices flowing. It wasn't the permutation I had imagined when I first suggested a threesome, but I was stuck with it. So that's where Steve came in.
I'm Brad. You don't need to know too much about me. I'm 34. I work in marketing at a mid-sized tech company with branches all over the southwest. We're doing well - and expanding internationally, which is relevant to this story in a way. Susannah's six years younger than me and we've been married four years. No kids yet. We wanted to save money first and maybe see whether we both liked Scottsdale since I'm from Fort Worth originally and Susannah's from St Paul. We're alike in some ways and not in others. We both like live ball games and dislike watching it on TV. But she's a diehard Twins fan and I'm a Rangers man through and through. She's a health nut and I like a beer, but we both love coffee. She was for Hillary and I'm Trump to the bone - but she doesn't mind if fuck her once in a while wearing my MAGA hat. I guess you could say we're a case of opposites attract in many respects. But she's my gal and I love her.
Steve was the obvious choice for the threesome in that he was young and fit - and Susannah had fancied him ever since first seeing him at a company barbecue at Squaw Peak in the early summer. More to the point he was a Brit and would be going home in a few months, so there wouldn't be anyone around town who could leer at me with that "I fucked your wife" look that I guess ate away at me whenever I thought of what I'd gotten myself into.
We set a date to spring it on Steve during a dinner that I arranged on the pretext of having several members of the marketing team over to discuss the upcoming trip to Hawaii where we were pitching at a major (for us) international tech fair. In reality, Steve was the only one coming. We'd have dinner, get a few drinks inside us and give Susannah the seeing to that she so clearly desired.
From that point of view It went off smoothly. Susannah made dinner and wore a see-through silk blouse, red lacy bra and matching panties and a skirt so short it must have been obvious to Steve from the get go what the evening was all about. She seduced him all through dinner, stroking his calf with her shoeless feet and winking at him over her wineglass. When, after dessert, I excused myself for five minutes to get a new bottle of wine from the cellar (a pre-arranged signal) I came back to find her sitting on his lap still at the table giving him a deep open mouthed kiss and his hand stroking her panties under her skirt.
He stood up at my entrance and seemed ready to flee but when all I did was smile and pour myself a glass he visibly relaxed. Susannah took his hand and led him to the couch and I undressed her - taking off her blouse and bra while he continued to stroke her pussy through her panties, and then stripping her completely naked for him.
Susannah had planned how she wanted this to go. I was to kiss her on the mouth while he warmed her up below with a good tonguing. Then I would enter her while she took his dick in her mouth. At some point we would change places. She was on the pill and I had hacked into the HR files to see Steve's medical records so we knew he was clean, so that meant she would let him cum inside her if all went to plan.
I guess you could say Susannah had a good night. Steve lapped at her pussy like a thirsty dog while I kissed her mouth hungrily. Pretty soon she was groaning softly to herself and I could see she wanted to swap places and kiss Steve. I moved down but I didn't want to put my lips near where I could still see his saliva all over her now visibly throbbing pussy so I just sat back and watched while Steve and Susannah made out.
Before too long she took his stiff cock in her hand and starting jerking him. He moved deftly between her legs and positioned himself so his glans was probing her wet pussy lips. I got into position too beside her head and she took my cock into her mouth at the same time Steve pushed himself into her. The next three minutes were incredible. I watched my wife being fucked while she sucked me off. It was horrible and fascinating and amazing all at once. I came first. She drank it all down and then she came - and while she was cumming Steve made a moaning sound and started emptying himself into her glistening pussy.
I don't remember too much more of the night because apparently I fell asleep shortly after that. I woke up in our bed but neither Steve nor Susannah were there. I got up, walked groggily into the lounge (it had been mostly me drinking last night's three bottle of wine and I was now paying for it) and found them asleep in each other's arms on the rug by the fireplace. I made coffee and as I did so, I saw Susannah wake up and disappear to the bathroom. Steve slept on and Susannah came to sit down next to me. I pushed a cup of coffee her way and she took it gratefully. We looked at each other and we knew we'd crossed a line - and that neither of us was sorry we had done so.
"Can we do this again?" Susannah eventually asked me.
"With Steve?"
"Yes".
"Sure. If it makes you happy".
* * * A few weeks later Susannah and I were in bed. It was just the two of us. I had had a couple things on my mind and I'd asked her a question I knew she'd been expecting since we started sharing her.
"Oh honey, don't torture yourself," she said. "It's really not important what I'm thinking about when we're together in that way."
"No, but I'd really like to know," I persisted. She sighed.
"Really? Do we have to do this?"
"Indulge me."
"OK, well just now while you were thrusting away I guess the main thought in my mind was should I just pick up a box of Tide at Harris' in the mall or is it worth driving out to Walmart and taking advantage of their current 2 for 1 offer."
"What? That's what you were thinking of while we were fucking?" I said. I was incredulous.